d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Football & Rugby > Official Philadelphia Eagles Fan Thread
Prev18889909192416Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 57,247
Joined: Oct 14 2010
Gold: 57,475.92
Feb 5 2018 09:33pm
Quote (OdellRectum @ Feb 5 2018 09:09pm)
Obviously it’s a touchdown but with all the bullshit that’s gone on with that rule and the refs blowing New England constantly, would you have been surprised if it was overturned?


Clement one was questionable if you judge the last foot placement off the whole foot and not the heel.
Ertz one could have been called back to the 1 yard line if they ruled he lost control going for the endzone.
1 . 2 . 3 steps 1 yard line then roll
Member
Posts: 17,747
Joined: Jul 12 2011
Gold: 69.00
Feb 5 2018 09:57pm
Quote (Applecrack @ Feb 5 2018 10:33pm)
Clement one was questionable if you judge the last foot placement off the whole foot and not the heel.
Ertz one could have been called back to the 1 yard line if they ruled he lost control going for the endzone.
1 . 2 . 3 steps 1 yard line then roll



Ertz one was unquestionable. Touchdown for sure
Member
Posts: 7,074
Joined: Jul 17 2007
Gold: 653.81
Feb 5 2018 10:16pm
Quote (Applecrack @ Feb 5 2018 10:33pm)
Clement one was questionable if you judge the last foot placement off the whole foot and not the heel.
Ertz one could have been called back to the 1 yard line if they ruled he lost control going for the endzone.
1 . 2 . 3 steps 1 yard line then roll


The nerve.
Member
Posts: 57,247
Joined: Oct 14 2010
Gold: 57,475.92
Feb 5 2018 10:19pm
Quote (OdellRectum @ Feb 5 2018 09:57pm)
Ertz one was unquestionable. Touchdown for sure


I think they should have called it a fumble recovery for a td lol.
Its like 2/3 he gets it regardless.
Member
Posts: 150,022
Joined: Apr 19 2005
Gold: 290.11
Feb 5 2018 10:49pm
Quote (Applecrack @ Feb 5 2018 11:33pm)
Clement one was questionable if you judge the last foot placement off the whole foot and not the heel.
Ertz one could have been called back to the 1 yard line if they ruled he lost control going for the endzone.
1 . 2 . 3 steps 1 yard line then roll


What???

You have got to be kidding me lol
Member
Posts: 23,451
Joined: Jan 7 2009
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 80%
Feb 5 2018 10:58pm
Quote (Applecrack @ Feb 5 2018 11:33pm)
Clement one was questionable if you judge the last foot placement off the whole foot and not the heel.
Ertz one could have been called back to the 1 yard line if they ruled he lost control going for the endzone.
1 . 2 . 3 steps 1 yard line then roll


Ertz one is 100% a TD and i'm a pats fan. He's definitely a runner at that point.

Clement one was meh, you gotta stand with the original call, which was a TD. NFL has been a little inconsistent with ruling this type of catch.
Member
Posts: 15,839
Joined: Jul 27 2009
Gold: 805.00
Feb 5 2018 11:03pm
Quote (WatcherOfTheSkies @ Feb 6 2018 12:58am)
Ertz one is 100% a TD and i'm a pats fan. He's definitely a runner at that point.

Clement one was meh, you gotta stand with the original call, which was a TD. NFL has been a little inconsistent with ruling this type of catch.


im honestly shocked we got both of those calls. Clement one i was more nervous about. He caught the ball and controlled it but the nose of the ball was sticking out a bit as he got his first foot down. He moved the ball to his other arm and fully controlled it while getting the second foot down and then the third step was out of bounds. I figured they were going to say he didnt have complete control until he switched it to his other arm and didnt get his second foot down in bounds.

Ertz was hands down a touchdown like you said. He caught the ball and took 3 steps and then dove. He wasn't in the process of making the catch while coming to the ground (although the same can be said about dez a few years back and jesse james as well.)
Member
Posts: 40,753
Joined: Apr 10 2008
Gold: 106.80
Feb 5 2018 11:11pm
This applecrack dude might be that guy you knew was in the special class but couldn't understand why til he spoke.
Member
Posts: 57,247
Joined: Oct 14 2010
Gold: 57,475.92
Feb 6 2018 12:13am
That Clement one was just sketchy.
Like I said I feel they got lucky and had a few things go their way in the 1st half that let them stay ahead.

Still glad to see them get a trophy.
Member
Posts: 4,569
Joined: Jul 27 2011
Gold: 0.00
Feb 6 2018 12:59am
That throw to Clement was a dime... foles was killing it
Go Back To Football & Rugby Topic List
Prev18889909192416Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll