So in a sense you would be creating a sort of a list members++ as a new form of Signature/avatar violations etc?

I like it, although it would probably make the system more anonymous.

The one flaw I see with this system is signature rotators, and rotating images in profiles. The usefulness of the interpersonal communication is demolished, and users can no longer specify in ONE report which of the signatures on the rotator violates the rules.

This post was edited by Protagonist on Jul 21 2012 12:13pm

i give yes for this.

yes !

#reports can do this. Just need to give details.

Only thing is that many people do not like to be publically known for reporting people.
And sometimes they feel like sending a pm is a waste of time.
Making it simple could improve the amount of reports.

Only thing is that the reports sometimes needs to be given details to point out the issue.
Maybe this is why it stayed with you having to Pm a Member++ or using #reports.
I do remember such a idea suggested long ago but never got followed up. Unsure how it sent.

Voted yes.

I vote yes.

Though of course, certain violations might have to be sent to a ++, but it works the same way with actual posts, because in certain cases (like where a topic is closed but there is material that must be trashed visible) a JM/TM must be messaged.

Absolutely, I don't know anything about how the report button currently works and what the process is. Obviously because I am not a mod or anything like that, but I thought with this system the way it would work is when you Report a User it would go directly to a Members ++ Automatically since they basically handle all the Signature/Profile violation type stuff anyways.

bump

I'd just like to note that I mistook the couch cushion on the top righthand corner of your signature for an ass.

voted yes great idea !!!!