No more suggestions?

woot woot , mu? , 2moons

Settlers online

mabinogi

Good: combat, lots of stuff to do outside of fighting, can be anything you want (no class restriction), got a storyline, can have pets with you for combat, you can write the AI for pets!

bad: a bit of grinding, will need money to get full taste of game (pets), going from town to town might take a while, the graphics.. really chunky

Guild Wars 1, you pay a small fee for the game but then it's free to play . It's a lot instanced tho, so it's open world like WoW etc.

dragon born, a new browser mmo actually pretty good

check out Spiral Knights, big topic on JSP

its full of players too, and has constant updates

also, if you need help or items i'm currently selling a hell of a lot of stuff for fg