Quote (kargus @ Aug 12 2012 12:41am)
For many years, fantasy football teams were built around running backs to the point that many owners would rarely consider taking a player at a position other than a running back with one of their first two draft picks.
That mindset may change this season, as current ESPN Live Draft results show quarterbacks being selected with three of the top seven picks and five of the first 17 picks on average.
With the increased cost of quarterbacks, many fantasy owners are going to be looking for undervalued passers who can be had for a relatively low price but have the point potential to far exceed their cost.
Here are six candidates who look to fit that bill:
Matt Schaub, Houston Texans
Average draft position (ADP): 89.7 (ranked 14th among quarterbacks)
The first thought that comes to most fantasy players' minds when Schaub's name is mentioned is injury. This is understandable given that Schaub has played in 11 or fewer games in three of his five seasons in Houston.
While he does have durability concerns, Schaub also has top-flight productivity potential.
Before he got hurt, Schaub was on pace to post a 240-point season despite not having the services of Andre Johnson for six of his 10 games. Only nine passers tallied more than 240 points last season, and if Johnson had been healthy, it's certainly possible Schaub could have moved that number even higher.
Schaub didn't miss a game in the two seasons prior to last year, so the injury history of late has actually been more in his favor than against it. Throw in the fact that my draft guide says Schaub has the most favorable schedule of any quarterback in the league, and it means he offers third- or fourth-round point potential for an eighth- or ninth-round pick.
Philip Rivers, San Diego Chargers
ADP: 60.1 (ranked 10th)
As was recently noted in an article detailing why the Chargers should be considered the favorites to win the AFC West, Rivers' perceived drop-off last year was nowhere near as large as generally thought.
He racked up 7.9 overall yards per attempt (YPA), a total that was ninth best in the league and achieved it on 601 attempts (if penalty plays are included). He also accounted for 28 touchdowns, had 216 vertical pass attempts (tied for third highest in the league) and a 12.0 vertical YPA that ranked ninth best.
The Chargers lost Vincent Jackson to free agency, but they still have a very deep wide receiver corps and could be looking at a turnaround campaign from Antonio Gates.
Rivers ended the 2011 season with 12 touchdowns and three interceptions over his last six games and posted 19 or more fantasy points in three of those contests, so he was getting back to his old self by the end of that campaign. That trend is likely to continue this year, and it makes Rivers a steal at pick No. 60.
Alex Smith, San Francisco 49ers
ADP: 119.2 (ranked 17th)
With the roster additions of Mario Manningham, Randy Moss and A.J. Jenkins, and the improved health of Michael Crabtree, it can safely be said that no team in the NFL has done more to upgrade its pass-catching personnel than San Francisco.
That probably won't be enough to vault Smith to the level of a dominant fantasy quarterback, if for no other reason than 49ers head coach Jim Harbaugh operates a run-heavy offense that likely won't allow Smith to tally much more than 500 pass attempts.
Even with that ceiling, Smith's prior history of superb performance shows that he can be one of those rare quarterbacks to post a high YPA total on a relatively low volume of attempts. That makes him a great later-round pick for leagues that have two quarterbacks or give six points for passing touchdowns.
Carson Palmer, Oakland Raiders
ADP: 137.7 (ranked 21st)
In looking for a backup quarterback, wouldn't it be great to have someone who is capable of posting 15 or more points a high percentage of the time?
If that sounds like a good definition for a QB2, Palmer should be on your draft radar screen, because he racked up 15 or more points in six of his nine starts last season.
He was able to do this in part because he ranked fifth in the league in overall YPA (8.3), tied for ninth in vertical YPA (12.0) and ranked eighth in stretch vertical YPA (14.5), as well as placing 11th in ESPN's Total QBR metric.
That Palmer was able to perform at such a high statistical level despite taking over the silver and black offense in midseason is quite extraordinary. With a full offseason under his belt, he should be able to make the adjustment to the Raiders' new West Coast offensive scheme and take full advantage of the stockpile of young receiving talent on the Oakland roster. That makes Palmer another terrific later-round selection for leagues that give six points for passing touchdowns or have two starting quarterbacks each week.
Brandon Weeden, Cleveland Browns
ADP: undrafted (ranked 28th)
In his career at Oklahoma State, Weeden displayed above-average or better showings in overall metrics, consistency, career growth, ability to raise the level of play of those around him and big-game performance.
He is taking the same kind of bull-by-the-horns approach to his new job in Cleveland, and it's just the type of mindset the Browns offense needs to shake itself out of its lethargy.
The state of the Cleveland receiving corps means Weeden may not offer quite enough upside to invest a draft pick in most leagues, but he has ample value as a waiver-wire pick in standard leagues, as a backup quarterback in a deep league or as a QB3 in multiquarterback leagues.
Potential rare value pick
Peyton Manning, Denver Broncos
ADP: 41.4 (ranked 8th)
Manning couldn't be listed with the above picks because his current ADP of 41.4 is generally considered to be a good risk/reward investment level for him.
Having said that, in the most recent ESPN experts' 10-team mock draft, Manning lasted until the end of the eighth round when Team Karabell picked him.
The likely reason he was passed over for so many rounds is a combination of two factors -- the depth of quality quarterbacks in the draft and the recurring concerns over his arm strength. The reports coming out of Denver have basically all had the same theme: Manning is in many ways back to his old form, with the exception of long passes. He still has to prove he can have a bigger impact in the vertical game than he did in his last full NFL season, when he posted a 9.7 vertical YPA that ranked 26th in the league.
Those factors could very well lead to a similar draft-day drop for Manning in many draft rooms and thus place him into the value-pick realm.