d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Martial Arts, Boxing & Wrestling > Best Martial Art For A Girl?
Prev123
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 5,869
Joined: Feb 13 2016
Gold: 7,909.00
Sep 21 2024 04:52am
Quote (girly @ Sep 15 2024 01:38pm)
i want to be able to defend myself not rely on a gadget


self defence is a legal term and a concept

most men AND women will lose to any normal sized human male that has
1- intent to maim or injure
2- lack of consideration for the consequences
3- propensity for the escalation of violence as briefly as possible in a given scenario


in my experience the % of population that has the intestinal fortitude, physical blessings, and fighting skill to fight off your average thug is suprisingly low


most people have a massively inflated self perception of their ability to fight, especially men ( it is a massive part of our identity as men to be "tough" or "badass" )
most people have no legitimate fighting skills
size differences matter exponentially more the less skilled you are in fighting


if you want to do martial arts do the one you will enjoy the most, women seem to enjoy judo, bjj, cardio kickboxing (this is kind of an exercise class tbh)
two days a month at the shooting range with a small caliber pistol you are proficient in maintaining and utilizing, would be more effective for "self defence" than 10,000 hours on the mats.

there is too many what if scenarios and strawmans, especially on a topic so sensitive to male ego fragility

source: ran a mma gym, combat arms veteran, bjj brown belt, 90% finishing rate in competitive jiu jitsu, survived prison (booty intact), marskmanship coach, etc



tldr

run away
martial arts are for enjoyment

Member
Posts: 5,888
Joined: May 13 2009
Gold: 43.69
Sep 21 2024 11:08am
Quote (Mahtava @ Sep 21 2024 06:52am)
self defence is a legal term and a concept

most men AND women will lose to any normal sized human male that has
1- intent to maim or injure
2- lack of consideration for the consequences
3- propensity for the escalation of violence as briefly as possible in a given scenario


in my experience the % of population that has the intestinal fortitude, physical blessings, and fighting skill to fight off your average thug is suprisingly low


most people have a massively inflated self perception of their ability to fight, especially men ( it is a massive part of our identity as men to be "tough" or "badass" )
most people have no legitimate fighting skills
size differences matter exponentially more the less skilled you are in fighting


if you want to do martial arts do the one you will enjoy the most, women seem to enjoy judo, bjj, cardio kickboxing (this is kind of an exercise class tbh)
two days a month at the shooting range with a small caliber pistol you are proficient in maintaining and utilizing, would be more effective for "self defence" than 10,000 hours on the mats.

there is too many what if scenarios and strawmans, especially on a topic so sensitive to male ego fragility

source: ran a mma gym, combat arms veteran, bjj brown belt, 90% finishing rate in competitive jiu jitsu, survived prison (booty intact), marskmanship coach, etc



tldr

run away
martial arts are for enjoyment


no one on this forum has any legit street fighting experience IRL except me. lol.

it doesn't go how you think. its not a fucking ufc fight.

This post was edited by Drox on Sep 21 2024 11:08am
Member
Posts: 5,869
Joined: Feb 13 2016
Gold: 7,909.00
Sep 21 2024 11:23am
Quote (Drox @ Sep 21 2024 01:08pm)
no one on this forum has any legit street fighting experience IRL except me. lol.

it doesn't go how you think. its not a fucking ufc fight.


nice
Member
Posts: 256
Joined: Sep 20 2023
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 10%
Sep 21 2024 03:58pm
This post is a violation of the site rules and appropriate action was taken.

Quote (Drox @ Sep 21 2024 10:08am)
no one on this forum has any legit street fighting experience IRL except me. lol.

it doesn't go how you think. its not a fucking ufc fight.


no doubt you have the most experience getting pegged and running away from fights since that's what you keep talking about on my thread for some reason.. go away
Member
Posts: 7,730
Joined: Apr 4 2016
Gold: 0.00
Sep 21 2024 04:34pm
Quote (girly @ Sep 21 2024 05:58pm)
no doubt you have the most experience getting pegged and running away from fights since that's what you keep talking about on my thread for some reason.. go away


You could train your whole life but if Drox wanted to take your virginity there's absolutely nothing you could do about it :rofl:

Buy a gun and close this trash thread. Or carry pepper spray. Fighting is not for little girls.
Go Back To Martial Arts, Boxing & Wrestling Topic List
Prev123
Closed New Topic New Poll