d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > World Football - Soccer > Rene Higuita
Prev123
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 150,017
Joined: May 8 2005
Gold: 5,100.00
Jul 20 2014 08:42am
Quote (Leonor @ 20 Jul 2014 14:38)
Many times chosen the best goalkeeper in The Americas.


separating GK skill and FK skill he won't be even close to top 10 GK-skill-wise

This post was edited by Andi on Jul 20 2014 08:42am
Member
Posts: 13,173
Joined: Nov 30 2006
Gold: 641.00
Jul 20 2014 08:44am
Quote (zarkadon @ 20 Jul 2014 16:27)
One of the best keepers of the 90s, but not one of the best overall.

imo the 90s were pretty bad years if we look at the keepers. Yes, there were some great keepers, but most of them played for lesser, or at least not the top-top, teams.

Preud'homme played for Mechelen and Benfica
Chilavert for Vélez
Zenga for Inter (which iirc only won 1 trophy during the 90s) and later Sampdoria
Buffon played for Parma

You could even argue about Schmeichel and Van der Saar. Man Utd was a big club in England, but they coudn't compete with the better teams in europe until the end of the 90s; and Ajax was one of the best clubs of Europe for a few years during the 90s, but they weren't during the rest of the time van der Saar spent the there.

Most top clubs had good/decent keepers like Perruzzi, Rossi, Zubizarreta, Illgner, etc; none of them were really outstanding imo. The dominant teams pretty much relied on good defenses.

The only real exception I can think off atm was Kahn at Bayern.

I mean, whenever someoene lists the top keepers of the 90s you often see  Taffarel, Barthez and Seaman on the list; it pretty much shows how dissapointing that decade was in terms of keepers.


Edwin was in goal in the 95 champions league victory aswell as the 96 penalty shootout loss. Ajax were unbeaten in the Eredivisie in their '94 '95 season, he started most of those matches.
Member
Posts: 54,178
Joined: Nov 2 2006
Gold: 62.69
Jul 20 2014 08:48am
Quote (zarkadon @ Jul 20 2014 03:27pm)
One of the best keepers of the 90s, but not one of the best overall.

imo the 90s were pretty bad years if we look at the keepers. Yes, there were some great keepers, but most of them played for lesser, or at least not the top-top, teams.

Preud'homme played for Mechelen and Benfica
Chilavert for Vélez
Zenga for Inter (which iirc only won 1 trophy during the 90s) and later Sampdoria
Buffon played for Parma

You could even argue about Schmeichel and Van der Saar. Man Utd was a big club in England, but they coudn't compete with the better teams in europe until the end of the 90s; and Ajax was one of the best clubs of Europe for a few years during the 90s, but they weren't during the rest of the time van der Saar spent the there.

Most top clubs had good/decent keepers like Perruzzi, Rossi, Zubizarreta, Illgner, etc; none of them were really outstanding imo. The dominant teams pretty much relied on good defenses.

The only real exception I can think off atm was Kahn at Bayern.

I mean, whenever someoene lists the top keepers of the 90s you often see  Taffarel, Barthez and Seaman on the list; it pretty much shows how dissapointing that decade was in terms of keepers.


Mechelen was pretty damn good back then, I agree with you tho.
My boy Preud'homme B)
Member
Posts: 28,849
Joined: Mar 8 2010
Gold: 2,570.91
Jul 20 2014 09:12am
Quote (CpTJenJen @ 20 Jul 2014 16:44)
Edwin was in goal in the 95 champions league victory aswell as the 96 penalty shootout loss. Ajax were unbeaten in the Eredivisie in their '94 '95 season, he started most of those matches.


I said Ajax was one of the best club in the world for a few years... and those are exactly the seasons I meant. Ajax wasn't that great during the other years Edwin spent there.
Member
Posts: 6,382
Joined: Feb 28 2008
Gold: 480.00
Jul 21 2014 05:27am
probably one of the most entertaining keepers to watch with his frequent dribbles and wild moves.

Not sure exactly how good he is a keeper though
Banned
Posts: 17,987
Joined: Jul 31 2009
Gold: 655.01
Warn: 10%
Jul 21 2014 05:35am
Quote (xPGen @ Jul 20 2014 11:19am)
Duckadam

Oliver kahn


Kahn was already in my list bruv.

Quote (ampoo @ Jul 20 2014 10:44am)
legend

kahn is the best ever though B)


Dino Zoff easily B)
Member
Posts: 28,849
Joined: Mar 8 2010
Gold: 2,570.91
Jul 21 2014 05:47am
Quote (Deathdot @ 21 Jul 2014 13:27)
probably one of the most entertaining keepers to watch with his frequent dribbles and wild moves.

Not sure exactly how good he is a keeper though


He was decent during his peak but mediocre for the most part. He was horrid for Valladolid, the only club he played for outside Colombia during his carrer iirc.

If he hadn't been such an excentric sweeper-keeper and a freekick/pk taker, he'd be unknown outside Colombia.
Member
Posts: 222,352
Joined: Nov 27 2012
Gold: 2,898.14
Jul 21 2014 05:52am
Nobody know duckadam :lol:
Member
Posts: 28,849
Joined: Mar 8 2010
Gold: 2,570.91
Jul 21 2014 06:07am
Quote (xPGen @ 21 Jul 2014 13:52)
Nobody know duckadam :lol:


A clean sheet during a pk shootout in a CL final, it can't get much better than that.

And against Barça aswell B)
Go Back To World Football - Soccer Topic List
Prev123
Add Reply New Topic New Poll