Quote (fender @ 25 Aug 2015 18:26)

true on the one hand, on the other hand you could limit those video challenges per game, say like each team has one per half or something...

Quote (darki99 @ 25 Aug 2015 20:58)

some1 watched tennis :D

the problem is where to start, and where to finish. what you can review?

then we have a similar situation to american football. where each team has guys in the stands sitting in front of monitors, telling the coach when to throw a challenge flag ...

it would hurt the flow of the game, leave it as it is imo. on american football the whole system somehow makes sense, because there is no flow. tennis is point after point, doesn't hurt either. football tho, it hurts the nature of the game.

Quote (darki99 @ Aug 25 2015 06:58pm)

some1 watched tennis :D

the problem is where to start, and where to finish. what you can review?

then we have a similar situation to american football. where each team has guys in the stands sitting in front of monitors, telling the coach when to throw a challenge flag ...

it would hurt the flow of the game, leave it as it is imo. on american football the whole system somehow makes sense, because there is no flow. tennis is point after point, doesn't hurt either. football tho, it hurts the nature of the game.

Quote (fender @ 25 Aug 2015 19:26)

true on the one hand, on the other hand you could limit those video challenges per game, say like each team has one per half or something...

the problem i see is: what if the video challenge says it wasn't offside? count it as goal? as free kick? the defense could always claim they stopped playing because the assistant raised the flag...
or change the rules that no offside is ever called and after the situation is over, the assistant says "i think it was offside" and then this can be challenged? nah...

for offsides it's not good imo. however, for foul calls, penalty situations, hand ball situations i'm in favour of (limited) video challenges...

Quote (Mr_Mill @ 25 Aug 2015 23:57)

Scum vs Arsenal in the carling cup B)

Quote (ampoo @ 25 Aug 2015 22:58)

so hard to guess who you are talking about
trollface.jpg