User Reviews/ratings - Topic

kingmaker

Member

Posts: 7,171

Joined: Mar 31 2016

Gold: 69,820.74

#11

Jan 20 2019 07:59pm

Quote (bipolargod @ Jan 20 2019 08:59pm)

I'm thinking 1 bad review with 5 good reviews will still drop your average rating well below 5

I am talking about ratings over months and you are talking about ratings in 5 hours

This post was edited by kingmaker on Jan 20 2019 07:59pm

Selet

Member

Posts: 11,489

Joined: Jul 6 2008

Gold: 30,360.69

Trader: Trusted

#12

Jan 20 2019 08:02pm

Gotta vote no to be honest. Kinda doesn't have a point. 99% of scams come out of nowhere after months of proper trades being done. And anyone that gives first to an account made a few days ago needs their head checked.

Would only help new users gain credibility faster that they can exploit to cause scams. If you are active in your realms trading thread, you will gain credibility over time.

Just my opinion ^_^

Mastermule

Member

Posts: 27,353

Joined: Mar 26 2007

Gold: 0.53

#13

Jan 20 2019 08:02pm

So you think it won't happen? Are rating going to be hidden for 3 months and then be shown?

Also scammers will manipulate their rating with multis

kingmaker

Member

Posts: 7,171

Joined: Mar 31 2016

Gold: 69,820.74

#14

Jan 20 2019 08:05pm

Quote (Selet @ Jan 20 2019 09:02pm)

This makes sense.

Quote (bipolargod @ Jan 20 2019 09:02pm)

So you think it won't happen? Are rating going to be hidden for 3 months and then be shown?

Also scammers will manipulate their rating with multis

Did you read my reply on how we can fix multi abusing?

Mastermule

Member

Posts: 27,353

Joined: Mar 26 2007

Gold: 0.53

#15

Jan 20 2019 08:10pm

How do you stop a scamming multi from giving good rating to one account from 20 other unique accounts? I must have missed it

kingmaker

Member

Posts: 7,171

Joined: Mar 31 2016

Gold: 69,820.74

#16

Jan 20 2019 08:18pm

Quote (bipolargod @ Jan 20 2019 09:10pm)

How do you stop a scamming multi from giving good rating to one account from 20 other unique accounts? I must have missed it

Only one review for a user per X months
User can submit a review only after X months of Y level of activity

Compared to around minimum 400 reviews in last 6 months 20 wont make a big difference.
Users need minimum of XX posts and needs to be at least Y months old to submit a review.
Multis are not going to have activity on every one of the 20 accounts

This post was edited by kingmaker on Jan 20 2019 08:18pm

Mastermule

Member

Posts: 27,353

Joined: Mar 26 2007

Gold: 0.53

#17

Jan 20 2019 08:21pm

Eh we disagree. I think you are being naive.. Peoples dedication can be amazing

SMNAC

Member

Posts: 104,473

Joined: Jun 22 2007

Gold: 0.00

#18

Jan 20 2019 10:23pm

sadly too many trolls exist now a days for this to make any positive impact on the site

voted no sorry

Penguins0690

Member

Posts: 73,507

Joined: Aug 14 2007

Gold: 1,940.52

#19

Jan 20 2019 10:53pm

We already have this.
2/3 rule

kingmaker

Member

Posts: 7,171

Joined: Mar 31 2016

Gold: 69,820.74

#20

Jan 20 2019 10:57pm

Quote (Lpot @ Jan 20 2019 11:23pm)

sadly too many trolls exist now a days for this to make any positive impact on the site

voted no sorry :(

np. I get it.

Quote (Penguins0690 @ Jan 20 2019 11:53pm)

We already have this.
2/3 rule

This request is not about who goes first. But about if you get the trade at all in the first place. I offered a service for 150fg. Same was offered for 300fg by a 2008 user and buyer went with 2008 user

Go Back To Site Suggestions Topic List