please put it into effect soon paul!

Great Idea Nick,

That would be useful.

Got my vote

Inbetween, but mostly yes.
Ok all is fine and we assume no scam is going to happen.
But what if the owner decides to sell the guild ?
1st he has to make sure all persons who still have fg in the bank must withdraw it, else he should not be allowed to sell it.
Therefore guild gold log should be either visible to Paul himself or to the public. ( since there's nothing to hide why u send fg to your guild forum bank.)
Small addition :
You cannot withdraw more than you have deposited
OR
any user except the owner can withdraw 90% or less of the fg he has sent to the guild forum bank..limited time only.
Reason : let's say u send 1st day 50 fg or more to enter guild.After a couple of months u decide to take back the 50 fg or more that u have deposited there for various reason...which is obviously stupid.

About paying to Paul for this : it's enough to get a tax when u create the guild, not to pay a % of each transaction to Paul, which would cause alot of small fg adds to him, making it harder to see his own gold logs when searching for an exact transaction.
And when ownership CAN change, the new guild leader has to pay 25-50% of what cost to create the bank itself, which would also mean clearing up the guild forum gold log.

I personally am guildless, but i care for those with guilds.

This post was edited by Alexandru on Feb 15 2008 12:40am

Vouch.

I think the way Nick laid it out is that only the guild owner and those the guild owner designates can withdraw fg from the guild bank.

edit: as for the other stuff you said. I think the consensus has been to have it be a one time fee to get the guild bank (like purchasing a charter).

As for selling the guild, I think the consensus has been that the members who donate have decided to trust their guild leader with the fg, so they should be able to handle things properly upon leaving.

This post was edited by DoomOnYou on Feb 15 2008 12:49am

nothing else to say but
+1

yes

Quote (Alexandru @ Fri, Feb 15 2008, 01:39am)

Inbetween, but mostly yes.
Ok all is fine and we assume no scam is going to happen.
But what if the owner decides to sell the guild ?
1st he has to make sure all persons who still have fg in the bank must withdraw it, else he should not be allowed to sell it.
Therefore guild gold log should be either visible to Paul himself or to the public. ( since there's nothing to hide why u send fg to your guild forum bank.)
Small addition :
You cannot withdraw more than you have deposited
OR
any user except the owner can withdraw 90% or less of the fg he has sent to the guild forum bank..limited time only.
Reason  : let's say u send 1st day 50 fg or more to enter guild.After a couple of months u decide to take back the 50 fg or more that u have deposited there for various reason...which is obviously stupid.

About paying to Paul for this  : it's enough to get a tax when u create the guild, not to pay a % of each transaction to Paul, which would cause alot of small fg adds to him, making it harder to see his own gold logs when searching for an exact transaction.
And when ownership CAN change, the new guild leader has to pay 25-50% of what cost to create the bank itself, which would also mean clearing up the guild forum gold log.

I personally am guildless, but i care for those with guilds.

Well the bank would be a part of the guild, so selling the guild would mean there would be fg in the bank, so he'd either have to remove it all himself and keep it, or redistribute it

also, we dont need a small tax or per withdrawal, a simply purchase of the bank would be sufficient

and random members cannot withdraw from bank, its uses would be for higher ups only, it would be for events such as guild raffles, tournaments, or even just funds contributed to expand the guild

First good guild suggestion I've read in a while.

--I think it would a good idea to add a ranked withdraw amount.
Like 3rd highest ranks can withdraw 250fg per time, unless the guild owner authorizes a higher one.

This post was edited by Morholt on Feb 15 2008 05:29pm

Well yes from me, and if you want to avoid scamming put it so that only admin can take fg out from the bank but everyone can put in?
then if someones needs the fg just simply ask the guild leader?

yes from me would be superhot actually!