How did your team do in the 2013 draft? Mel Kiper grades all 32 NFL teams based on need and value.
Everybody knows you can't grade an NFL draft on performance the day it ends. You can't do it for years, which is part of the reason why I audit old drafts. What I do here is assess three main things:
• How much overall talent did a team add based on board position?
• How effectively did they address key personnel needs?
• How efficient were they in maneuvering on the draft board?
And I use my player grades as the prism. I'm well aware all NFL teams see players differently -- I might have a third-round grade on a safety many teams see as a late-round pick. That's the reality of player evaluations.
Grading Scale: In my mind an "A" means it's exceptional; a "B" is pretty good; a "C" means average, with hits and misses; a "D" means below average with some big questions. An "F" … well, I didn't have one.
Baltimore Ravens
Top needs: ILB, S, LT, TE, WR
Summary: The Ravens needed to come out of this draft with an inside linebacker and a safety, and with their first two picks, they got two really good players at those positions. Matt Elam has played high-level football at Florida, can move around (particularly up to the line of scrimmage) and make hits. He plays with fearlessness, can make plays in coverage with his good instincts and long arms and slotted in next to Michael Huff at strong safety, provides immediate impact. Baltimore used its pile of picks to move up and take Arthur Brown, a player the Ravens really liked. He's a steal at No. 56 overall and takes over the void left by Ray Lewis. Brandon Williams gives them a rotation player at nose tackle and gives them depth behind Terrence Cody. Kyle Juszczyk is the best fullback in the draft, and makes plenty of sense in the fourth round. Ricky Wagner is an interesting pick because if you asked me a year ago I'd have told you he probably lands in Round 2 this year. He just didn't play to that level this season, but you have to wonder if he can get back to that point. I see his future at right tackle, or even guard. Tackle was a need, and we'll see if he helps there. I think it's a good bet on upside. John Simon is an interesting player, because it's hard to say what position he'll play. For now he provides depth at linebacker and should be a good special-teamer. The Ravens had another excellent draft because they needed starters at some key spots and pulled it off. That's not easy to do when you're slotted in at No. 32.
Round Pick Position Player College
(1) 32 S Matt Elam Florida
(2) 56 LB Arthur Brown Kansas St.
(3) 94 DT Brandon Williams Missouri Southern St.
(4) 129 DE John Simon Ohio State
(4) 130 FB Kyle Juszczyk Harvard
(5) 168 G Ricky Wagner Wisconsin
(6) 200 DE Kapron Lewis-Moore Notre Dame
(6) 203 C Ryan Jensen Colorado State-Pueblo
(7) 238 WR Aaron Mellette Elon
(7) 247 CB Marc Anthony California
Cincinnati Bengals
Top needs: S, OLB, RB, CB
Summary: The Bengals somehow didn't address a pretty big need early (and they don't have many) and still really impressed me. The pick of Tyler Eifert is just a steal (I had him No. 8 on my final Big Board). You have a good QB, but a limited one -- Andy Dalton isn't going to carve teams up down the field. But with A.J. Green, Jermaine Gresham and Eifert, you have guys that don't need to be open to be thrown to. Try dealing with all three on the field in the red zone. Eifert to Cincy is a great case of a team simply pouncing when the value gets too good. Giovani Bernard gives them a new dimension in the run game, ironically because he can actually catch the ball. He was the most versatile RB on my board, and getting the first RB taken at No. 37 overall isn't bad. The Bengals D-line continues to be filled with long, athletic freaks with the addition of Margus Hunt. I know Hunt's a project, but he's a great bet at No. 53 overall. He can almost block enough kicks to justify that pick given how weirdly effective he is at it. They did get their safety in Round 3. Shawn Williams has a chance to beat out Taylor Mays. Sean Porter can back up James Harrison, who's now 35. Cobi Hamilton has a chance to stick. And Reid Fragel could be a steal in the seventh. The Bengals seem to be a groove with the draft, the only downside being the picks that came via the Carson Palmer deal are now spent. It was fun while it lasted.
