Yes for casual fans/commentators who know nothing about football

This post counts and matters

really? because outside of the playoffs troy aikman was mediocre as fuck and romo was a regular season god. Which one had the HOF career?

This post was edited by casedizzle45 on Aug 20 2017 08:44pm

They both did, for different reasons.

You don't use one or the other to judge a career. You use a culmination of them both along with a ton of other stats to evaluate a career.

Sorry bro, legends are made in the post season, not regular season

And that line of thinking is why barely anyone takes you seriously. Also why no one takes ESPN seriously. Most people are dumb when it comes to sports including all the pundits they hire because they know people like you will believe them.

They overreact to just about everything. But in reality nothing is that simple.

So I guess you consider Peyton manning better than Tom Brady. Peyton manning won 5 mvps and 2 Super Bowls. Brady won 5 Super Bowls and two mvps so who had the better career? I'm sure if you asked peyton manning he would trade those mvp trophies for a super bowl every single time.

Edit: I'm not saying regular season stats don't matter at all, but the playoffs are hands down where a player makes or breaks his career and it's not even up for debate

This post was edited by casedizzle45 on Aug 21 2017 08:43am

Why do you say that? Where did I say regular season was more important?

Teams win championships, not quarterbacks. Until you start realizing that, I have nothing more to say to you.