d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Other Games > Other Games > Hearthstone > Onyxia
123Next
Add Reply New Trade New Service New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 41,780
Joined: Jan 13 2009
Gold: 25.20
Aug 26 2015 05:57pm
Why is this card not played? Curious as to your opinions.

You get 14/14 of value for 9 cost.
Member
Posts: 30,376
Joined: Dec 8 2012
Gold: 223,792.69
Aug 26 2015 06:01pm
too slow, doesnt doo enough when it comes on the battlefield, 9 mana cards u usually can only have 1-2 in a deck at best and there are better 9 mana dragons etc etc
Member
Posts: 4,726
Joined: May 30 2008
Gold: 648.54
Aug 26 2015 06:06pm
some guy played that against me yesterday at rank 4, in a mage with spells and flamewakers, it was weird as fuck. then he lost.
Member
Posts: 41,780
Joined: Jan 13 2009
Gold: 25.20
Aug 26 2015 06:16pm
Quote (oWntpWnt @ Aug 26 2015 04:01pm)
too slow, doesnt doo enough when it comes on the battlefield, 9 mana cards u usually can only have 1-2 in a deck at best and there are better 9 mana dragons etc etc


It overloads the board and you have to deal with them all.
Member
Posts: 4,726
Joined: May 30 2008
Gold: 648.54
Aug 26 2015 06:20pm
Quote (FroggyG @ Aug 27 2015 12:16am)
It overloads the board and you have to deal with them all.


swipe deals with them pretty well


but for comparison sake

Blast mage /flamewalker / freeze mage spells
hellfire/shadowflame
whirlwind / deathsbite / ghoul
holy nova / auchenie circle / lightbomb
concecration /healing /taunts
explosive trap / unleash the hounds
lightning storm
Fan of knives/ blade flurry.

BGH


these are all usable cards in top tier decks and make onyxia just bad overall because of it.







This post was edited by Quadpvp on Aug 26 2015 06:25pm
Member
Posts: 41,780
Joined: Jan 13 2009
Gold: 25.20
Aug 26 2015 06:55pm
Quote (Quadpvp @ Aug 26 2015 04:20pm)
swipe deals with them pretty well


but for comparison sake

Blast mage /flamewalker / freeze mage spells
hellfire/shadowflame
whirlwind / deathsbite / ghoul
holy nova / auchenie circle / lightbomb
concecration /healing /taunts
explosive trap / unleash the hounds
lightning storm
Fan of knives/ blade flurry.

BGH


these are all usable cards in top tier decks and make onyxia just bad overall because of it.


Swipe kills the 1/1s and leaves an 8/4. That's 2 cards you need to trade for 1.
No matter what you seem to be trading 2 for 1. And that's if you have BOTH answers.

This post was edited by FroggyG on Aug 26 2015 06:57pm
Member
Posts: 4,726
Joined: May 30 2008
Gold: 648.54
Aug 26 2015 07:01pm
Quote (FroggyG @ Aug 27 2015 12:55am)
Swipe kills the 1/1s and leaves an 8/4. That's 2 cards you need to trade for 1.
No matter what you seem to be trading 2 for 1. And that's if you have BOTH answers.


in theory its good. in practice its not.

but dont let anyone stop you from trying it, and if you do. i suggest things that synergize with it. savage roar for example
Member
Posts: 41,780
Joined: Jan 13 2009
Gold: 25.20
Aug 26 2015 07:17pm
Quote (Quadpvp @ Aug 26 2015 05:01pm)
in theory its good. in practice its not.

but dont let anyone stop you from trying it, and if you do. i suggest things that synergize with it. savage roar for example


I'm just wondering what people's arguments are for not running it.
Has lots of potential with token buffers.

Like if they don't play an AoE you just win the game. And it's likely they already played lots because you're already a token deck as is.

If you have to waste your board clear on 1 card then it's a pretty good card..

This post was edited by FroggyG on Aug 26 2015 07:20pm
Member
Posts: 15,416
Joined: Feb 17 2014
Gold: 5.71
Aug 26 2015 07:37pm
You get 14/14 assuming you have nothing on your board.

It's not run because the card has no immediate impact for 9 mana. Does it fill your board? Yes. Does that actually do anything a lot of the time? No...... lol. For 9 mana you can get ysera, 4/12 and at least 1 extra card. Ysera has WAYYYYYYY more upside potential though. For 9 mana you could have Nef which is an 8/8 and 2 spells. Every big leg that gets played has an immediate impact outside of just existing on the board.
Member
Posts: 41,780
Joined: Jan 13 2009
Gold: 25.20
Aug 26 2015 07:49pm
Quote (DrLatBC @ Aug 26 2015 05:37pm)
You get 14/14 assuming you have nothing on your board.

It's not run because the card has no immediate impact for 9 mana. Does it fill your board? Yes. Does that actually do anything a lot of the time? No...... lol. For 9 mana you can get ysera, 4/12 and at least 1 extra card. Ysera has WAYYYYYYY more upside potential though. For 9 mana you could have Nef which is an 8/8 and 2 spells. Every big leg that gets played has an immediate impact outside of just existing on the board.


Nef and Ysera have no immediate effect on the board at all. You can't do anything with them the turn they are played.
Neither does Onyxia, but gives you 6x 1/1s to immediately threaten them while Ysera gives you 1 random card that can be trash.
The 1/1s can at be used to combo with bloodlust, savage roar
And it's better at trading against aggressive decks that have lots of minions on board.

That's like saying Dr. Boom is trash. Does it fill your board? Yes. That's all.

This post was edited by FroggyG on Aug 26 2015 07:52pm
Go Back To Hearthstone Topic List
123Next
Add Reply New Trade New Service New Topic New Poll