nice DT pick

I hope we'll pick up more OL'd later on

Well, Robinson got new OC so who know he might perform better.

At this point I'm starting to doubt the entire New York Giants organization along with it's fans... Xnoz you can't seriously think we don't need a LT? Also, you can't seriously have wanted Ebron or Donald... The smallest TE and DTs in the draft... Also, Zack Martin is a Justin Pugh clone lol.. We don't need anymore tweener offensive lineman with short arms. We need big lengthy tackles.

We should have traded up to get Lewan. It's a travesty what the Giants have done in this draft. Sticking to their fucking Syracuse and BC roots.. While I absolutely love Andre Williams, taking him before they get a true tackle is absurd.

We literally have ZERO NFL offensive tackles on our roster. And of course, they aren't going to pick up Seantrel Henderson now because of that dumbass Will Hill. There goes a possible starting LT for us.

The fact that they have not addressed their OT problems in this draft so far shows how piss poor their scouting is.

And on top of it, they draft the wrong safety. The only pick I'm not disgusted with is Weston Richburg.

The only team we outdrafted in our own division is Dallas lol.. Hopefully they prove me wrong.

This is how I would have liked this draft to go so far

Round 1 pick 8 or 9 - Taylor Lewan via trade for NYG 12, 2015 3 and 2015 6 or something like that
Round 2 pick 43 - Troy Niklas or C.J. Fiedorowicz
Round 3 pick 74 - Kareem Martin or one of the many big interior lineman available (Long, Linder etc.)
Round 4 pick 113 - Andre Williams or could have gone safety here (Boston, Reynolds, not Berhe etc)
Round 5 pick 152 - Caraun Reid, Ed Reynolds, AJ McCarron, Lamin Barrow, Cyril Richardson (any of these five)

Can't wait to see who they draft next! Maybe Syracuse backup longsnapper John Johnson!

lol pathetic

its odd to see the analysts praise the giants draft then come online to see a fan so mad at them. i think the people who get paid alot of money to do this know more than you.
just relax, you wont know how this draft went for another 5 years anyways.

lol the Giants drafts have been pathetic man...look at the past 5 years drafts...

2013
Pugh - an undersized tackle (sure he played well but he's not a tackle)
Hankins - they seem to be putting a lot of faith in him after failing to resign the most dominant player on their team in Linval Joseph, jury's still out
Moore - should have played much more, but why didn't he? The front office is just all over the place
Nassib - never going to see the field, shouldn't have been drafted
Taylor - one of 7 strong safeties we have on our team. Bunch of slow guys at safety
Herman - only pick I liked in this draft
Cox - not going to be in New York very long

2012
Wilson - lol..
Randle - says a lot about this guy that they felt the need to reach on a receiver at 12 in 2014
Hosley - depth player at best
Robinson - we'll see after this year, can't stay healthy
Mosley - depth player at best
McCants - lol
Kuhn - xnoz and the Giants seem to love this guy, I'm not buying it. Can't stay healthy

2011
Amukamara - here's one I'll give them
Austin - lol
Jernigan - seems to have talent, but per usual the Giants don't get the most out of him
Brewer - backup at best
Jones - lol
Sash - solid special teams at best
Williams - 3rd down linebacker
Scott - had talent, but no playing time

2010
JPP - jury's still out, surprisingly. Hasn't done shit as of late. Looks like he's already 35
Joseph - best player drafted since Eli, they let him go. Real geniuses
Jones - unfortunate accident has kept him off the field
Dillard - no name
Petrus - backup
Tracy - backup
Dodge - lol

2009
Nicks - frequently hurt, but was effective for us
Sintim - lol
Beatty - oft-injured but has been effective. Terrible last year and I think a transition to RT would do him some good. Too bad we won't see it because they paid him like a starting LT when he just isn't
Barden - didn't develop
Beckum - didn't develop
Brown - was with a bunch of teams before coming back and finally playing. Also very injury prone
Bomar - lol
Wright - never saw the field
Woodson - same


All below average drafts.

Then you have this year..........lol
Beckham - instead of trading up to get Lewan or picking up C.J. Mosley they draft this guy. While I think he can have an impact early, he won't be a superstar. Not worthy of the 12th overall pick.
Richburg - the only pick I didn't mind. Still should have gone TE here with Niklas or Fiedorowicz
Bromley - why take this guy when you could have taken the DE out of UNC? All in all, I also don't mind this pick
Williams - I like Williams, but not here. Still had a bunch of tackles available and they go RB
Berhe - this is when I started to seriously doubt the entire New York Giants organization. Why take this guy when you could get Ed Reynolds (an actual FS)? We already have 7 strong safeties on our team. We need range in the secondary. Instead they draft a 5'10" slow strong safety..
Kennard - another beauty here..a freaking DE/OLB tweener on a 4-3 team.. Great fit..yea just great
Jackson - idk anything about this kid, nor do I want to when there are much greater needs

If you are content with this year's draft and what the Giants have been doing as of late, you are still high off our previous super bowl.

xnozx. where are you i wanna see your response

Sorry bud had some unexpected news the past few days haven't had much time for anything.

I'll be posting now

I know you don't like Will Beatty but he was one of the best young upcoming LT's in the game 2 years ago. He only had one bad season, not sure why you continue to write him off like he sucks. He's going to make a lot of Giants fans look incredibly foolish for calling him a bust(which is comical in itself).

Wanted no part of Lewan.. what sense does that make? What do we do with Beatty and his contract? Lewan is not all he's hyped up to be.

Donald is a corbon copy of Geno Atkins. He's going to dominant in the league. Height means nothing when you have strength and heart.

Ebron would have finally given Eli a dynamic weapon and security blanket at TE to create mismatches with linebackers and safeties. Our hope now is Adrien Robinson to finally get on the field and stay healthy. I have HIGH hopes for this kid still.


Pugh is going to be part of our bookends for the next 10 years for you had better get used to it. He's an excellent RT and only getting better. Richburg was a great pick, he's going to be another 10 year player for us much like Richie Seubert, Shaun O'Hara & Kareem Mackenzie.


You need to take a deep breathe, inhale, exhale and have faith in this organization that's brought us TWO Super Bowl Championships not too long ago. Realie they know more than you and MANY others who freak out every year during draft day lol... it's ridiculous some of these complete buffoons.

As for your comment about Odell Beckham. He wasn't a reach. The Giants LOVE this kid and so did the Eagles, Steelers, Patriots, 49ers, and Jets per the reported teams.

Beckham rose on draft boards more than any other player. He's the real deal. His work ethic is the greatest attribute about him. He's Hakeem Nicks with work ethic/drive. A comparison that's being echoed by everyone is Greg Jennings. Greg Jennings. I will take that over a guy who will be out of the NFL in a few years aka C.J. Mosley. He has medical issues out the ass.



Every draft expert out there is giving us a solid B+ or an A.



Have faith my brother.... this draft we picked CHARACTER guys that bring PRODUCTION. Every player we picked was a captain and leader of their football teams. We nailed this draft. You'll see.