d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > General Help > Site Suggestions >
Poll > Forum Gold - In & Out Information.
Prev123Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 8,545
Joined: Oct 4 2021
Gold: 281.64
Oct 11 2021 09:31pm
How does volume in/out indicate a trust score?
Member
Posts: 27,224
Joined: Nov 18 2013
Gold: 10,575.00
Oct 11 2021 11:58pm
How much fg comes and goes from my account is nobody's business but my own unless I end up in a Scammer Accusation thread (which I will not)

Voted no.

Quote (Cascadian @ Oct 11 2021 08:31pm)
How does volume in/out indicate a trust score?


It doesn't.

This post was edited by Vilify on Oct 11 2021 11:59pm
Member
Posts: 25,596
Joined: Jan 10 2009
Gold: 5,337.00
Oct 12 2021 06:29am
Voted no. I don't see how this helps anything. There are always going to be issues about who should go first and that's just up to the users to decide between themselves. If this is the difference between someone going first or not, you could offer to show them your gold log. I doubt that is very common though. No need for our in/out to be displayed for all to see at all times. It would just lead to people using a "3/4 rule" instead of a "2/3" rule anyway

This post was edited by Greeley on Oct 12 2021 06:30am
Member
Posts: 545
Joined: Jun 23 2021
Gold: 8,822.00
Oct 12 2021 06:41am
Quote (Greeley @ Oct 12 2021 02:29pm)
Voted no. I don't see how this helps anything. There are always going to be issues about who should go first and that's just up to the users to decide between themselves. If this is the difference between someone going first or not, you could offer to show them your gold log. I doubt that is very common though. No need for our in/out to be displayed for all to see at all times. It would just lead to people using a "3/4 rule" instead of a "2/3" rule anyway


What's 3/4 rule if you don't mind me asking?

EDIT: NVM, i'm dumb

This post was edited by hyasei on Oct 12 2021 06:42am
Member
Posts: 25,596
Joined: Jan 10 2009
Gold: 5,337.00
Oct 12 2021 06:43am
Quote (hyasei @ Oct 12 2021 08:41am)
What's 3/4 rule if you don't mind me asking?


Something that is fairly common with traders is "following the 2/3 rule" which means that they will only give first if the other user has at least two of three of the following:

More FG
More posts
Earlier join date

What I'm saying is that this "Gold In/Out", if it were a thing, people would probably just say "I follow the 3/4 rule" meaning that the other trader must have 3 of 4 of the following:

More FG
More FG In/Out
More posts
Earlier join date
Member
Posts: 545
Joined: Jun 23 2021
Gold: 8,822.00
Oct 12 2021 07:21am
Just had a thought - this would be a nice idea if it was toggleable by user - for example, do I want people to see my FG in/out/volume or number of transactions.

The only downside to this is that some people might not be willing to trade with people who do not share this kind of information, but if they do then they might seem to be more trustworthy
Member
Posts: 86,020
Joined: Mar 18 2003
Gold: 2,893.38
Oct 12 2021 07:29am
This will not stop people from scamming


There are no rules as to who has to give first
Member
Posts: 6,476
Joined: Apr 11 2007
Gold: 13,960.00
Oct 18 2021 03:41pm
Sorry voted no, Main problem I see would be Multis/Scammers could easily just send FG back and forth to each other to make themselves look trustworthy before attempting to scam.

It would be giving people who believe that more fg in/out a false sense of security, which would make them easier to scam.

This post was edited by SirGivret on Oct 18 2021 03:41pm
Retired Moderator
Posts: 124,186
Joined: Mar 11 2006
Gold: 130,766.00
Trader: Trusted
Oct 18 2021 03:48pm
Voted no because there is a free Mediator service ;)
Member
Posts: 5,048
Joined: Feb 20 2009
Gold: 35,210.01
Oct 18 2021 03:49pm
Yeah I dropped the idea too, I have a much better solution I'm working on that I'm sure will see a 99%+ Yes ratio, although it would require some coding.

Any ways I can close my own thread?
Go Back To Site Suggestions Topic List
Prev123Next
Closed New Topic New Poll