Round Pick Position Player College
(1) 21 TE Tyler Eifert Notre Dame
(2) 37 RB Giovani Bernard UNC
(2) 53 DE Margus Hunt SMU
(3) 84 S Shawn Williams Georgia
(4) 118 LB Sean Porter Texas A&M
(5) 156 G Tanner Hawkinson Kansas
(6) 190 RB Rex Burkhead Nebraska
(6) 197 WR Cobi Hamilton Arkansas
(7) 240 T Reid Fragel Ohio State
(7) 251 C T.J. Johnson South Carolina
St. Louis Rams
Top needs: S, WR, RB, G, OLB
Summary: The Rams really needed to add a wide receiver (or two), and they really needed to add a safety. I thought they could use a running back, and if they had a guard available, that would be good. Well, the Rams did well. We can sit and remind ourselves that they don't have Robert Griffin III and that's part of the reason they have the ability to maneuver so well, but we forget the Rams improved as much or more than the Redskins last season, and we don't know exactly what RG III will do early in 2013. St. Louis crushed the WR question, adding Tavon Austin and Stedman Bailey. (Know who caught 113 passes to Austin's 111 at West Virginia last year? That was Bailey.) Alec Ogletree is an impact performer. Put him next to James Laurinaitis and throw away the key. T.J. McDonald wouldn't have been my safety choice at No. 71, but he wasn't much of a reach and they clearly like the fit. He'll start, too. Barrett Jones is your depth at guard, and I think Zac Stacy could see some action at running back. I really liked this draft, and found myself in agreement with my colleagues. Oh, and they still have an extra first-rounder next year. The NFC West arms race is not just a two-team affair.
Round Pick Position Player College
(1) 8 WR Tavon Austin West Virginia
(1) 30 LB Alec Ogletree Georgia
(3) 71 S T.J. McDonald USC
(3) 92 WR Stedman Bailey West Virginia
(4) 113 C Barrett Jones Alabama
(5) 149 CB Brandon McGee Miami (FL)
(5) 160 RB Zac Stacy Vanderbilt
San Diego Chargers
Top needs: OT, G, ILB, CB, NT
Summary: The Chargers really needed a tackle, and while I think D.J. Fluker will need to stay on the right side if you want to see the best of him, the guy can pass protect pretty well over there and will simply maul in the run game. Fluker can collapse the edge. Manti Te'o fills an immediate need at linebacker, and I don't think San Diego could have expected to get this kind of a player at No. 38 overall. He will step in and start immediately, and now you look at a corps with Melvin Ingram, Te'o, Donald Butler and Jarret Johnson. Not bad. Keenan Allen wasn't a huge need, but he's got the tape of a first-rounder, so expect impact from him. He's got a lot of ability and is a couple years younger than many of the other top wideouts in this draft. Both Steve Williams and Tourek Williams are useful backups, and Brad Sorenson has a chance to make the depth chart.
Round Pick Position Player College
(1) 11 T D.J. Fluker Alabama
(2) 38 LB Manti Te'o Notre Dame
(3) 76 WR Keenan Allen California
(5) 145 CB Steve Williams California
(6) 179 LB Tourek Williams Florida International
(7) 221 QB Brad Sorensen Southern Utah
Green Bay Packers
Top needs: S, RB, DE, OT, WR
Summary: I love what Green Bay got out of this draft, particularly at two spots -- defensive end and running back. Datone Jones is a perfect scheme-fit for the defense. He's the penetrating 3-4 defensive end who should line up to the right of B.J. Raji. The Packers improved their pass rush last year after a disastrous 2011, and Jones is going to provide yet another player who can cause some problems for opposing quarterbacks. I know some teams have health questions with Eddie Lacy, but getting the guy I had as the No. 1 RB in the draft all the way down at No. 61 is terrific value. The Packers build their offensive portfolio off Aaron Rodgers' arm, but it'd be nice to see that 43-game streak of no running backs reaching 100 yards come to an end. Remember, Rodgers also took plenty of hits over the last two years, so a little more reliability in the run game is key. Adding to that, Johnathan Franklin will produce if called upon. That position is now a strength. There isn't a lot else here that will factor into the 2013 plans. J.C. Tretter can give them reps, but won't be needed early. One sleeper here is Charles Johnson from Grand Valley State. I thought he might come off much earlier than No. 216. Green Bay did well with its early picks, and that's plenty.
