d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > World Football - Soccer > Manchester United > Match & General Discussion
Prev1296329642965296629673163Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Views: 440676Replies: 31621Track Topic
Member
Posts: 24,082
Joined: Oct 5 2006
Gold: 45.00
#29641
Aug 26 2019 08:51am
Quote (piatek @ Aug 26 2019 06:08am)
Harry Kane https://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/cvb4eb/var_rules_no_penalty_for_harry_kane_vs_newcastle/

Silva https://www.reddit.com/r/MCFC/comments/cv95m6/how_is_this_not_a_penalty_i_have_to_admit_im_not/

They hide behind the 'clear and obvious error' ruling to protect the referee, even though not awarding a penalty when it is one is a clear and obvious error.

They have some stupid rule where the VAR team has to factor in what the referee might have been thinking when they made the call, then decide if it's a clear error or if the referee is justified in getting it wrong... Then they have to uphold the incorrect decision if the referee's mistake wasn't egregious enough.

Why not just let the VAR team review each incident on its own merit, with slow motion replay and multiple camera angles, then let the referee know what to award. Is it that hard?


People are already complaining VAR takes too long. It isn't there to do the refs job for them, it's there for ABSOLUTE certain decisions, "the var team" will still look at an incident and be split on whether it's a penalty or not, just like when reviewing the game after the pundits rarely come to the same conclusion. It should be used for offsides and handballs and anything the ref hasn't seen, like someone getting twatted off the ball. Having the var team review all slow motion replays is farcical, you could be 5 minutes back into the game before a decision is made. :lol:
Member
Posts: 2,121
Joined: Apr 8 2019
Gold: 174.33
#29642
Aug 26 2019 09:35am
Quote (WNxIrvine @ Aug 26 2019 03:51pm)
People are already complaining VAR takes too long. It isn't there to do the refs job for them, it's there for ABSOLUTE certain decisions, "the var team" will still look at an incident and be split on whether it's a penalty or not, just like when reviewing the game after the pundits rarely come to the same conclusion. It should be used for offsides and handballs and anything the ref hasn't seen, like someone getting twatted off the ball. Having the var team review all slow motion replays is farcical, you could be 5 minutes back into the game before a decision is made. :lol:

It wouldn't take any more time, they already review it to see if a clear and obvious mistake was made, so it would take the exact same amount of time. In each of the instances linked, they stopped the game temporarily during the check.

This post was edited by piatek on Aug 26 2019 09:36am
Banned
Posts: 105,543
Joined: Aug 23 2005
Gold: 4,043.00
Warn: 10%
#29643
Aug 27 2019 02:11am
It's not even September and all the goodwill created by start of the new season has already evaporated :lol:

Sure we were unlucky to lose, but Palace have probably the worst forward line in the Prem, conceding once is careless, twice is just unforgivable.
Member
Posts: 19,738
Joined: Oct 1 2008
Gold: 2.00
#29644
Aug 27 2019 09:22am
the whole var thing is just lame right now.
couldnt the var just tell that inept ref that dan james got caught indeed and didnt dive? -_-


isnt this clear and obvious?

This post was edited by ChaoCheeBye on Aug 27 2019 09:24am
Member
Posts: 53,368
Joined: Sep 2 2004
Gold: 57.00
#29645
Aug 27 2019 04:29pm
Alexis likely off to Inter on loan

sooo who is gonna be the other forward who can score with any consistency? Greenwood is 17, only Rooney was scoring with some frequency at that age the last 20 years :rofl:
Banned
Posts: 105,543
Joined: Aug 23 2005
Gold: 4,043.00
Warn: 10%
#29646
Aug 28 2019 02:11am
Loan is the worst possible solution to the Sanchez problem - he's still at the club, we'll have to subside his wages and we're left very short up front with transfer window closed <_<
Member
Posts: 19,738
Joined: Oct 1 2008
Gold: 2.00
#29647
Aug 29 2019 02:38am
Quote (Pozer @ Aug 28 2019 04:11pm)
Loan is the worst possible solution to the Sanchez problem - he's still at the club, we'll have to subside his wages and we're left very short up front with transfer window closed <_<


Quote (excellence @ Aug 28 2019 06:29am)
Alexis likely off to Inter on loan

sooo who is gonna be the other forward who can score with any consistency? Greenwood is 17, only Rooney was scoring with some frequency at that age the last 20 years :rofl:


this is probably done to appease de gea, pogba, martial and basically anyone in the team that earns less but contributed more than alexis. which is probably 90% of the team :rofl:
just get rid and get alexis out of sight.
Member
Posts: 54,178
Joined: Nov 2 2006
Gold: 62.69
#29648
Aug 29 2019 03:07am
Sanchez to United has to have been one of the worst transfers in premier league history. The guy completely lost it.

Wonder what would have happened if he had stayed or went to City :mellow:
Member
Posts: 54,178
Joined: Nov 2 2006
Gold: 62.69
#29649
Aug 29 2019 03:08am
Smalling to Roma :lol:
Banned
Posts: 105,543
Joined: Aug 23 2005
Gold: 4,043.00
Warn: 10%
#29650
Aug 29 2019 03:29am
Quote (ChaoCheeBye @ Aug 29 2019 09:38am)
this is probably done to appease de gea, pogba, martial and basically anyone in the team that earns less but contributed more than alexis. which is probably 90% of the team :rofl:
just get rid and get alexis out of sight.
Not sure it's gonna appease anyone, it's actually a sweeter gig - get paid more than most of the team to actually not live and play football in rainy Manchester, instead enjoy Italian life.
Go Back To World Football - Soccer Topic List
Prev1296329642965296629673163Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll

© 2003-2026 d2jsp  Contact