d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > How Many Times Can U Re-roll Baal Item?
Prev12
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 74,658
Joined: Aug 3 2013
Gold: 3,211.11
Jan 6 2022 01:02am
Quote (0blique @ Jan 6 2022 12:55am)
well it's just something to roll as you collect the gems playing. though i suppose you could actually try to buy 31k chipped gems lol. you're going to be seeing lots of them playing anyway, so why not roll them? that was just an example though, another one you could try for is the exact same recipe with a caduceus instead for priest's caduceus of the apprentice (+2 pal / 10 fcr). the blessed hammer & concentration aura staffmods are available for that item.

on d2r, i've been burning most of my non-ruby or amethyst pgems on a sacred targe, which has a 1/15307 chance of spawning as jeweler's of deflecting with ilvl 77 (that's not counting the potential auto mod). comparatively, baal gcs have a 1/121000 to be a specific skiller with 41+ life (if that's the only type of prefix you want). only some of those skill tabs are actually sought after, but either way combined those are also comparatively decent odds that you'll get one someone likes.

in my opinion, it's still not the only item worth rerolling (particularly if you want to use the item you are rolling). i'd also consider magic diadems - lots of potential salable results (volcanic of the magus, artisan's of speed, etc) that have comparative odds (100k or less)



You are also completely ignoring the extra rolls for example on jewelers sacred targe of deflecting, to roll the needed ED/AR for it to be worth it.

Which exponentially lowers the odds. You keep throwing these odds around for just the affix portion, and ignoring the staff mod / ED/AR portion of the equation.

You are completely misrepsentinf the odds to help your story.

I understand YOU are doing it. That doesn’t change the fact that it is stupid and ineffective.

You would be able to find more fg worth of items simply MFing instead of rolling, than you will get for the item you rerolled.
Member
Posts: 2,526
Joined: Aug 19 2007
Gold: 20.00
Jan 6 2022 01:21am
Quote (Overpriced @ Jan 6 2022 02:02am)


You are completely misrepsentinf the odds to help your story.


except that i clearly noted that, "that's not counting the potential auto mod". even without a perfect auto/staffmod, they're still highly valuable items if you're at all successful (example after a quick search: https://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=91482566 note that it has no ed/ar and is imperfect, too).
what exactly do you think i misrepresented? you don't waste much time collecting 1x1 size items along your path mfing (nobody ever said not to lol - who's the one misrepresenting?) and you get extra chances at an item that is valuable (or usable, depending on how far along your character is). you're wrong and you have a stupid and ineffective attitude.
Member
Posts: 74,658
Joined: Aug 3 2013
Gold: 3,211.11
Jan 6 2022 01:40am
Quote (0blique @ Jan 6 2022 01:21am)
except that i clearly noted that, "that's not counting the potential auto mod". even without a perfect auto/staffmod, they're still highly valuable items if you're at all successful (example after a quick search: https://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=91482566 note that it has no ed/ar and is imperfect, too).
what exactly do you think i misrepresented? you don't waste much time collecting 1x1 size items along your path mfing (nobody ever said not to lol - who's the one misrepresenting?) and you get extra chances at an item that is valuable (or usable, depending on how far along your character is). you're wrong and you have a stupid and ineffective attitude.



You found a thread in which there are 3 clueless dumbasses that have no idea what they are doing.

A HoZ is better than that
Member
Posts: 74,658
Joined: Aug 3 2013
Gold: 3,211.11
Jan 6 2022 01:44am
Quote (0blique @ Jan 6 2022 01:21am)
except that i clearly noted that, "that's not counting the potential auto mod". even without a perfect auto/staffmod, they're still highly valuable items if you're at all successful (example after a quick search: https://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=91482566 note that it has no ed/ar and is imperfect, too).
what exactly do you think i misrepresented? you don't waste much time collecting 1x1 size items along your path mfing (nobody ever said not to lol - who's the one misrepresenting?) and you get extra chances at an item that is valuable (or usable, depending on how far along your character is). you're wrong and you have a stupid and ineffective attitude.



I’m also not wrong. To get a 1/15,000 chance at an item, it takes 135,000 button clicks To just grab the 3x flawless to get 1x pgem, 3 times. . . At 1 second per, it takes 37.5 hours to just pick up the flawless gems in reference from the ground.

That doesn’t count the time to put them in your stash. And then in your cube, and then Transmute. Then move item out of cube. And then move it to stash. And then put the 3 in your cube. Then sacred targe in cube. And then hit transmute. And then move sacred targe back to stash.

It is a complete time sink. You are sinfifxbrlt better off just keeping on MFing and by passing those flawless gems

This post was edited by Overpriced on Jan 6 2022 01:47am
Member
Posts: 2,526
Joined: Aug 19 2007
Gold: 20.00
Jan 6 2022 01:51am
Quote (Overpriced @ Jan 6 2022 02:44am)
I’m also not wrong. To get a 1/15,000 chance at an item, it takes 45,000 button clicks To just grab the chipped gems. . At 1 second per, it takes 12.5 hours to just pick up the chipped gems in reference.

