d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Football & Rugby > Name Your Top 10-20 Qb's In The Nfl > We Ranked Top 5 & 1-10 Already
Prev13456714Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Views: 954Replies: 130Track Topic
Member
Posts: 59,137
Joined: Jan 19 2005
Gold: 26.51
Warn: 10%
#41
Jan 17 2012 06:28pm
Top 20:

1. Peyton
2. Rodgers
3. Brady
4. Brees
5. Eli
6. Ben
7. Rivers
8. Stafford
9. Romo
10. Cam
11. Schaub
12. Vick
13. Cutler
14. Ryan
15. Dalton
16. Flacco
17. Alex Smith
18. Freeman
19. Fitzpatrick
20. Kolb
20. Sanchez


Here's my revised list with Cutler
Member
Posts: 11,340
Joined: Oct 20 2008
Gold: 5.05
#42
Jan 17 2012 06:29pm
Quote (Photoshopd @ Jan 17 2012 06:25pm)
If WR's make the QB good, how come Skelton is garbage?

The whole "rofl herp derp (wr name here) is the only reason (qb name here) is good" argument is beyond retarded. A lot of jealous mother fuckers who wish they had said QB's on their team.


This is horse shit.. your telling me that if Stafford didn't have the most dominant WR in NFL history to bail him out every single time he is in trouble, that he would still be a top qb in the nfl?

Without Megatron he would barely be an average QB
Member
Posts: 51,331
Joined: Feb 18 2007
Gold: 0.27
#43
Jan 17 2012 06:29pm
Quote (xnozx. @ Jan 17 2012 05:28pm)
Top 20:

1. Peyton
2. Rodgers
3. Brady
4. Brees
5. Eli
6. Ben
7. Rivers
8. Stafford
9. Romo
10. Cam
11. Schaub
12. Vick
13. Cutler
14. Ryan
15. Dalton
16. Flacco
17. Alex Smith
18. Freeman
19. Fitzpatrick
20. Kolb
20. Sanchez


Here's my revised list with Cutler


Still giving Kolb some love huh?

You have more faith in him than I do lol. Hope I'm wrong, really do, but god he's not good lol.

EDIT:


Quote (jrjl89 @ Jan 17 2012 05:29pm)
This is horse shit.. your telling me that if Stafford didn't have the most dominant WR in NFL history to bail him out every single time he is in trouble, that he would still be a top qb in the nfl?

Without Megatron he would barely be an average QB


There's no point, this is JSP where the idiots roam free.

Although, Stafford is better than average. He's good enough to be an above average qb, hell, he is an above average qb, just not as elite as they're saying.

This post was edited by Randolph on Jan 17 2012 06:31pm
Member
Posts: 38,581
Joined: Jun 28 2006
Gold: 0.00
#44
Jan 17 2012 06:29pm
Quote (xnozx. @ Jan 17 2012 04:28pm)
Top 20:

1. Peyton
2. Rodgers
3. Brady
4. Brees
5. Eli
6. Ben
7. Rivers
8. Stafford
9. Romo
10. Cam
11. Schaub
12. Vick
13. Cutler
14. Ryan
15. Dalton
16. Flacco
17. Alex Smith
18. Freeman
19. Fitzpatrick
20. Kolb
20. Sanchez


Here's my revised list with Cutler


good list

I would still take Romo over Stafford
Member
Posts: 2,841
Joined: Jun 23 2009
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 20%
#45
Jan 17 2012 06:29pm
Quote (jrjl89 @ Jan 17 2012 07:29pm)
This is horse shit.. your telling me that if Stafford didn't have the most dominant WR in NFL history to bail him out every single time he is in trouble, that he would still be a top qb in the nfl?

Without Megatron he would barely be an average QB


Irony
Member
Posts: 4,507
Joined: Mar 27 2010
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
#46
Jan 17 2012 06:30pm

Sanchez in your top 20? u must be on something fierce
Member
Posts: 12,542
Joined: Jun 11 2007
Gold: 74.01
Warn: 20%
#47
Jan 17 2012 06:30pm
Quote (Randolph @ Jan 17 2012 08:16pm)
Assuming each QB had the exact same team around him so no one has Fitz and Dre to pass to while others have DHB and Albert Haynesworth as their receivers ( <3 Raider fans) and a pro bowl line vs the Cardinals oline, etc etc....

1) Tom Brady
2) Peyton Manning
3) Aaron Rodgers
4) Drew Brees
5) Phillip Rivers
6) Eli Manning
7) Ben Roethlisberger
8) Tony Romo
9) Matt Schaub
10) Jay Cutler
11) Mathew Stafford
13) Cam Newton
13) Michael Vick
14) Joe Flacco
15) Andy Dalton
16) Alex Smith
17) Matt Ryan
18) Ryan Fitzpatrick
19) Josh Freeman
20) John Skelton

Let the haters hate on Skelton.

I didn't exactly put a lot of thought into that one, but I'm OK with it.

EDIT: Actually, let me make a slight change.  19 and 20 can be any of these: Freeman, Skelton, Hasselbeck, Bradford, Orton


best list by far
Member
Posts: 11,340
Joined: Oct 20 2008
Gold: 5.05
#48
Jan 17 2012 06:33pm
Quote (Photoshopd @ Jan 17 2012 06:29pm)
Irony


and the only reason his stats are so high is because the lions clearly throw the ball more than any team in the NFL...
Member
Posts: 59,137
Joined: Jan 19 2005
Gold: 26.51
Warn: 10%
#49
Jan 19 2012 05:39pm
Quote (Odds @ Jan 17 2012 08:29pm)
good list

I would still take Romo over Stafford


As would I I revised my list



Top 20:

1. Peyton
2. Rodgers
3. Brady
4. Brees
5. Eli
6. Ben
7. Rivers
8. Romo
9. Stafford
10. Cam
11. Schaub
12. Vick
13. Cutler
14. Ryan
15. Dalton
16. Flacco
17. Alex Smith
18. Freeman
19. Fitzpatrick
20. Kolb
20. Sanchez


From 15-20 could be swapped around any way really & even replace some of the choices with others not mentioned. Hard to be accurate when you get that far down
Member
Posts: 21,077
Joined: May 25 2007
Gold: 2,032.14
#50
Jan 19 2012 05:50pm
No way Rodgers has moved over Brady yet. This is what Rodgers 4th season as a starter? I mean he had a good year this year but Brady has been doing what Rodgers is doing for 10 years (9 seasons) and hasn't slowed down.
Go Back To Football & Rugby Topic List
Prev13456714Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll

© 2003-2026 d2jsp  Contact