d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > General Help > Site Suggestions >
Poll > Block User From Their Profile
Prev1234Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 39,157
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 9,070.07
Jun 19 2021 03:02pm
Voted yes, would be a solid quality of life addition.
Member
Posts: 17,273
Joined: Jul 29 2010
Gold: 10,709.66
Warn: 70%
Jun 19 2021 03:04pm
Voted No. Numerous Reasons.

I will try to keep it simple.

To be at Heart with it, if you need to block someone then a good or close first step would be not looking at their profile.

Also why do you feel this needs to be implemented on our site? As a dedicated member here I feel kind of confused. You are currently Staff. I feel much safer knowing I can pm staff at any time over the reasons they wish to Staff for. I certainly don't have anyone blocked, and if I do I would not wish for it long term while wanted to be here and helpful for so many other different individuals. While you suggest this I also have a concern that it could lead to poor performance of some staff because they may decide to block someone for the wrong reasons while having such access and standalone blocking feature. Meanwhile it could also lead to increased amount of work load for staff because more members are prone to blocking someone and it could be strictly biased off a profile view, while the other member that has been blocked may have absolutely no clue what is going on and more.
Member
Posts: 9,011
Joined: Jan 10 2010
Gold: 1,005.99
Trader: Trusted
Jun 19 2021 03:51pm
Voted yes. Great idea friend.
Member
Posts: 11,679
Joined: Feb 3 2009
Gold: 226.69
Jun 19 2021 03:53pm
Quote (Sempervirens @ Jun 19 2021 05:04pm)
Voted No. Numerous Reasons.

I will try to keep it simple.

To be at Heart with it, if you need to block someone then a good or close first step would be not looking at their profile.

Also why do you feel this needs to be implemented on our site? As a dedicated member here I feel kind of confused. You are currently Staff. I feel much safer knowing I can pm staff at any time over the reasons they wish to Staff for. I certainly don't have anyone blocked, and if I do I would not wish for it long term while wanted to be here and helpful for so many other different individuals. While you suggest this I also have a concern that it could lead to poor performance of some staff because they may decide to block someone for the wrong reasons while having such access and standalone blocking feature. Meanwhile it could also lead to increased amount of work load for staff because more members are prone to blocking someone and it could be strictly biased off a profile view, while the other member that has been blocked may have absolutely no clue what is going on and more.


This is a valid concern staff being able to block people would be a transparency issue.
Member
Posts: 39,157
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 9,070.07
Jun 19 2021 03:57pm
Quote (Xanhast @ Jun 19 2021 05:53pm)
This is a valid concern staff being able to block people would be a transparency issue.


Each category of staff has more than one member so you can always revert to PMing a secondary or third member of the same staff category.
Member
Posts: 33,358
Joined: Dec 20 2007
Gold: 11,245.00
Jun 19 2021 03:58pm
Yes.
Member
Posts: 28,349
Joined: Mar 13 2006
Gold: 450.00
Trader: Trusted
Jun 19 2021 03:59pm
Quote (Xanhast @ Jun 19 2021 02:53pm)
This is a valid concern staff being able to block people would be a transparency issue.


Staff is already able to block people, this site suggestion is just a way to make it easier for all users to block someone.
With most websites, if you want to block someone you can usually find this option by clicking on them or their profile and finding the option.

Currently on this website you have to open your PMs, locate the Block List, and manually type their name to add them to your list. This is simply a way to make it a 3 click process without having to type anything. Open profile, block this user, confirm.
Member
Posts: 5,561
Joined: Aug 22 2017
Gold: 21,591.95
Jun 19 2021 04:07pm
I was actually looking for that yesterday, i thought it was already implemented.
Drastically undercutting the market always makes enemies and i was getting dms/spams in my threads from a few particular members on the east hc community.

All i could do was block dm's but i still can see their posts.

Voted yes.
Retired Moderator
Posts: 32,585
Joined: Sep 1 2007
Gold: 0.00
Trader: Trusted
Jun 19 2021 04:14pm
Quote (Sempervirens @ Jun 19 2021 05:04pm)
Voted No. Numerous Reasons.

I will try to keep it simple.

To be at Heart with it, if you need to block someone then a good or close first step would be not looking at their profile.

Also why do you feel this needs to be implemented on our site? As a dedicated member here I feel kind of confused. You are currently Staff. I feel much safer knowing I can pm staff at any time over the reasons they wish to Staff for. I certainly don't have anyone blocked, and if I do I would not wish for it long term while wanted to be here and helpful for so many other different individuals. While you suggest this I also have a concern that it could lead to poor performance of some staff because they may decide to block someone for the wrong reasons while having such access and standalone blocking feature. Meanwhile it could also lead to increased amount of work load for staff because more members are prone to blocking someone and it could be strictly biased off a profile view, while the other member that has been blocked may have absolutely no clue what is going on and more.


You forget that staff members are people too. If a staff member is continuously harassed... with the conversations going absolutely nowhere - then they have the right to block (just like everyone else). Obviously, there are a lot of other contributing factors, and is a last resort. Also, this wouldn't increase the workload. If someone wants to block randomly (or intentionally), then that is on them.. and essentially *decreases* the traffic; the blocked user wouldn't be aware of it. Staff will never force anyone to unblock somebody, even if the blocked user doesn't know why.

If you don't wish to permanently block, then that's great - but it's a personal privilege (for everyone) to decide why and for how long. If someone blocks you willy-nilly for no reason, then maybe it was for the best, and they've saved you the trouble. If someone has you blocked because of interactions you've had - then that might be a sign to reflect on the situation, regardless if that member is staff or not.

As for the suggestion itself, I don't see any problems with it - as long as there is a confirmation prompt.
Retired Moderator
Posts: 18,493
Joined: Feb 7 2009
Gold: 167,190.00
Trader: Mediator
Jun 19 2021 05:06pm
I personally supported the extended blocking system in the past:
https://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=69539091&f=258

But the more I think about it I see one issue with blocking profiles.
What if you trade with someone get scammed and the user is blocking you from viewing his profile? It's not necessarily needed to have a look into his profile. But something that could be abused. And could be extremely confusing for new users.
That means only a certain amount of content in the profile can be generally blocked e. g. the "Notes" ... the entire User Stats // Send Private Message // Recent Posts & Topics should be all still visible imo.
And then is the question is this function still worth it if you can't generally block the entire profile?

This post was edited by Cel on Jun 19 2021 05:09pm
Go Back To Site Suggestions Topic List
Prev1234Next
Closed New Topic New Poll