Round Pick Position Player College
(1) 26 DE Datone Jones UCLA
(2) 61 RB Eddie Lacy Alabama
(4) 109 T David Bakhtiari Colorado
(4) 122 C J.C. Tretter Cornell
(4) 125 RB Johnathan Franklin UCLA
(5) 159 CB Micah Hyde Iowa
(5) 167 DT Josh Boyd Mississippi State
(6) 193 LB Nate Palmer Illinois State
(7) 216 WR Charles Johnson Grand Valley State
(7) 224 WR Kevin Dorsey Maryland
(7) 232 LB Sam Barrington South Florida
Philadelphia Eagles
Top needs: CB, G/OT, S, DE, QB
Summary: The Eagles really did well at the No. 4 spot. Lane Johnson has the best combination of upside and athleticism in the draft, and while he's an unfinished product, he's the perfect tackle to develop in Chip Kelly's fast-paced system. After that, we saw a kind of fun theme develop -- a head coach who gets a say in personnel decisions, taking players he should know really well. It started in Round 2, where the Eagles took my No. 2-ranked tight end. Well, Zach Ertz caught 11 passes against Kelly's Oregon Ducks last year. Matt Barkley also piled up huge numbers versus Oregon, and was the first pick taken in Round 4 (I once said I thought Barkley was a future first pick -- maybe I meant in Round 4?). Kelly wants competition at QB, and Barkley is going to come in ready to compete. Bennie Logan fits as a potential 3-4 DE or even a nose tackle, and Earl Wolff offers some depth at safety. They needed a corner and got another guy Kelly knows, Jordan Poyer from Oregon State. Joe Kruger isn't fast, but he could provide a pass rush in this system. Overall, I like what the Eagles accomplished.
Round Pick Position Player College
(1) 4 T Lane Johnson Oklahoma
(2) 35 TE Zach Ertz Stanford
(3) 67 DT Bennie Logan LSU
(4) 98 QB Matt Barkley USC
(5) 136 S Earl Wolff NC State
(7) 212 DE Joe Kruger Utah
(7) 218 CB Jordan Poyer Oregon State
(7) 239 DE David King Oklahoma
Jacksonville Jaguars
Top needs: CB, DE, QB, RT, OLB
Summary: Jacksonville Jaguars I haven't given them the best grades in recent years, not because they didn't take good players, but because they seemed to lack some sense of how the board was lining up. Well, they deserve a good grade this year. Luke Joeckel was the No. 1 player on my Big Board, and while I didn't have left tackle as a top need (in part because they have many needs), right tackle is a problem. With Joeckel's arrival, Jacksonville is now better at both tackle positions. Either Joeckel starts there and Eugene Monroe remains on the left, or they swap. Either way, they got better on the O-line. Johnathan Cyprien was one of the best safeties in college football last season, and should be the starter at strong safety in Week 1. Dwayne Gratz is a physical corner who should also start immediately. Then the Jags turned up the offensive intrigue factor, adding Denard Robinson and Ace Sanders. Neither will be confused with a really refined route-runner, but this offense has lacked playmakers, and these guys are dangerous in space. Josh Evans could become another starter at safety. The big gripe is they really need another pass-rusher, and they didn't even add a developmental one in the draft. But overall, they did pretty well -- the roster is easily more talented than it was on Wednesday.
Round Pick Position Player College
(1) 2 T Luke Joeckel Texas A&M
(2) 33 S Johnathan Cyprien Florida International
(3) 64 CB Dwayne Gratz Connecticut
(4) 101 WR Ace Sanders South Carolina
(5) 135 WR Denard Robinson Michigan
(6) 169 CB Josh Evans Florida
(7) 208 CB Jeremy Harris New Mexico State
(7) 210 CB Demetrius McCray Appalachian State
Tennessee Titans
Top needs: DE, G, CB, WR, S
Summary: Tennessee Titans The Titans may not have any idea what will become of Jake Locker. I don't know either. But they sure as heck should be better running the ball in 2013 behind the line they're building, and between whatever pressure that takes off Locker and the addition of yet another receiver, they can say they gave him a chance. Chance Warmack is one of the more dominating run-blockers to enter the league in years. Between him and Andy Levitre, the Titans are really good at guard. Tennessee also added a nasty center in Brian Schwenke in Round 4. Justin Hunter gives them another deep threat, so they now have Kenny Britt, Hunter, Kendall Wright, Nate Washington and Delanie Walker, as well as Chris Johnson and Shonn Greene. If Locker struggles early, maybe it's Ryan Fitzpatrick's team, because somebody can work with this offensive talent. Blidi Wreh-Wilson gives them the corner they needed. I had defensive end as a big need and Lavar Edwards was a steal in the fifth. I thought they did pretty well overall.
Round Pick Position Player College
(1) 10 G Chance Warmack Alabama
(2) 34 WR Justin Hunter Tennessee
(3) 70 CB Blidi Wreh-Wilson Connecticut
(3) 97 LB Zaviar Gooden Missouri
(4) 107 C Brian Schwenke California
(5) 142 DE Lavar Edwards LSU
(6) 202 CB Khalid Wooten Nevada
(7) 248 S Daimion Stafford Nebraska
Houston Texans
Top needs: WR, RT, LB, NT, FB
Summary: I thought the Texans would go with DeAndre Hopkins at No. 27, and they did. Andre Johnson will be 32 in Week 1 of this season, and soaked up an absurd 58 percent of their wide receiver targets in 2012. Hopkins gives them a legit No. 2 while they wait for DeVier Posey to come back healthy. That selection checked off what I considered the No. 1 need. Ed Reed is now at safety, but he's not the same player he was five years ago, and they need depth. D.J. Swearinger can play right away, and knows how to take angles and deliver hits. He'll just need to learn how to play by Roger Goodell's rules. Brennan Williams could develop for them at right tackle but was a little of a reach. Trevardo Williams was a steal for me. Wade Phillips can get him on the field because Williams can rush the passer and was hugely productive. David Quessenberry was a pretty good value at No. 176; he could develop and at least has the ceiling of a starter. Sam Montgomery has some makeup questions, but he plays with a high motor and could turn into a really good value. I'm not sure he has the size to hold up as a 3-4 DE, but Phillips could develop him. Keep an eye on Alan Bonner, who could make the team as a return man. That's what put him on the radar of teams. I think the Texans did pretty well overall.
Round Pick Position Player College
(1) 27 WR DeAndre Hopkins Clemson
(2) 57 S D.J. Swearinger South Carolina
(3) 89 T Brennan Williams UNC
(3) 95 DE Sam Montgomery LSU
(4) 124 DE Trevardo Williams Connecticut
(6) 176 T David Quessenberry San Jose St.
(6) 195 WR Alan Bonner Jackonsville State
(6) 198 DT Chris Jones Bowling Green
(6) 201 TE Ryan Griffin Connecticut
Kansas City Chiefs
Top needs: OT, ILB, FS, WR, DE
Summary: It still seems remarkable that an offensive tackle out of the MAC was the No. 1 pick in the NFL draft. Remember, the highest we'd seen before this was Byron Leftwich, who went No. 7. The Chiefs needed a tackle, and they took the one they thought had the best chance to be a long-term answer on the left side. If Fisher works out well, Andy Reid can do a lot more with this offense, because it really doesn't lack for weapons. I don't have a problem with the Fisher pick, but the next two were odd. Travis Kelce is a good tight end, but they already have Tony Moeaki and Anthony Fasano on the roster. And Knile Davis is explosive, but he's not a steal in Round 3, and has had both injury and fumble problems. I like the next two picks, however. Nico Johnson can start as an inside linebacker, and Sanders Commings provides some corner depth. Eric Kush could step in at center in a pinch as early as 2013. They got the guy they wanted at No. 1, but there's a lot of "we'll see" with the rest, with one caveat: I don't think this team has the personnel issues of most teams picking at No. 1, and it showed. Remember, they also got Alex Smith, a proven starting NFL QB, with their second-round pick.
Round Pick Position Player College
(1) 1 T Eric Fisher Central Michigan
(3) 63 TE Travis Kelce Cincinnati
(3) 96 RB Knile Davis Arkansas
(4) 99 LB Nico Johnson Alabama
(5) 134 CB Sanders Commings Georgia
(6) 170 C Eric Kush Cal (PA)
(6) 204 FB Braden Wilson Kansas State
(7) 207 DE Mike Catapano Princeton
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Top needs: CB, DT, TE, LB, DE
Summary: Like the Seahawks, we need to factor into Tampa's grade the fact that they now have Darrelle Revis on the roster. Cornerback was a huge need and they used this draft to get a guy they coveted. But I'll say this, he's also making $16 million this year (about $13 million more than the Round 1 pick will make) and he's coming off an ACL injury, so it's something far less than theft. Johnthan Banks, who they drafted at No. 43, gives them some extra cover in the secondary. He'll see plenty of the field in nickel situations. Mike Glennon can backup Josh Freeman, but I think fans are way overstating it if they think Glennon can provide actual competition at this point. He needs some time. Akeem Spence provides a rotation D-tackle, but William Gholston is merely depth now. After that you won't see much from this class in 2013. If Revis is Revis, we're all happy. After that, I thought they just did OK.
Round Pick Position Player College
(2) 43 CB Johnthan Banks Mississippi St.
(3) 73 QB Mike Glennon NC State
(4) 100 DT Akeem Spence Illinois
(4) 126 DE William Gholston Michigan St.
(5) 147 DE Steven Means Buffalo
(6) 189 RB Mike James Miami (FL)
Arizona Cardinals
Top needs: OLB, OT, G, S, DE, QB
Summary: Last year the Cardinals allowed a sack on one out of every 11.7 drop-backs. This offseason, there's been almost a hysteria about their need to get better on the offensive line, with tackle mentioned often. But very quietly, rookies Bobby Massie and Nate Potter played a lot better on the edges toward the end of the season, and Levi Brown is also returning. That's why I had guard as a bigger need. The Cardinals drafted a future Pro Bowl one in Jonathan Cooper. Historically, No. 7 is extremely high to take a guard (there hasn't been one taken inside the top 10 since 1997), but if Arizona didn't take him, there's no chance he would have gotten past the Jets at No. 9. Cooper could also be a stud at center if Arizona chose to go that way. Kevin Minter gives the Cardinals a very capable inside linebacker, but he probably slots in behind Daryl Washington. At one time Alex Okafor would have been a steal in the fourth round, but his motor runs hot and cold. He could be an effective situational pass-rusher as an OLB, which was the No. 2 need on my board. Anybody else? Oh yeah, only Tyrann Mathieu, the Honey Badger. We know Mathieu is headed for the slot, but depending on the sub-package, he could essentially take on the role of safety on a lot of plays. Now, what I like about Mathieu landing here (aside from having him with a late second-, early third-round grade) is the familiarity with teammates. Both Minter and Patrick Peterson know Mathieu well. The Badger can also take on some return duties for Peterson. Earl Watford could be a future starter at guard, and Stepfan Taylor offers some depth at RB, though I had a handful of players ranked higher at the position who were still available. That said, Andre Ellington (a guy Todd McShay really likes) provides some speed. Nothing remarkable about this class, but Carson Palmer's chance to succeed has improved with the presence of Cooper, and there's plenty of sleeper potential.
