d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > General Help > Site Suggestions >
Poll > League Of Legends Sub-forum Posting Buttons
Prev1678910Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Retired Moderator
Posts: 51,165
Joined: Mar 26 2008
Gold: 0.00
May 15 2015 11:18am
Its still a good suggestion, I find I even create a service and when I go to post I should be creating a topic so I have to redo it :D
If its a site issue overall I feel it should be changed. especially not forums that are not mainly trade orientated

yes
Member
Posts: 90,800
Joined: Sep 23 2009
Gold: 916.13
May 15 2015 11:39am
Quote (Markro @ May 15 2015 10:07am)
it appears that the sorting of the buttons is global (i may be mistaken), but just a quick glance at other games section:

http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=221
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=106
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=238
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=211
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=281
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=154
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=218
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=221
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=260
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=299
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=277
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=40
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=132
http://forums.d2jsp.org/form.php?f=261
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=219
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=213
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=252
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=166
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=92
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=181
http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=222

it seems the hierarchy for buttons within his code is: trade -> service -> pc -> topic -> poll.

if one is missing ie; service, the order remains: trade -> pc -> topic -> poll ( http://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=211 )

this is the case because he uses the "forum.php" file to generate the forum topic listings for each section. this means if he adjusts the button sorting, it will change globally. so the issue is not league forum specific, it is site wide. granted he could do a conditional specifically for the league forum, however that is typically a horrible programming practice and i am positive he will not do that. instead of specifically appealing to the league forum, it sounds like this suggestion should be appealing to the entire site.

tl;dr: what you are suggesting is not league specific, it is a site wide change and will impact every section.

oh also, null'd to see results.


Thank you for the input
This was the reason njag originally told me in PM after i posted this topic, but i feel it should still be changed.
The sub-forum has been around since ~2009-2010(?), and after 5 years, the button was added, so it's hard to break habit and I see people accidentally posting services at least 3 times per day.
But yeah, I see the reasoning behind why it is the way it is.

Quote (Meridyth @ May 15 2015 10:18am)
Its still a good suggestion, I find I even create a service and when I go to post I should be creating a topic so I have to redo it :D
If its a site issue overall I feel it should be changed. especially not forums that are not mainly trade orientated

yes


Yeah, this was basically my reasoning as well.
The sub-forum isn't a "trade" forum, it's always been there for discussion, so discussion should come first & then trading comes after.
If it can't be changed, that's fine, at least I can say that I tried :)
Retired Moderator
Posts: 15,410
Joined: Jun 2 2005
Gold: 9,504.66
Trader: Trusted
May 15 2015 11:49am
Quote (Mikasa @ 15 May 2015 11:39)
Thank you for the input
This was the reason njag originally told me in PM after i posted this topic, but i feel it should still be changed.
The sub-forum has been around since ~2009-2010(?), and after 5 years, the button was added, so it's hard to break habit and I see people accidentally posting services at least 3 times per day.
But yeah, I see the reasoning behind why it is the way it is.


ah okay, figured as much. yes you are correct the league sub-forum is long standing, however, the position of the "new topic" button has not changed (with and without the services button), as illustrated below:



regardless, i do understand your point, the eye goes directly for the far left button for new topics. the point behind my above post was to properly illustrate the problem at hand and identify that a change will only not impact the league forum but the entire community. in the interest of fairness it is reasonable to require the entire community support for this change and not simply one section. with that said, maybe an adjustment and repost of this suggestion is in order. your suggestion, your call.

This post was edited by Markro on May 15 2015 11:59am
Member
Posts: 90,800
Joined: Sep 23 2009
Gold: 916.13
May 15 2015 08:48pm
Quote (Markro @ May 15 2015 10:49am)
ah okay, figured as much. yes you are correct the league sub-forum is long standing, however, the position of the "new topic" button has not changed (with and without the services button), as illustrated below:

http://i.imgur.com/IcNbB8v.png

regardless, i do understand your point, the eye goes directly for the far left button for new topics. the point behind my above post was to properly illustrate the problem at hand and identify that a change will only not impact the league forum but the entire community. in the interest of fairness it is reasonable to require the entire community support for this change and not simply one section. with that said, maybe an adjustment and repost of this suggestion is in order. your suggestion, your call.


That's true.
I'll spend some time over the weekend to write up a new suggestion to pertain to everyone.
If I don't have time, I'll just continue to bump this topic once per day until I have time :)
Member
Posts: 90,800
Joined: Sep 23 2009
Gold: 916.13
May 18 2015 12:24am
Bump
Member
Posts: 90,800
Joined: Sep 23 2009
Gold: 916.13
May 20 2015 06:59pm
Bump
Member
Posts: 90,800
Joined: Sep 23 2009
Gold: 916.13
May 22 2015 10:08am
Bump
Member
Posts: 90,800
Joined: Sep 23 2009
Gold: 916.13
May 25 2015 02:50pm
Bump
Member
Posts: 27,980
Joined: Aug 6 2010
Gold: 20,055.00
May 25 2015 03:42pm
Hope it happens
Member
Posts: 90,800
Joined: Sep 23 2009
Gold: 916.13
May 27 2015 12:41am
Bump
Go Back To Site Suggestions Topic List
Prev1678910Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll