What would be your order guys?

Saw a video of carragher and Neville discussing this and wondered ...

Mine would be : gerrard > scholes > lampard

However IMO there is very little between them I think gerrard and scholes can influence a game more than lampard

scholes would be my pick.

He was instumental for united the past 10 years.

Gerrard was meh, always choking big games.
Lampard great box to boxer 5-7 years ago.

i think scholes is pretty overrated to be honest...
i'd say gerrard > lampard >>> scholes

so untrue

for me I'd have a Gerrard in his prime, like during the time Torres was at L'pool. Scholes was just as good (if not better) than Gerrard but he was very one dimensional ...couldn't tackle, keep his cool, or score many goals

id take lampard over both of them.

goals win you trophies, and hes the best scoring midfield in premiership history.

He took way more pens than Gerrard, there were many penalty takers at Liverpool throughout the years whereas he was always Chelsea's

penalties = goals.

1. Lampard
2. Scholes
3. Gerrard.

Though this is basically like comparing the Mercedes S-class, the Audi A7/A8 and the BMW 7-series..

This post was edited by MGS4BestGameEverMade on Sep 17 2014 01:48pm

Scholes

Always Scholes..

Scholes>Gerrard>Lampard, thats just my personal opinion however.