d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > General Help > Site Suggestions >
Poll > Comment Gold Logs Yourself
Prev12345627Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Views: 5870Replies: 260Track Topic
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 16,129
Joined: Mar 14 2010
Gold: 20,410.00
#31
Nov 20 2024 07:18am
Would be super nice. Nothing worse than empty gold logs
Member
Posts: 82,763
Joined: Nov 2 2007
Gold: 107,530.00
#32
Dec 11 2024 11:25am
Quote (eerock @ 20 Nov 2024 12:08)
No.

There is already a suggestion to export gold logs in order to add your own custom comment directly on the export gold logs screen:
https://i.imgur.com/1QE6Hyo.png

If you want to do this you can export your gold logs to excel and add your own comment that way. I can see this potentially causing many headaches in certain moderation instances and don't actually see any additional benefit that using an excel document, google sheet, etc... can't provide.


Good point.
But tbh I don't want to go through all the trouble of exporting stuff instead of simply just adding a line of text to the already existing gold log :lol:

Quote (Gordonn @ 20 Nov 2024 13:54)
not sure I understand


Please elaborate on what you don't understand :lol:

Quote (Luvedocta @ 20 Nov 2024 14:18)
Would be super nice. Nothing worse than empty gold logs


Exactly. I simply hate it :unsure:
Member
Posts: 109,924
Joined: Apr 26 2010
Gold: 6,626.60
#33
Dec 11 2024 12:28pm
Quote (Magisk @ Dec 11 2024 12:25pm)
Good point.
But tbh I don't want to go through all the trouble of exporting stuff instead of simply just adding a line of text to the already existing gold log :lol:

Please elaborate on what you don't understand :lol:



Exactly. I simply hate it :unsure:


so what you want is to add your own comment to a log in which another person sent you Gold?

I guess that makes more sense, however as eerock stated I feel this will just cause headaches from a mediation standpoint trying to track down matching gold logs and the legitimacy of the comments added.


for instance;

if I trade with a user for x amount of ber runes on Monday,

then Tuesday I make a trade with the same user for a griffons, what's stopping that person from just adding the custom comment "griffons" to the prior gold log and claiming they sent gold for the item when in reality they are just relabling a trade from the day before.

now it's cause for additional prerequisite logs to keep track of when things were changed making it harder for site mods to do thier jobs.

just my personal opinion though, good luck!
Member
Posts: 82,763
Joined: Nov 2 2007
Gold: 107,530.00
#34
Dec 11 2024 12:33pm
Quote (Gordonn @ 11 Dec 2024 19:28)
so what you want is to add your own comment to a log in which another person sent you Gold?

I guess that makes more sense, however as eerock stated I feel this will just cause headaches from a mediation standpoint trying to track down matching gold logs and the legitimacy of the comments added.


for instance;

if I trade with a user for x amount of ber runes on Monday,

then Tuesday I make a trade with the same user for a griffons, what's stopping that person from just adding the custom comment "griffons" to the prior gold log and claiming they sent gold for the item when in reality they are just relabling a trade from the day before.

now it's cause for additional prerequisite logs to keep track of when things were changed making it harder for site mods to do thier jobs.

just my personal opinion though, good luck!


if we did a trade of a Shako 141 Def, you left the comment empty, I wouldn't be able to edit yours but add a line next to yours with my own comment in this case would be 'Shako 141 Def'

And of course there would be a maximum of letter like in the original gold logs comment.

And it would have to be a one time thing to make the comment so you can't change it later.
Member
Posts: 109,924
Joined: Apr 26 2010
Gold: 6,626.60
#35
Dec 11 2024 12:36pm
Quote (Magisk @ Dec 11 2024 01:33pm)
if we did a trade of a Shako 141 Def, you left the comment empty, I wouldn't be able to edit yours but add a line next to yours with my own comment in this case would be 'Shako 141 Def'

And of course there would be a maximum of letter like in the original gold logs comment.

And it would have to be a one time thing to make the comment so you can't change it later.


if that was the case you would also have to put a time limit on how long you are able to wait to edit said comment.

much like the time limit on how long you have to edit your post.

if you do not edit within 30 minutes of a trade the option to add comments to that log show disappear

This post was edited by Gordonn on Dec 11 2024 12:36pm
Member
Posts: 82,763
Joined: Nov 2 2007
Gold: 107,530.00
#36
Dec 11 2024 12:48pm
Quote (Gordonn @ 11 Dec 2024 19:36)
if that was the case you would also have to put a time limit on how long you are able to wait to edit said comment.

much like the time limit on how long you have to edit your post.

if you do not edit within 30 minutes of a trade the option to add comments to that log show disappear


That would work for sure. Or just a one time add. Either way would work for me :D
Member
Posts: 40,014
Joined: Feb 24 2007
Gold: 11,605.43
#37
Dec 11 2024 12:51pm
Voted yes, great idea. :thumbsup:
Member
Posts: 82,763
Joined: Nov 2 2007
Gold: 107,530.00
#38
Dec 22 2024 06:44am
Bump
Member
Posts: 71,460
Joined: Jun 17 2007
Gold: 1,040.00
#39
Dec 22 2024 10:43am
Voted yes.
Member
Posts: 48,672
Joined: Jul 5 2008
Gold: 60.00
#40
Dec 22 2024 12:37pm
Easy to implement, but it may require a ton of drive space. If 1,000,000 d2jsp users each stored 64 character long gold log comments, it would require about 6.4gb of space in a .txt file. Multiply that by the total number of gold log comments.

It would be easier to allow a full HTML/CSS/JS export that includes a custom comment box because then you can just open a local file, input your own comments, and look. It is not like custom comments are admissible in the S/A forum.

Quote (eerock @ Nov 20 2024 04:08am)
No.

There is already a suggestion to export gold logs in order to add your own custom comment directly on the export gold logs screen:
https://i.imgur.com/1QE6Hyo.png

If you want to do this you can export your gold logs to excel and add your own comment that way. I can see this potentially causing many headaches in certain moderation instances and don't actually see any additional benefit that using an excel document, google sheet, etc... can't provide.


An export all button would be nice.


This post was edited by Superman on Dec 22 2024 12:44pm
Go Back To Site Suggestions Topic List
Prev12345627Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll

© 2003-2026 d2jsp  Contact