d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > Poe Vs D2r
Prev12
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 2,616
Joined: May 11 2021
Gold: 1,433.00
Sep 10 2024 08:46am
Poe has trash pvp which is the real endgame unless you're content brainlessly bashing pixels.
Member
Posts: 29,372
Joined: Apr 4 2010
Gold: 0.89
Warn: 10%
Sep 10 2024 12:31pm
Always imitated
Never intimidated
Playability unlimited
One day you'll get it kid


Member
Posts: 9
Joined: May 22 2024
Gold: 0.00
Sep 10 2024 01:57pm
Yes I played classic last ladder WW Barb and it was an amazing experience, but converting to expansion was rough..

Not trying to trash D2R I still love it, but as someone who plays SSF mainly POE was just a much better leveling experience for me and much more endgame to get lost in.
Just want to pick the brain of the community I am still a noob.

I will always come back to D2R for vibes and nostalgia. I think I do just need to play more offline, but I get Ladder Fomo.

Also just trying to recommend POE for those who haven't tried it, it's free which baffles me in a time like now.
Member
Posts: 31,116
Joined: Jul 1 2008
Gold: 15,503.67
Sep 11 2024 07:24am
Played Poe but I really hate how skills are on items and the leveling grid. Also the pvp sucks
Member
Posts: 10,012
Joined: May 11 2024
Gold: 230,805.00
Sep 11 2024 05:42pm
d2lod > both
Member
Posts: 11
Joined: Sep 11 2024
Gold: 710.00
Sep 11 2024 06:54pm
I'm just waiting for PoE2, maybe it will be the ARPG we all want xD
Member
Posts: 2,809
Joined: Sep 2 2021
Gold: 26,091.08
Sep 11 2024 08:38pm
I recently hit 1k hours in PoE and I have way more than 1k in d2 and d2r each. My issue with PoE is the way that loot works in the endgame is extremely boring unless you like to craft. Your entire farming experience is based on div/hour instead of finding good or cool items, unless you are bossing where you find the same items over and over and just hope for good rolls. In D2, there are so many items you want to pick up because they have the potential to be GG. In PoE, you basically filter out every item in the game that drops. I like both games quite a bit, but that is why I always come back to D2.
Also, I've basically never even seen anyone wanting to PvP in PoE.

This post was edited by vonweiden on Sep 11 2024 08:40pm
Member
Posts: 9,759
Joined: Apr 6 2022
Gold: 209.69
Sep 11 2024 08:47pm
Poe > d2r > lod
Member
Posts: 9,415
Joined: Jan 1 2007
Gold: 0.00
Sep 12 2024 01:02am
Quote (can1playwithmadness @ Sep 10 2024 01:52am)
I just played POE for the first time and I am wondering why people still play D2R? Poe is like D2 but so much more fun and not broken. You can actually progress through the campaign and after only once your in the end game which is insanely expansive.

Then we have D2R, where if your not a hammerdin you have to respect 2 to 3 times to reach endgame, then tirelessly farm for gear for thousands of runs. You constantly hit brick walls and then you can't even play certain areas of hell based on your build.

Then there's trading, D2R is so trade dependent it's basically just the most expensive pay to win game on the market. This makes this game super classist. Over-Privileged people just buy their gear and skip the entire game just to get on a leader board? Poe has trading but I never felt the need to use it, and it doesn't seem like the community is exploiting it like the elitists at D2R. I think trading just ruins these types of games and gives an unfair advantage to the rich.


Nostalgia, PoE has a painful learning curve, animations seem janky even in comparison to the original d2. Other than that I enjoyed PoE, felt different and really fun. Each brings something different but I understand where you are coming from. PoE was novel whereas d2 is relaxingly familiar. Also Pvp on d2 is great, never seen much of that on PoE from my experience.

This post was edited by kamkla on Sep 12 2024 01:03am
Member
Posts: 1,985
Joined: Sep 11 2024
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Sep 12 2024 01:24pm
Poe ftw
Go Back To Diablo 2 Discussion Topic List
Prev12
Add Reply New Topic New Poll