d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Other Games > Other Games > Hearthstone > Priest Legendary > Not Real
Prev123Next
Add Reply New Trade New Service New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 17,488
Joined: Dec 11 2010
Gold: 3,115.13
Feb 11 2017 11:41am
Quote (Hepzibah @ Feb 11 2017 12:38pm)
yeah it makes the card way too strong right?

but at the same time it being legend rarity makes its consistency on turn 1 kinda rough... 13% chance to have it on turn 1 if youre going first?

Maybe it wouldn't automatically take priest to tier1; but it would certainly be an auto-include in at least 95% of priest decks..



Absolutely. I still think aggro shaman would beat it though. Even if it didn't unstealth. It'd need more help. Pyro combos and holy smites would probably also need to be in the deck. It'd be cool to see. A shame it's not real, and there is no way to test it.
Member
Posts: 23,312
Joined: Apr 18 2008
Gold: 45,199.50
Feb 11 2017 11:54am
Quote (Pinecones @ Feb 11 2017 12:41pm)
Absolutely. I still think aggro shaman would beat it though. Even if it didn't unstealth. It'd need more help. Pyro combos and holy smites would probably also need to be in the deck. It'd be cool to see. A shame it's not real, and there is no way to test it.


Yeah I think its a super interesting concept.. interesting use of inspire; where normally inspire effects benefit the player using the effect; this card is so strong for its mana cost that inspire is used as a downside.
would be hard countered by maelstrom portal - arcane nova - whirlwind/ravaging ghoul. interesting setup for warriors running frothing berserkers as counter play.. But hard countering the current turn 1 curve out meta.

Really like the card. but ultimately think its too strong for what priest currently has in its kit. especially given reno iterations -- maybe if priest was in absolute last place in this meta it would seem more fair.
Member
Posts: 1,507
Joined: Nov 24 2016
Gold: 1,465.71
Feb 11 2017 09:55pm
To clarify to the questions asked about the card's design:

The " Enemy minions take 1 damage when attacking your hero. " is always active

It does not reveal when it deals 1 damage to an enemy minion from it's effect.

And using your hero power reveals itself and all other cards.

it does 2 things:

1 You're no longer in charge (fuck patches)

2 Fuck your conceal 1 mana bullshit that autowins you the game. You have counter-play now as a priest. It's hard enough to deal with a 4/4 as a priest, let alone a stealthed 4/4.

Best case scenario - it kills 1-2 minions. You're trading being able to heal by playing this card.

Worse case scenario - it 1 for 1's against fan of knives. (Play nevermore, gets fanned -1 minion +1 card)

This post was edited by d2jspNA on Feb 11 2017 10:07pm
Member
Posts: 41,780
Joined: Jan 13 2009
Gold: 25.20
Feb 12 2017 06:41pm
Quote (Hepzibah @ Feb 11 2017 11:33am)
its basically a 1 cost arcane explosion that repeats itself everytime your opponent attacks... this card makes you not want to hero power.

You have brain right mr.frog sir?

this card would single handedly take priest to tier 1.


If it was a passive effect for the whole game it would say that.
The way it is worded it just means that the effect is active as long as that minion is alive.

Doesn't matter what the person's intention was when making the card. That's what the text means so the card sucks.

This post was edited by FroggyG on Feb 12 2017 06:42pm
Member
Posts: 23,312
Joined: Apr 18 2008
Gold: 45,199.50
Feb 12 2017 07:00pm
Quote (FroggyG @ Feb 12 2017 07:41pm)
If it was a passive effect for the whole game it would say that.
The way it is worded it just means that the effect is active as long as that minion is alive.

Doesn't matter what the person's intention was when making the card. That's what the text means so the card sucks.


No... No I think maybe the second effect needed to be placed above the inspire. But its worded correctly my friend.
And given its effect - which the OP has clarified - the card is op as fuck.

You have such a shitty attitude towards the game that even after the op clarifies its effect for you - you won't comment/ignore him.

youre a piece of shit.
Member
Posts: 41,780
Joined: Jan 13 2009
Gold: 25.20
Feb 12 2017 07:04pm
Quote (Hepzibah @ Feb 12 2017 07:00pm)
No... No I think maybe the second effect needed to be placed above the inspire. But its worded correctly my friend.
And given its effect - which the OP has clarified - the card is op as fuck.

You have such a shitty attitude towards the game that even after the op clarifies its effect for you - you won't comment/ignore him.

youre a piece of shit.


Regardless of where the effect was placed in the text it only implies a static effect when the minion is in play.
If the minion is not in play, then the static effect is no longer on the field and therefore no longer active.

If Blizzard did put an effect of this type in the game it would probably be some kind of symbol near the class portrait

This post was edited by FroggyG on Feb 12 2017 07:05pm
Member
Posts: 23,312
Joined: Apr 18 2008
Gold: 45,199.50
Feb 12 2017 07:11pm
Quote (FroggyG @ Feb 12 2017 08:04pm)
Regardless of where the effect was placed in the text it only implies a static effect when the minion is in play.
If the minion is not in play, then the static effect is no longer on the field and therefore no longer active.

If Blizzard did put an effect of this type in the game it would probably be some kind of symbol near the class portrait


Woah woah no kidding

you think the card isn't powerful as godly fuck even if its removed when the minion dies? because that's what is implied..

youre still failing the reading comprehension man
Member
Posts: 41,780
Joined: Jan 13 2009
Gold: 25.20
Feb 12 2017 07:17pm
Quote (Hepzibah @ Feb 12 2017 07:11pm)
Woah woah no kidding

you think the card isn't powerful as godly fuck even if its removed when the minion dies? because that's what is implied..

youre still failing the reading comprehension man


If the effect stays for the entire game it's obviously an overpowered card.
The card presented, however, is awful, because the text means something different.
Member
Posts: 23,312
Joined: Apr 18 2008
Gold: 45,199.50
Feb 12 2017 07:18pm
Quote (FroggyG @ Feb 12 2017 08:17pm)
If the effect stays for the entire game it's obviously an overpowered card.
The card presented, however, is awful, because the text means something different.


No the effect goes away when the card is removed from play........
As the OP has fucking clarified you fucking meat heat.

EVEN SO

The card would single handedly take priest to tier1 it is so powerful its unreasonable.

This post was edited by Hepzibah on Feb 12 2017 07:19pm
Member
Posts: 41,780
Joined: Jan 13 2009
Gold: 25.20
Feb 12 2017 07:19pm
Quote (Hepzibah @ Feb 12 2017 07:18pm)
No the effect goes away when the card is removed from play........

As the OP has fucking clarified you fucking meat heat.


The OP doesn't decide what the text means.
He just needs to word it better.
Go Back To Hearthstone Topic List
Prev123Next
Add Reply New Trade New Service New Topic New Poll