Quote (Decarnate @ Sep 5 2024 06:26pm)

Silva beat the shit out of arguably the weakest MW division since Dana took over the organization.

Pereira has successfully captured belts in 2 divisions.

Silva popped for PEDs.

I'm not entirely disagreeing with you, I'm just saying if he beats DDP and let's say Ankalaev, there is a very strong argument.

Quote (JOHNOATES @ 5 Sep 2024 17:01)

Anderson fought in an era where everybody was on peds, who cares. Alex was KO'd stiff a year ago, anderson went on a 17 fight winning streak, with 10 title defense, undefeated for years. Alex has far more work to do than 2 more wins.

Quote (JOHNOATES @ Sep 5 2024 07:01pm)

Anderson fought in an era where everybody was on peds, who cares. Alex was KO'd stiff a year ago, anderson went on a 17 fight winning streak, with 10 title defense, undefeated for years. Alex has far more work to do than 2 more wins.

Quote (Decarnate @ Sep 5 2024 08:19pm)

Its fine if you believe that quantity > quality. I've been watching mma for quite a few years and remember a lot from the old days. For the life of me I cannot recall how guys like Patrick Cote or Travis Lutter ever received title shots :rofl:

Quote (jumanji8 @ Sep 5 2024 04:23pm)

This 100%. Alex isnt close and he will never achieve what Silva did because hes already old

Quote (Decarnate @ Sep 5 2024 08:19pm)

Its fine if you believe that quantity > quality. I've been watching mma for quite a few years and remember a lot from the old days. For the life of me I cannot recall how guys like Patrick Cote or Travis Lutter ever received title shots :rofl:

Quote (crosspawz @ Sep 5 2024 09:02pm)

Alex just needs one chance and he could do what no one else has, 3x division champ which, in my mind, would 100% make him the goat but ofc someone will say im gay for that

Quote (crosspawz @ Sep 3 2024 01:58pm)

Does this 100% cement him as the GOAT?

Quote (Decarnate @ Sep 5 2024 04:30pm)

An argument for Brazilian GOAT surpassing Aldo/Silva with a few more quality wins.