d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > General Help > Site Suggestions >
Poll > A Guild Subforum
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Retired Moderator
Posts: 14,105
Joined: Sep 28 2021
Gold: 1.00
Trader: Trusted
Oct 18 2022 10:11pm
A guild subforum would be great where people can post their recruitments or LFGs and guild transfers, tags can also be added akin to some of our trading subforums where people can categorize their guilds such as #D2R, #PVE, #PVP, #CS:GO etc...

Share your thoughts! :thumbsup:

This post was edited by Lionhearted on Oct 18 2022 10:12pm
Member
Posts: 25,049
Joined: Apr 22 2022
Gold: 1,100.03
Oct 18 2022 10:48pm
I think it would be easier to recruit new members this way. And just in general find like minded guilds, to play with. “Brother hood” . I like the idea buddy. Voted yes.
Member
Posts: 14,611
Joined: Dec 26 2006
Gold: 174.67
Oct 18 2022 11:42pm
https://forums.d2jsp.org/guild.php?a=17

before guild topics were a thing there was this sub forums

guild topics are still the proper place for guild recruitment go to general chat then look at the sub forum and description

being able to search the guilds based on what games they focus on sounds great
but at the same time can see this getting quite cluttered and very outdated(some whole guilds havnt been on over a year)


Retired Moderator
Posts: 14,105
Joined: Sep 28 2021
Gold: 1.00
Trader: Trusted
Oct 19 2022 12:39am
Quote (NerdLord @ Oct 19 2022 01:42pm)
https://forums.d2jsp.org/guild.php?a=17

before guild topics were a thing there was this sub forums

guild topics are still the proper place for guild recruitment go to general chat then look at the sub forum and description

being able to search the guilds based on what games they focus on sounds great
but at the same time can see this getting quite cluttered and very outdated(some whole guilds havnt been on over a year)


Yep I know of this, but this is more of a "bulletin board" for individual guilds instead of an actual full-fledged subforum, if we're able to to have an actual subforum for guilds with tags to properly categorize and manage topics then I'd assume it'd function better than that.
Member
Posts: 14,611
Joined: Dec 26 2006
Gold: 174.67
Oct 19 2022 12:42am
Quote (Lionhearted @ 19 Oct 2022 02:39)
Yep I know of this, but this is more of a "bulletin board" for individual guilds instead of an actual full-fledged subforum, if we're able to to have an actual subforum for guilds with tags to properly categorize and manage topics then I'd assume it'd function better than that.


The topics came in a update and replaced the recruitment subforum
So it be more reverting or bringing back that forum
But the tags part is original
Sorry if that doesn't make sense lol
Retired Moderator
Posts: 14,105
Joined: Sep 28 2021
Gold: 1.00
Trader: Trusted
Oct 19 2022 12:45am
Quote (NerdLord @ Oct 19 2022 02:42pm)
The topics came in a update and replaced the recruitment subforum
So it be more reverting or bringing back that forum
But the tags part is original
Sorry if that doesn't make sense lol


Yeah I can totally make sense of that, imo is that the current state doesn't function as well as an actual subforum since it's less "exposed" and doesn't garner as much popularity and exposure.

It's still very awkard for user to hunt for a guild and sell/transfer/buy guilds.

This post was edited by Lionhearted on Oct 19 2022 12:50am
Member
Posts: 14,611
Joined: Dec 26 2006
Gold: 174.67
Oct 19 2022 12:50am
Quote (Lionhearted @ 19 Oct 2022 02:45)
Yeah I can totally make sense of that, imo is that the current state doesn't function as well as an actual subforum since it's less "exposed" and doesn't garner as much popularity and exposure.


I think moving it from within general chat to the top forum with df general help etc. Would give it much better visibility and probably gather more attention,it's definitely hidden away with the way it is
Retired Moderator
Posts: 14,105
Joined: Sep 28 2021
Gold: 1.00
Trader: Trusted
Oct 19 2022 12:53am
Quote (NerdLord @ Oct 19 2022 02:50pm)
I think moving it from within general chat to the top forum with df general help etc. Would give it much better visibility and probably gather more attention,it's definitely hidden away with the way it is


Yeah it's pretty tucked away atm.
Retired Moderator
Posts: 6,660
Joined: Oct 3 2021
Gold: 61,913.30
Trader: Trusted
Oct 19 2022 01:02am
A lovely idea.

Could potentially bring a bit more interest to the participating guilds and help with recruitment :)
Member
Posts: 8,809
Joined: Oct 16 2006
Gold: 10.00
Oct 19 2022 01:57am
Quote (Lionhearted @ 19 Oct 2022 08:53)
Yeah it's pretty tucked away atm.


Where would you like the subforum to be added? If you want tags for games other than Ladderslasher (which has such a subforum) then the "d2jsp" section of the forum might not be the most suitable place for it. Given that other games start at their own sections beneath the d2jsp one.

The idea itself is not unappealing, but whether it has a potential to be successful depends on where the forum is located.
Go Back To Site Suggestions Topic List
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll