Hmmm... Mostly behind it but 1 part that seems kind of sketchy..

How you have it set up (And correct me if I'm wrong) That guild leader(s) control who can and can't withdraw items... Right?

Well any way you look at it, that puts the guild leader in complete control. I see the real easy scam already... Guild leader makes guild, buys the bank... Recruits tons of people, has it active for a little while, then cuts off everyone else's use to it... Or has someone else steal it all out, multi possibly, then gradually send him the FG before lock takes place.

Why not have something where you can't withdraw until you put in, and a certain ratio of such? For example...

Guild X's Forum Bank = 100k fg.
Member A hasn't donated.
Member A donates 100 fg.
Member A may now withdraw up to 125 Forum Gold.

Perhaps set up a cap system on this? And a "reserve" from the bank, where it can't fall below a certain point without approval from xx% of the members in the guild?

This way, members that haven't contributed won't be able to access it...

Ofc more could be elaborated upon the approval from xx% of the guild, so that noone can scam, and have that on a weighted scale put to rank?

Idk... You say that yeah, people CAN rob it, but they won't get away with it... Well, look around the forums... Scammers get locked every day, but that doesn't stop them. A gold log would only get that user Scammer tagged, it wouldn't get the FG back.

Needs alot more refining done to it, still too many loop holes...

This post was edited by dragonkilla8 on Dec 28 2007 12:19am

I like it but i think leaders should be able to limit withdrawls by amount.

i rly love this idea

i'm english mate

you just dont see the meaning yes its a good idiea but dont matter how much you trust your guild or onwer

i have seen people including owners scam other in the guild

some have bin joined they for a ong period of time so you wouldnt ashume they would have done this.

now when you have finished translating this and then retyping your reply ... then learn from differnt people who live on other sides of the world we talk differnt english where im from to you ..but it all the same if you can read

Yes, why not.

nice idea , voted yes