Quote (HC-QuikSilver @ Tue, Jun 17 2008, 10:21pm)
Ofc everyone will say it needs alot of work, but most of
them are experienced.
But afterall.. it is your first try.
So goodjob. 
Well of course this is based on his basic sig tutorial and following his instruction for the most part if you look @ his guide and the other people who posted their finished products you really need to compare it to that..as I did this on my first day using photoshop its of course not on par with anyone who has any experience lol i'm a complete and utter beginner it'll take a few weeks to get used to using photoshop even remotley well probably..lol but thank you anyway