d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > World Football - Soccer > Fc Barcelona > Discuss - Love Or Hate
Prev1432433434435436733Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 31,053
Joined: Jul 29 2006
Gold: 127,773.00
Sep 28 2015 05:39am
Quote (excellence @ 26 Sep 2015 17:23)
Messi out 2 months, Neymar destined for prison, this is Suarez's team going forward it seems :O

does it matter?

if catalonia seperates from spain, you may as well close the thread :santa:
Member
Posts: 57,983
Joined: Jan 12 2006
Gold: 5,104.00
Sep 28 2015 06:44am
Quote (darki99 @ 28 Sep 2015 13:39)
does it matter?

if catalonia seperates from spain, you may as well close the thread :santa:


After the VW saga, is there any reason to take seriously anything a german guy says ?
Member
Posts: 24,082
Joined: Oct 5 2006
Gold: 45.00
Sep 28 2015 07:01am
Quote (B4al @ Sep 28 2015 12:44pm)
After the VW saga, is there any reason to take seriously anything a german guy says ?


Serious question doe. What would happen to barca if catalonia was it's own country?
Member
Posts: 31,053
Joined: Jul 29 2006
Gold: 127,773.00
Sep 28 2015 07:08am
Quote (B4al @ 28 Sep 2015 13:44)
After the VW saga, is there any reason to take seriously anything a german guy says ?

last time i checked barcelona was the capital of catalonia. pm him http://forums.d2jsp.org/user.php?i=843054 for more info i guess.

you might as well blame pep for voting yes, if the lfp should throw out barcelona


Member
Posts: 16,144
Joined: Aug 17 2008
Gold: 175.00
Sep 28 2015 07:19am
I dont know if you guys realise but Cardiff and Swansea play in the English league system no problem ... so I doubt it would change for Barcelona,Barcelona is extremely important to la liga and generates alot of £ for spain so Spain would make exception and bring them in.

Unless ofcourse the spanish a really pissed off and said no, this imo would probably never happen for reasons posted above
Member
Posts: 15,619
Joined: Aug 4 2010
Gold: Locked
Sep 28 2015 07:27am
Quote (aswethegods @ Sep 28 2015 09:19am)
I dont know if you guys realise but Cardiff and Swansea play in the English league system no problem ... so I doubt it would change for Barcelona,Barcelona is extremely important to la liga and generates alot of £ for spain so Spain would make exception and bring them in.

Unless ofcourse the spanish a really pissed off and said no, this imo would probably never happen for reasons posted above



€ I believe they use in Spain,
Member
Posts: 24,082
Joined: Oct 5 2006
Gold: 45.00
Sep 28 2015 07:50am
Quote (aswethegods @ Sep 28 2015 01:19pm)
I dont know if you guys realise but Cardiff and Swansea play in the English league system no problem ... so I doubt it would change for Barcelona,Barcelona is extremely important to la liga and generates alot of £ for spain so Spain would make exception and bring them in.

Unless ofcourse the spanish a really pissed off and said no, this imo would probably never happen for reasons posted above


But the UK is one big happy family. I don't think Spain and catalonia would be the same. But of course money always talks. They wouldn't want to pull a Scotland and cut off their nose to spite their face.
Member
Posts: 57,983
Joined: Jan 12 2006
Gold: 5,104.00
Sep 28 2015 07:55am
Quote (WNxIrvine @ 28 Sep 2015 15:01)
Serious question doe. What would happen to barca if catalonia was it's own country?


Won't ever happen. It's like saying what would happen to Arsenal if Arsene won the title ?
Member
Posts: 28,849
Joined: Mar 8 2010
Gold: 2,570.91
Sep 28 2015 08:00am
Quote (aswethegods @ 28 Sep 2015 15:19)
I dont know if you guys realise but Cardiff and Swansea play in the English league system no problem ... so I doubt it would change for Barcelona,Barcelona is extremely important to la liga and generates alot of £ for spain so Spain would make exception and bring them in.

Unless ofcourse the spanish a really pissed off and said no, this imo would probably never happen for reasons posted above


Well, La Liga's president already said that there won't be any foreign clubs playing in the league.

It's a different case to Swansea/Cardiff. First of all, there's a law in Spain that doesn't allow foreign clubs to compete in spanish competitions (except for Andorra, since it's a microstate with extremely limited resources).

Secondly, there are UEFA regulations which I once explained here before:

Quote (zarkadon @ 13 Oct 2014 22:41)
still waaaaaaaaay closer than Las Palmas or Tenerife though

in any case, iirc, UEFA regulation does not allow teams to play in leagues from outside of their country unless:

-their country didn't already have their own league, and the clubs from that country had been playing in a foreign league previous to the creation of this new league (like when the welsh premier league was created and welsh clubs were allowed to remain in the english football system if they wanted to)... this exception would allow Barça to choose between a catalan league and La Liga (however they wouldn't really have the choice to play in La Liga since spanish legislation doesn't allow it)

-their country doesn't have a league of its own because the country doesn't have the minimum of 8 teams registered in their FA (like Monaco playing in Ligue 1 because of this, or several clubs from Liechtenstein playing in Switzerland)... wouldn't be the case as there are hundreds of catalan teams

-the club would financially struggle to pay travel costs if they played in their country's league (basicly applies to amateur clubs from towns located on the borders between countries)... obviously not Barça's case


so, if catalonia were to split from the rest of Spain, the only thing that could prevent Barça from ending up playing in a catalan league would be a change in spanish laws

I'm almost certain those are the only 3 cases. I went to a series of conferences on UEFA and FIFA regulations, and I remember about this. However that was like 8 years ago, so it might have changed, but it doesn't seem likely

independence won't happen anyway though
Member
Posts: 24,082
Joined: Oct 5 2006
Gold: 45.00
Sep 28 2015 08:22am
Quote (B4al @ Sep 28 2015 01:55pm)
Won't ever happen. It's like saying what would happen to Arsenal if Arsene won the title ?


Are you saying independence wouldn't ever happen or barca wouldn't ever be kicked out of La liga cuz I really can't tell?
Go Back To World Football - Soccer Topic List
Prev1432433434435436733Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll