Quote (draino @ 20 Jan 2014 01:50)
Clowney reminds me of Mario. Great physical talent, but never plays at 100% like JJ Watt does. We already had the best defensive player in the league last year and where did that get us? 2-14 and #1 pick. We have other concerns/needs, but we need an elite QB and I can see Bridgewater becoming an elite QB. Manziel could under the right offense/team, but I don't see it happening in Houston. Teddy Bridgewater has played in a pro offense all his career, he knows how to read defenses(most important thing in a QB IMO), and he knows how to audible.
I understand your points, but I still think Bridgewater is just a mediocre QB - kinda like Schaub was until this season. With Manziel, I think you have a way higher floor and ceiling. Under Kubiak, we hardly ever took risks, both on the field and in the draft, and his 61-64 record is reflective of that.
I still say we go Manziel or Clowney. Either that, or we trade down and get more picks, because there are a lot of issues and positions that this team needs to address, and if we aren't completely sold on any one QB, mine as well get more picks in what is, in my opinion, kind of a muddled QB class.
Dream tank scenario: draft Clowney at #1, tank against next season, take Jameis Winston at #1, profit