d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Homework Help > Chemistry Help > Will Pay Fg
Prev12
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 7,324
Joined: Dec 22 2002
Gold: 1,261.00
May 23 2013 10:42pm
Quote (cialda @ May 23 2013 06:15pm)
http://www.sciencegeek.net/Chemistry/taters/Unit0SigFigCounting.htm

says its 3 or 4. its like saying 530,000 mph has 6 six figs even though you can only measure it to "5" and the 3 is an estimate - in reality its only 2 for such said case <-- this is at least what i have been taught.

this is different than being able to measure the speed being 530,000, where the last bolded number is an estimate and the zero in the tens place is the last digit you measured.


Well even this source then agrees that it's at the very least ambiguous. Someone looking at the number will not be able to tell if the 3 is rounded or if you measured it exactly to 530,000. IMO you should never leave it as such, because some people may assume one and some may assume the other. You should ideally always use scientific notation because it avoids such confusion and can only be interpreted one way. Personally, if I was marking homework and got an answer like 4970 I would take it as 4 sig figs because there is nothing to indicate otherwise.
Member
Posts: 38,770
Joined: Sep 14 2005
Gold: 12,839.39
May 24 2013 07:02am
Quote (russian @ May 23 2013 10:42pm)
Well even this source then agrees that it's at the very least ambiguous. Someone looking at the number will not be able to tell if the 3 is rounded or if you measured it exactly to 530,000. IMO you should never leave it as such, because some people may assume one and some may assume the other. You should ideally always use scientific notation because it avoids such confusion and can only be interpreted one way. Personally, if I was marking homework and got an answer like 4970 I would take it as 4 sig figs because there is nothing to indicate otherwise.


Yes, it does leave it to be ambiguous. scientific notation would help, but on some of these homework problems (im assuming online) they dont necessarily ask for scientific notation or allow for it to be entered.

This post was edited by cialda on May 24 2013 07:02am
Member
Posts: 7,324
Joined: Dec 22 2002
Gold: 1,261.00
May 24 2013 10:27am
Quote (cialda @ May 24 2013 06:02am)
Yes, it does leave it to be ambiguous. scientific notation would help, but on some of these homework problems (im assuming online) they dont necessarily ask for scientific notation or allow for it to be entered.


Well, his homework said "scientific notation is optional", so it probably accepts it.
Also, consider this. If I have 530,000 how do I know if that's 2 sig figs (let's say it was 529,231) or 3 sig figs (let's say it was 529,789) or 4 sig figs (let's say it was 530,021), etc. Just because the 3 is the last non-zero number doesn't mean that it's the one that got rounded. I could just happen to round up or down to a zero.
Member
Posts: 38,770
Joined: Sep 14 2005
Gold: 12,839.39
May 24 2013 11:05am
Quote (russian @ May 24 2013 10:27am)
Well, his homework said "scientific notation is optional", so it probably accepts it.
Also, consider this. If I have 530,000 how do I know if that's 2 sig figs (let's say it was 529,231) or 3 sig figs (let's say it was 529,789) or 4 sig figs (let's say it was 530,021), etc. Just because the 3 is the last non-zero number doesn't mean that it's the one that got rounded. I could just happen to round up or down to a zero.


Yes and I realize that. Was agreeing it was ambiguous and that could be a problem. I didn't read entire thread as to if his hw accepted sci notation :)
Go Back To Homework Help Topic List
Prev12
Add Reply New Topic New Poll