d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Martial Arts, Boxing & Wrestling >
Poll > Who Is The Goat?
Prev1234525Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 34,935
Joined: Jan 21 2012
Gold: 1,090.50
Jul 10 2018 10:31am
Jones or DJ for me
Member
Posts: 23,931
Joined: Sep 8 2008
Gold: 19,005.00
Jul 10 2018 10:32am
the only real debate is dc or jones.
jones never lost, dc only lost to jones but 1 of them is a no contest due to jones cheating.
seems like a moral question more than anything, do you disqualify jones for cheating or not.
if you do, then i dont see how you can say dc isnt the goat. jones is his only loss, he won 2 belts and has dominated everyone else. and never cheated like anderson/gsp/ anyone from pride.

dj has been great but his resume cant compare to dcs. same with khabib. at this moment in time the only logical answers are jones or dc, and it comes down to if you personally disqualify cheaters or not.
Member
Posts: 7,730
Joined: Apr 4 2016
Gold: 0.00
Jul 10 2018 10:48am
assume you go to court 20 times, get found not guilty 19 times, and on the 20th trial u are found guilty. do the 19 prior not guilty verdicts get changed to guilty?

to the morons disqualifying jons career, apparently they do.

el jones is the god.

This post was edited by devilslayer on Jul 10 2018 10:48am
Member
Posts: 23,931
Joined: Sep 8 2008
Gold: 19,005.00
Jul 10 2018 10:54am
Quote (devilslayer @ Jul 10 2018 12:48pm)
assume you go to court 20 times, get found not guilty 19 times, and on the 20th trial u are found guilty. do the 19 prior not guilty verdicts get changed to guilty?

to the morons disqualifying jons career, apparently they do.

el jones is the god.


if you scam once you are a scammer
if you rape once you are a rapist
if you murder once you are a murderer


jones is a cheater. to which degree or how high you hold that info is all up for interpretation. but he is indeed a proven cheater.
Member
Posts: 18,905
Joined: Jul 1 2015
Gold: 3,025.00
Jul 10 2018 10:56am
Fedor/DC/GSP/Mighty Mouse

Jon Jones, Anderson Silva honorable mention
Member
Posts: 120,295
Joined: May 18 2013
Gold: 201.66
Jul 10 2018 11:39am
jons isnt in this kuz he cheated imo. same with silva. u dont see conor getting popped for roids. so its a choice between conor / dc / gsp.

also one other thing. lets imagine MM was a hw with his same frame/ skill set in hw form. what then?

This post was edited by bbanee on Jul 10 2018 11:40am
Member
Posts: 40,753
Joined: Apr 10 2008
Gold: 106.80
Jul 10 2018 11:58am
Quote (lucrative @ Jul 10 2018 10:54am)
if you scam once you are a scammer
if you rape once you are a rapist
if you murder once you are a murderer


jones is a cheater. to which degree or how high you hold that info is all up for interpretation. but he is indeed a proven cheater.


Proven? What? This current one was absolute trace amounts and the previous one was proven to be a tainted supplement. So unless USADA comes out and says this current one was him cheating, he hasn't been proven to be a cheater.

Idiot? For sure, but he's not a 'proven cheater'
Member
Posts: 18,905
Joined: Jul 1 2015
Gold: 3,025.00
Jul 10 2018 12:12pm
Quote (Fezbang @ Jul 10 2018 09:58am)
Proven? What? This current one was absolute trace amounts and the previous one was proven to be a tainted supplement. So unless USADA comes out and says this current one was him cheating, he hasn't been proven to be a cheater.

Idiot? For sure, but he's not a 'proven cheater'


If trace amounts don't prove you failed a test, why even test?
Member
Posts: 52,315
Joined: Mar 25 2007
Gold: 6,487.40
Jul 10 2018 12:13pm
Quote (bbanee @ 10 Jul 2018 12:39)
jons isnt in this kuz he cheated imo. same with silva. u dont see conor getting popped for roids. so its a choice between conor / dc / gsp.

also one other thing. lets imagine MM was a hw with his same frame/ skill set in hw form. what then?


remove conor
its between dc and my Georges
conor doesn't have enough pedigree to be consider in the top 10
He score no1 in the big mouth department only

as for those who think jon jones can be the goat, well come back clean and prove it. period
Go Back To Martial Arts, Boxing & Wrestling Topic List
Prev1234525Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll