You guys arn't really reading lol..

If you were to donate forum gold to your guild..Who would you send it to? The guild leader right? So he has the power over the forum gold. This would make it no different..Accept the Guild's FG Pot would be public to it's Guild Members.. So..Everyone sees there is 500fg in the Guild Pot.. That fg dissapears.. Nothing was added in Guild Logs.. Where did the fg go?

Well, the Guild Members would defenately ask questions right?..And if answers didn't make sense..Possibly leave that guild.

If you donate gold to your guild now..You actually have less tracking options on what it's used on..The leader could just buy whatever he wants from whoever lol. So in all actuality.. The Guild Bank would make it so leaders would have less options to abuse it.

I guess what I'm saying is..You guys keep posting about how it could be abused.. Well, give an example..I havn't seen one yet to prove your accusations on it being abuseable.

Anybody else?

So the guild buys a guild bank feature,
Members can donate via this feature,
Say your guild acquires 5k fg,

The guild leader can only have the option to do the following


Maybe make it so that the feauture has some kind of limitation so that the leader can't just run off with the money.
Yes I know it's a donation, but the donations should be left to benefit the guild and not the leader.

Maybe leader get's 10% for all the work he does.

Just throwing some different options, I don't see the point in it now, so I am holding my vote: But I can see this going somewhere.

I don't see the point of this, or how it could be made so that it actually works as a useful addition.

*Someone* has access to that bank so sending the fg to him or to that bank makes no difference.
You can always put a fee for new members if you want to buy stuff for the guild.

Yeah just in my experience that is where the confusion came from lol.. I collected the entrance fee's ..but it got mixed with my fg unless I kept note of it. And I would get 5 members who want in..have mixed fg in there for example lol..And I would get confused and simply purchase 10 users spots instead of 5 lol

Not a bad idea but you can do this even without a guild bank feature, if you trust your leader, you can give him fg

Can just support this!

No and i will tell you some reasons:

1. High potential of scams -> also happen in WoW where this system exists
2. You can loan/donate FG to someone if he need
3. The one who put something in should be atleast able to take the same out what he have put in in case it was an accident or he might need it on his own.
4. Gold banks are used to buy things for the Guild in WoW -> on JSP this would be Guild Features ... and everyone could just donate FG to the Guild leader and put "Guild Features" in comment or can get the rights to buy them on his own.
5. The Guild owner goes inactive for some reasons and wont come back because he dont care or forgot about it what then?

But just wanted to share my oppionion and let you know why i voted "no" for this.

This post was edited by Cel on Dec 25 2013 08:42pm

This ^

Quote (Cel @ Dec 25 2013 09:37pm)
No pointless and i will tell you some reasons:

1. This is not WoW
2. High potential of scams -> also happen in WoW
3. You can loan/donate FG to someone if he need
4. The one who put something in should be atleast able to take the same out what he have put in
5. Gold banks are used to buy things for the Guild in WoW -> on JSP this would be Guild Features ... and everyone could just donate FG to the Guild leader and put "Guild Features" in comment or can get the rights to buy them on his own.

Maybe its a great idea and im the only one who dislike this.
But just wanted to share my oppionion and let you know why i voted for this.

Quote

[Expanse] You can trade on other games with people and you can on jsp too, saying "this is not wow" is about the most ignorant and comical thing to say all in one.
I did not say it had to be exactly like WoW.

With the way you're thinking I can see a high potential of scams but if you have a guild full of scammers get them locked/tagged and be done with also your guild can have the option of having it so those who do not want it do not have to use it.

If you're going to donate why would you want to take it back? you can easily use the fg someone donates anyways and not give it back so whats the difference?

If he did want it back for any reason I'm sure a leader would be happy to.

I know in my guild we do not have scum so that is not a issue for ours regardless.

Just to keep this going.