wat lol, that movie was dumb..

not sure if already mentioned but apparently giants resigned tynes

Nope TB signed him

Really cool chart, thanks for posting. Not accurate but cool lol

ah my bad, I read the header wrong.

I'd say its pretty close to accurate, Rolle is probably average IMO and Tuck is above average. Randle is not above average and Baas is probably below average.

Sorry forgot to tell PFF that everyone on the giants are above elite

lmao, if anything that chart is making you guys look better.... but I'd say it's pretty accurate. JPP is the only Elite player you guys have. Eli is in the same class as Big Ben and Rivers, just below Elite. I would say Nicks is Above Average at this point and Randle is Average at best right now. Wilson and Prince are right where they should be. Jenkins and Joseph may be a little overrated as well on that chart, but I won't really argue those rankings.

Not gona touch the Eli topic but how is Myers below average? He's a more reliable Martellus Bennett. He's not gona run many deep routes but his intermediate game in Oakland was crazy and it's only going to improve under Eli.


Nicks when he's healthy is an absokute monster. Joseph is not overrated by any stretch, jenkins maybe.