Round Pick Position Player College
(1) 7 G Jonathan Cooper UNC
(2) 45 LB Kevin Minter LSU
(3) 69 CB Tyrann Mathieu LSU
(4) 103 DE Alex Okafor Texas
(4) 116 G Earl Watford James Madison
(5) 140 RB Stepfan Taylor Stanford
(6) 174 WR Ryan Swope Texas A&M
(6) 187 RB Andre Ellington Clemson
(7) 219 TE D.C. Jefferson Rutgers
Minnesota Vikings
Top needs: WR, CB, MLB, DT, DE
Summary: The Vikings got a gift when Sharrif Floyd fell to them at No. 23. We heard going into Thursday that he might tumble a little, but that was a pretty big drop. My guess is they'll rotate him in with Kevin Williams, who will be 33 when the season starts. The top two needs on my board for the Vikings were wide receiver and cornerback, and that's where they went with the next two picks. Xavier Rhodes at No. 25 made sense, because several teams after that could have targeted corner. The Vikings then gave up a tremendous amount to move into Round 1 again at No. 29 overall, where they got Cordarrelle Patterson. He needs work in terms of learning how to play the position, but Patterson is a player who can create explosive plays once he gets the ball, which is what they lost when they dealt Percy Harvin. Thing is, Patterson needs to work out because they sent New England a few picks to get him. But the strategy makes sense: They saw a chance to add a starter and took it. Jeff Locke was the best punter available, so I don't mind the use of a fifth-round pick to get him. Gerald Hodges, who they took at No. 120 overall, could push to start at middle linebacker. Hey, they got starters, but they needed to add impact in this draft considering they dealt Harvin and had a few pretty big needs. I also thought they should've found a way to get their hands on Manti Te'o in this draft.
Round Pick Position Player College
(1) 23 DT Sharrif Floyd Florida
(1) 25 CB Xavier Rhodes Florida St.
(1) 29 WR Cordarrelle Patterson Tennessee
(4) 120 LB Gerald Hodges Penn State
(5) 155 P Jeff Locke UCLA
(6) 196 G Jeff Baca UCLA
(7) 213 LB Michael Mauti Penn State
(7) 214 G Travis Bond UNC
(7) 229 DT Everett Dawkins Florida State
Pittsburgh Steelers
Top needs: OLB, WR, RB, TE, S
Summary: The Steelers got a little bit of their bite back. I love the selection of Jarvis Jones in Round 1. We're talking about the most productive pass-rusher in college football over the last two seasons, and he did it against the best competition. Jones fits the system, and OLB was the top need on my board. Hard to beat that pick -- a guy I had at No. 1 on my Big Board before some really poor workouts still there at No. 17. Wide receiver was the No. 2 need for me, and Markus Wheaton is a pretty good player with plenty of burst. Shamarko Thomas was a great value pick in Round 4. The guy can really hit and is a fantastic athlete. If he was taller, he'd have gone earlier. The Steelers also got a running back, I just thought Le'Veon Bell was a bit of a reach. I'll say this for him, however: Bell played behind some pretty awful blocking last year and still managed to be productive. Get him behind Maurkice Pouncey and David DeCastro and we might see something better. Terry Hawthorne could stick. Not a bad draft at all.
Round Pick Position Player College
(1) 17 LB Jarvis Jones Georgia
(2) 48 RB Le'Veon Bell Michigan St.
(3) 79 WR Markus Wheaton Oregon State
(4) 111 S Shamarko Thomas Syracuse
(4) 115 QB Landry Jones Oklahoma
(5) 150 CB Terry Hawthorne Illinois
(6) 186 WR Justin Brown Oklahoma
(6) 206 LB Vince Williams Florida St.
(7) 223 DT Nick Williams Samford