Guild Forum Bank, V2 - Topic

Rapture

Member

Posts: 66,644

Joined: Oct 8 2005

Gold: 7,830.00

#1101

Apr 20 2010 12:38pm

nudge

Member

Posts: 15,110

Joined: Aug 25 2003

Gold: 29,603.00

Warn: 10%

#1102

Apr 20 2010 01:05pm

I don't think so, I mean
What if a user scams another user and then send it to the guild bank and then he pick the forum gold up with one of his multi accounts? Or maybe any of his friends will pick it up for him? This system would be used by scammers alot.
it's an easy way to launder forum gold and make them look clean through a system like this.
for example in the donor forum there is a section where you can buy in real life things for forum gold.. But you cannot buy things there if you have sold unperm items..
So what if someone sells unperm and add it to the guild bank and then his friends withdraw them?

There are so many reasons that i can think of why this feuture should not be added...

Anyway i voted yes because i know this will not be added..
It sounds more like a scammer system to me

People would even use this system when they are selling forum gold to each others aswell wich is against the rules..
Wich means if a guild owner is selling forum gold he would just tell the buyer to join his guild and he send the forum gold to the bank and then the buyer picks it up. then he just leave the guild..

-Best regards

This post was edited by kiss on Apr 20 2010 01:19pm

Rapture

Member

Posts: 66,644

Joined: Oct 8 2005

Gold: 7,830.00

#1103

Apr 22 2010 09:01am

Quote (kiss @ Apr 20 2010 03:05pm)
I don't think so, I mean
What if a user scams another user and then send it to the guild bank and then he pick the forum gold up with one of his multi accounts? Or maybe any of his friends will pick it up for him? This system would be used by scammers alot.
it's an easy way to launder forum gold and make them look clean through a system like this.
for example in the donor forum there is a section where you can buy in real life things for forum gold.. But you cannot buy things there if you have sold unperm items..
So what if someone sells unperm and add it to the guild bank and then his friends withdraw them?

There are so many reasons that i can think of why this feuture should not be added...

Anyway i voted yes because i know this will not be added..
It sounds more like a scammer system to me

People would even use this system when they are selling forum gold to each others aswell wich is against the rules..
Wich means if a guild owner is selling forum gold he would just tell the buyer to join his guild and he send the forum gold to the bank and then the buyer picks it up. then he just leave the guild..

-Best regards

Deposited Scammer fg, will still just be taken away by njaguar [if he cares, he doesnt seem to always take back scammed spent fg i cant say i entirely know the deal with scammed fg.]
using the guild bank as a mediator for the transfer of the multi just makes it easier to catch. Plus you have to consider the fact that there would need to be an approval by the leader first [whether or not this feature would be mandatory or optional is still in the air ofc]
which depending on the leader and the multi, may or may not make it past the leader.
you figure, you have to trust the multi to take it out to begin with, not like every random eprson gets access to these features.

Then the unperm thing, i think is also noticable by moderators.
what if someone does go get 12k fg. then someone withdraws 12k fg?
pretty sure Lajo is capable of making a simple connection, and do not feel this would fall through.

None of your reasons really seem to be that problematic, nor even much of a significant threat.

Rapture

Member

Posts: 66,644

Joined: Oct 8 2005

Gold: 7,830.00

#1104

Apr 24 2010 06:52am

Rapture

Member

Posts: 66,644

Joined: Oct 8 2005

Gold: 7,830.00

#1105

Apr 26 2010 09:33am

tjapp

Banned

Posts: 794

Joined: Aug 25 2005

Gold: 8,000.40

Warn: 10%

#1106

Apr 26 2010 11:00am

this function will be so abused by guild leaders

i can imagine, "it cost 100fg deposit to guild bank to join this guild, you'll have a chance to withdraw it + even more later blablabla" invite 100 members, guild owner takes the win and /bye

Rapture

Member

Posts: 66,644

Joined: Oct 8 2005

Gold: 7,830.00

#1107

Apr 28 2010 03:52am

Quote (tjapp @ Apr 26 2010 01:00pm)
this function will be so abused by guild leaders

i can imagine, "it cost 100fg deposit to guild bank to join this guild, you'll have a chance to withdraw it + even more later blablabla" invite 100 members, guild owner takes the win and /bye

This already happens, difference being they add it to their pocket directly.
entry fee, is the same thing.

The bank would allow also for an option to have a fee payable to the bank, as in, you could set it up, to automatically accept anyone who pays.

This post was edited by djinni on Apr 28 2010 03:53am

Rapture

Member

Posts: 66,644

Joined: Oct 8 2005

Gold: 7,830.00

#1108

Apr 29 2010 03:34pm

Rapture

Member

Posts: 66,644

Joined: Oct 8 2005

Gold: 7,830.00