What is more important the +3 to PS or the type of claw?
I've never made one, and thought it'd be the season to try it out, and i've found 1+3ps Suwaywayayayayaya and +2 greater claws

And curious if the + to PS is more important then using something like a Greater Talon.
Or would a greater talon plain base be better than any other base +3ps.

The +3 is generally better

Thiss^^

slower bases are alright for the off-hand slot. you definitely want a gt main-hand though. so go for any GT over the suw as long as it's for the left slot