i wouldn't normally dispute anything about this. this thread though, is about how i feel the masses ruined it. only because they couldn't comprehend how to battle it.
i've stated early off i was in disagreement. my claims are based solely off experience playing this game. which is why i'm able to list cards and plays. from most of you all i'm getting is... this guy said so. i know what ppl have said, again i am in disagreement. the whole point of this thread.
some of you have made a decent point, just like the mention of control priest vs rogue. from my experience, that is a very correct call. i can't even imagine losing to a priest with my pre-nerf quest rogue. but i am not in agreement over quest warrior. i think ppl should learn to play quest warrior better is all.
still. even if we all include quest warrior. that's 2 decks listed to me that would have troubles. is 2 very specific decks worth killing the quest? i refuse to add quest warrior to the list myself, but 2 decks having a weakness to 1 is not uncommon. by any means.

this thread is poppin. more please

Seems your only issue was already answered by both me and froggy.







But don't let this stop you, this is actually hours of laughter from my end.

This post was edited by DrLatBC on Jul 14 2017 05:25pm

haven't played ladder in 2 months, do I dust golden quest rogue?

I mean I would.

If it stays popular just recraft it ezpz. If it is totally useless then you you lose 3600 dust if you didn't dust it.

I always dust nerfed cards for this reason lol.

This post was edited by DrLatBC on Jul 14 2017 06:59pm

dust it, as BC says you can always recraft it.



although i haven't agreed fully with every statement froggy has made here. froggy has still made some points. over-all froggy has been saying, rogue is the reason we don't see decks that lose to rogue.
you are telling me that quest warrior loses to quest rogue. i mean sure, it can. but it's not this extravagant disadvantage you are making it out to be.

you have listed exactly 1 play, in a very loosely used way.



can you seriously believe that you have vanish 100% of the time when you need it. especially as i only used 1 in my deck, i can tell you it doesn't.
taunt minions are supposed to trade off. they are literally there as blockers while you complete your quest.
the lack of consistent pressure early game does help a quest rogue play with options. i don't think you are taking into factor how few minions the rogue uses.
pending what turn it is, 1 whirlwind or brawl or sleeping with the fishes can devastate options and completely turn momentum.

I like how you choose to ignore half my posts then bash me for "having one point"

I literally in plain English said there are lots of decks that never saw the light of day because of rogue, I even fucking said it before froggy. YOU LITERALLY COMPLIMENTED MY POINT BECAUSE SOMEONE ELSE HAD MADE IT AFTER ME.



/e God bless, buddy.

This post was edited by DrLatBC on Jul 14 2017 08:42pm

when? you mean when you said the nerf was for "LOTS" of decks? you speak so vaguely. you continue to steal other peoples actual effort to build a point.
roflwaffle w/e yourself to sleep if you want to. simple minds, simple pleasures.
i'm all up for a debate. you just come here with a large mouth as you spout more bull shit than i. you say i'm ignoring half your posts? i've clearly answered to them all and you choose to ignore them because you wouldn't be a proper fanboy if you didn't follow your streamer.
if you've forgotten any of those replies, go ahead and read back. you seem to love reading my stuff any way.

God bless. Reading is hard.

It doesn't matter whether you know how to battle it or not.
I don't think this is a matter of win percentages.

It's not interactive. It's bad for the game. And it pushes out a lot of control decks from meta making it almost purely aggressive (and a lot of people are tired of aggressive metas).

If you want though, you can easily look up win percentages at specific rankings of control decks vs quest rogue. I think they normally sort by 1-5, 5-15, 15+

This post was edited by FroggyG on Jul 15 2017 12:31am