d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Football & Rugby > Is There A Case To Not Pick Cmc #1?
1235Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 14,728
Joined: Jul 10 2016
Gold: 33,166.00
Aug 30 2024 11:10am
I'm thinking of taking hall first overall. .5 PPR 12 man

Some of my reasons include

Calf injury - we don't know the true severity
Trent Williams hold out
Mileage - imo he's due for an injury with how much he gets used
No one has repeated as the #1 fantasy asset since LT


Or am I overthinking this?
Member
Posts: 62,534
Joined: Aug 15 2012
Gold: 60,735.00
Aug 30 2024 11:15am
It’s a risky play but I think Hall is RB1 this year. CMC will take a step back but I dont think he’ll be far behind.
Member
Posts: 12,977
Joined: Oct 30 2020
Gold: 0.00
Aug 30 2024 11:33am
on the cover of Madden.
Member
Posts: 14,728
Joined: Jul 10 2016
Gold: 33,166.00
Aug 30 2024 11:33am
Quote (Cbramgar @ Aug 30 2024 10:33am)
on the cover of Madden.


Mahomie broke that curse
Member
Posts: 12,977
Joined: Oct 30 2020
Gold: 0.00
Aug 30 2024 12:58pm
Quote (Jihn420 @ Aug 30 2024 10:33am)
Mahomie broke that curse


:bonk:
Member
Posts: 1,710
Joined: Feb 29 2024
Gold: 200.00
Aug 30 2024 01:15pm
I'm thinking the same, if I had the first overall draft pick, I'd choose Hall too over CMC. You pointed our my biggest concern: Mileage - imo he's due for an injury with how much he gets used
Member
Posts: 72,632
Joined: Mar 20 2007
Gold: 7,623.00
Aug 30 2024 08:01pm
if you're not taking CMC you're taking Lamb
Member
Posts: 32,507
Joined: Jan 28 2007
Gold: 44,500.00
Aug 31 2024 04:35am
PPR I’d go Hill or Lamb

0.5 Hall

I’m not on the CMC train this year
Member
Posts: 2,305
Joined: Dec 26 2015
Gold: 35.00
Aug 31 2024 08:49am
Lamb all day.
Member
Posts: 14,728
Joined: Jul 10 2016
Gold: 33,166.00
Aug 31 2024 10:54am
Quote (ZeaLORDeaL @ Aug 30 2024 07:01pm)
if you're not taking CMC you're taking Lamb


Quote (joshd21 @ Aug 31 2024 03:35am)
PPR I’d go Hill or Lamb

0.5 Hall

I’m not on the CMC train this year


Quote (SafeTrades @ Aug 31 2024 07:49am)
Lamb all day.


I don't value lamb as #1 overall but thanks for the input!
Go Back To Football & Rugby Topic List
1235Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll