Quote (neekzisonfire @ Jan 10 2015 02:14pm)
I suggest you think for yourself before you speak, instead of just agreeing with "an old post on smogon somewhere"

Who was the poster of that topic, a smogon moderator or something? And what relevance is their opinion? Because they moderate a chat or forum or something? I guess whatever they say goes...
Anyway. How is it in any way skillful if I have 4 nfes against your 3 ubers? Especially in a game like Pokemon where there are critical hits, burns, freezes, parahax, ect all based on a Random Number Generator...
random battles involving skill.... Lol please
And about those win %'s, I don't know if they are true and I'm not able to check if they are because I'm at work. But why wouldn't a lucky player be able to win 60-90%? You think luck means winning exactly 50% of the time? They won most of the time because they are lucky players, what exactly is your point?
let me be a little more clear,
YES the post was made by a smogon programmer in order to dispel some of the common misconceptions about random battle
a lot of ubers, due to low lvl, gimped movesets, stat spreads and such, are complete trash in random battle. a low tier pokemon like tauros that has a lvl 86, sheer force and life orb set, is effectively an uber in random battle.
all that is to say, traditional tiers have almost no relevance to random battle
also there are absolutely no nfe pokemon in random battle, so that comment alone does nothing but bolster my argument that you have no idea what you're talking about
Quote
And about those win %'s, I don't know if they are true and I'm not able to check if they are because I'm at work. But why wouldn't a lucky player be able to win 60-90%? You think luck means winning exactly 50% of the time? They won most of the time because they are lucky players, what exactly is your point?
one does not "luck" their way to a 60-90% winrate over 500+ games
This post was edited by Dangers on Jan 10 2015 09:14am