Voted no, just pm someone to reapply if they got accidently rejected.

It just seems unnecessary to begin with. It would also take someone with the ability to View Guild Logs in order to see what happened.

This post was edited by Sempervirens on Mar 7 2021 01:16am

The same people who can view guild logs can most likely approve and disapprove members. If they can't, then they shouldn't have either privilege.

Guild Logs provide a different experience than being able to accept a potential Guildmate.

This post was edited by Sempervirens on Mar 7 2021 01:54am

Exactly this.

Bump

Seems like you want people to be able to accept but not reject right? Couldn’t they just click the request to join button again if they’re accidentally rejected?

They can but thats not what he's suggesting.
He want to have another option, call it user permission in the guild for either only Reject / only Accept or both ( Reject & Accept ).

I think when managing large guilds this is something you would like to have.


if thats what aiming for, its a yes from me.

Yep that is it. I want to say this would be good for all Guilds.

Guilds have Ranks. This suggestion could be a way to Rank up from a variety of opportunities and could give users a better experience doing something they enjoy doing.

I vote no.
Simply because of what has already been stated.
Don’t give permissions to people who shouldn’t be denying or accepting.
Even if it’s an accident. The person joining the guild should just pm the leader and ask why they didn’t get accepted. Whoops was accident please apply again ETC.

I would also trust my co GM’s to make the right decision. And if accident super easy fix.