That doesn’t count the time to put them in your stash. And then in your cube, and then Transmute. Then move item out of cube. And then move it to stash.

It is a complete time sink. You are sinfifxbrlt better off just keeping on MFing and by passing those chipped gems


that time isn't wasted if it's done while not mfing anyway (or if you have a degenerate gambling habit to feed). also, ctrl+click streamlines things a good deal. i admit, sometimes i pass them by when my inv is full though :)

https://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=91677887 wonder how much this one sold for! it's 1/1767920 chance but a 35 roll - higher than the one in the first link - is 1/160720. comparing it to a hoz, i'd say whether the 3 extra sockets outweigh the extra skills/stats on hoz is entirely subjective to the build. some people just like getting extra rare stuff, too, so regardless of actual use it comes down to what people are willing to pay.
Member
Posts: 74,658
Joined: Aug 3 2013
Gold: 3,211.11
Jan 6 2022 01:57am
Quote (0blique @ Jan 6 2022 01:51am)
that time isn't wasted if it's done while not mfing anyway (or if you have a degenerate gambling habit to feed). also, ctrl+click streamlines things a good deal. i admit, sometimes i pass them by when my inv is full though :)

https://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=91677887 wonder how much this one sold for! it's 1/1767920 chance but a 35 roll - higher than the one in the first link - is 1/160720. comparing it to a hoz, i'd say whether the 3 extra sockets outweigh the extra skills/stats on hoz is entirely subjective to the build. some people just like getting extra rare stuff, too, so regardless of actual use it comes down to what people are willing to pay.



Just to grab the gems from the ground for that 1/1.8million chance, not counting turning them jnto p gems and moving them to Cube and then moving sacred targe to cube. And then the 3 pgems. Etc etc. assuming each action takes a second, (agin this is human hand, not automated), there is roughly 10 additional steps. To do what you said would take 45,000 hours. Which is over 2 years of 40 hours a week, working 52 weeks in a year, to roll an item.

Assuming the person makes $10/hour, that’s a $45,000 item.



Come on dude. You are so clearly wrong.
Member
Posts: 74,658
Joined: Aug 3 2013
Gold: 3,211.11
Jan 6 2022 01:59am
Quote (Overpriced @ Jan 6 2022 01:57am)
Just to grab the gems from the ground for that 1/1.8million chance, not counting turning them jnto p gems and moving them to Cube and then moving sacred targe to cube. And then the 3 pgems. Etc etc. assuming each action takes a second, (agin this is human hand, not automated), there is roughly 10 additional steps. To do what you said would take 45,000 hours. Which is over 2 years of 40 hours a week, working 52 weeks in a year, to roll an item.

Assuming the person makes $10/hour, that’s a $45,000 item.



Come on dude. You are so clearly wrong.



Or 4500 hours, is 187 days rolling a sacred targe, 24 hours a day.



That doesn’t even count the time it takes to find all those flawless gems.


Just stop. It’s never effective to reroll items.
Member
Posts: 2,526
Joined: Aug 19 2007
Gold: 20.00
Jan 6 2022 02:16am
Quote (Overpriced @ Jan 6 2022 02:57am)
Just to grab the gems from the ground for that 1/1.8million chance, not counting turning them jnto p gems and moving them to Cube and then moving sacred targe to cube. And then the 3 pgems. Etc etc. assuming each action takes a second, (agin this is human hand, not automated), there is roughly 10 additional steps. To do what you said would take 45,000 hours. Which is over 2 years of 40 hours a week, working 52 weeks in a year, to roll an item.

Assuming the person makes $10/hour, that’s a $45,000 item.



Come on dude. You are so clearly wrong.


well if we're talking anecdotally about how i play, i don't cube up the chipped/normal/flawless for the shield. i roll the runic talons. i only use pgems i acquire from playing with people in-game for the sacred targe (also if i use a gem shrine and i have no flawless amethyst/ruby). also to make it clear, i never suggested cubing up gems for 45,000 hours lol. do you do that for your grandcharms? either way it's a gamble, you could work toward either reroll option for X time and still end up with nothing or something. and it's not solely for the 1/1.8 million chance - there are lots of other rolls that would be totally acceptable to trade/sell, even if it's not perfect (like a sub-45 life gc)

i would agree, if you had said it, that the value on those sacred targes is so high (really do wonder what that 45 res one went for) is probably in part due to the fact that not many people reroll them
Member
Posts: 4,929
Joined: Oct 15 2015
Gold: 14,350.00
Jan 6 2022 03:39am
Rerroling rares is only worth if you want something like 5nado 5oak pelt other than that is a total waste.

And by "worth" I mean that at least you a looking something that you can't get it from a regular drop, the time to get it and the amount of Pskull is still way to high to be worth, just let some bot to do the job and just buy it.
Go Back To Diablo 2 Discussion Topic List
Prev12
Add Reply New Topic New Poll