I'm thinking of taking hall first overall. .5 PPR 12 man

Some of my reasons include

Calf injury - we don't know the true severity
Trent Williams hold out
Mileage - imo he's due for an injury with how much he gets used
No one has repeated as the #1 fantasy asset since LT


Or am I overthinking this?

It’s a risky play but I think Hall is RB1 this year. CMC will take a step back but I dont think he’ll be far behind.

on the cover of Madden.

Mahomie broke that curse

I'm thinking the same, if I had the first overall draft pick, I'd choose Hall too over CMC. You pointed our my biggest concern: Mileage - imo he's due for an injury with how much he gets used

if you're not taking CMC you're taking Lamb

PPR I’d go Hill or Lamb

0.5 Hall

I’m not on the CMC train this year

Lamb all day.

I don't value lamb as #1 overall but thanks for the input!