2 is #1.

As much as I loved halo 2 I am going to disagree for the sole fact that 1 took a little more skill even though there were more button glitches in 2. The skill gap was greatest in 1 and then slowly went downhill

This post was edited by Shmazoo on Aug 22 2010 04:21pm

Only reason I'm saying 2 is #1, is cause of all the amazing, insane customs, glitches, etc. Like I played from Day 1 to the last day.. and idk, nothing comes close

haha ya. Halo 3 is the worst game ever compared to halo 2.

1 > 2 > Hello kitty > 3

2 was fun because of glitches and clear cut line between good people and bad.

1 was awesome because it took more skill and was much more competitive.

XBC ftw.

halo 1 might be #1 in my books if it had xbox live.
i dont no really how competitive it really was as i only played with my friends and brothers.
im still not sure if it would be better then halo 2, halo 3 for sure tho

nothing compares to the custom games, fun glitches, the maps, and even CLANS. that was a sick idea, they should have kept that.

im glad that reach is bringing back old halo2 maps instead of halo 3, halo 3 maps are the worst!

anyone know if reach will have clans?

Really it's just the basic ideas of the map. It's not like they'll be played the same or be as fun as they were in h2. They'll still be different, just look at heretic. Can sit p3 for 5 minutes and not die at level 50 mlg because the games a joke and connection > but h2 you had to play smart cuz you can get 4 shotted no matter where you are.

Halo 2>all

yah i didnt like heretic eithher.

but remakes can always be jsut as good as the original.

check out the new accension for halo reach. looks liek a fun map
on the other hand, the new ivory tower looks gay

1 heretic is the best map in halo 3

2 ivory tower remake looks great

3 ascension forge remake looks cool as well