d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Other Games > Other Games > Hearthstone > Hearthstone General Discussion
Prev19159169179189191090Next
Add Reply New Trade New Service New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 41,780
Joined: Jan 13 2009
Gold: 25.20
Jul 27 2017 10:36pm
Quote (Pinecones @ Jul 27 2017 10:12pm)
So essentially you're saying that because the card art changes, dotc will come back?

I know this is a blizzard explanation, I just think it's a very poor one. So the robo cub and ancient of war are just boned.


The ancient of war health can be silenced because the +5 health and taunt is a battlecry
DOTC isn't a battlecry it's an actual minion spawned that way, otherwise you would be able to silence it into a 4/4.

This post was edited by FroggyG on Jul 27 2017 10:37pm
Member
Posts: 73,131
Joined: Nov 1 2006
Gold: 36,635.00
Jul 28 2017 12:41am


Member
Posts: 73,131
Joined: Nov 1 2006
Gold: 36,635.00
Jul 28 2017 02:20am
Member
Posts: 36,389
Joined: Jul 18 2008
Gold: 3,192.00
Jul 28 2017 06:06am
Both free arena runs had 0 legendaries in draft :(
Member
Posts: 73,131
Joined: Nov 1 2006
Gold: 36,635.00
Jul 28 2017 07:23am
Member
Posts: 17,488
Joined: Dec 11 2010
Gold: 3,115.13
Jul 28 2017 10:51am
Quote (FroggyG @ Jul 28 2017 12:36am)
The ancient of war health can be silenced because the +5 health and taunt is a battlecry
DOTC isn't a battlecry it's an actual minion spawned that way, otherwise you would be able to silence it into a 4/4.



Except it doesn't say battle cry on the card. Does ancient of war become a 5/15 with brann? I'm asking because I don't know, but I don't think so because it isn't an explicit trait in the card.

Therefore, your rationale would be incorrect. Literally the only reason is because it changes card art and becomes one of 3 uncollectables, and therefore a new card as a whole, which is bullshit imo

This post was edited by Pinecones on Jul 28 2017 10:53am
Member
Posts: 2,018
Joined: Oct 14 2012
Gold: 18,955.00
Jul 28 2017 11:17am
It's "choose one" not "battlecry" so Brann doesn't work. When you play Druid of the Claw and transform it into 4/6 taunt you get new minion. You can check it by returning it to your hand. If you try to play it again you don't get to choose transformation. Ancient of War works differently. If you return it to your hand and replay it you get to choose bonus again.
Member
Posts: 53,552
Joined: Mar 6 2008
Gold: 1,908.33
Jul 28 2017 12:35pm
I believe wtk is right. the unintuitive differences between the cards are known.




The free arenas are bringing out the noobs. I love it.
Member
Posts: 17,488
Joined: Dec 11 2010
Gold: 3,115.13
Jul 28 2017 02:24pm
Quote (wtk300 @ Jul 28 2017 01:17pm)
It's "choose one" not "battlecry" so Brann doesn't work. When you play Druid of the Claw and transform it into 4/6 taunt you get new minion. You can check it by returning it to your hand. If you try to play it again you don't get to choose transformation. Ancient of War works differently. If you return it to your hand and replay it you get to choose bonus again.



See, this I know. I was merely contesting the point of froggy. My issue though is with the idea of transformation vs non transformation. There should be a transform keyword instead of a choose one if they're going to lack continuity through the set.

Druid of the claw, Druid of the flame - transform

Ancients of war/lore, robo cub, cenarius - choose

I'm sure there are plenty of examples for both categories, it's just a nuance that fucks with the mechanics of the game.

Member
Posts: 97,837
Joined: Feb 26 2006
Gold: 3.09
Trader: Trusted
Jul 28 2017 03:39pm
Currently 4-0 with this arena draft :D
edit: 6-0



This post was edited by Garnier on Jul 28 2017 03:47pm
Go Back To Hearthstone Topic List
Prev19159169179189191090Next
Add Reply New Trade New Service New Topic New Poll