d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Football & Rugby > Keep Building Up That Pedestal Philly
Prev12627282930103Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Views: 12688Replies: 1027Track Topic
Member
Posts: 34,802
Joined: Jul 14 2008
Gold: 8,816.79
#271
Nov 25 2016 11:42pm
Quote (Terps @ Nov 26 2016 01:40am)
Being a fan of team x should never invalidate your ability to be critical of team y (or in this case, team y's fanbase).

Arguments should be judged on content, not the fandom of the person making the argument. Like, Sryan is one of the smartest posters on this forum, but he's a Bucs fan. Under your logic, he would be unable to criticize other franchises because of his fandom. The logic here is fallacious.


no its not fallacious its the point

it doesnt matter how smart the poster is, plain and simple fans of terrible franchises keep their ridiculous criticisms within themselves
but as far as that goes, bucs actually have won a super bowl so he wouldnt even fall into the conversation
Member
Posts: 35,719
Joined: Jan 19 2004
Gold: 1,720.80
#272
Nov 25 2016 11:43pm
Or, to look at your argument from the inverse, only Patriots fans would have the authority to be critical of other teams, yet, considering at the IQ of their general fanbase, this is obviously a poor way of going about evaluating arguments.
Member
Posts: 62,894
Joined: May 20 2009
Gold: 2,441.00
#273
Nov 25 2016 11:44pm
In the last 7 games, Wentz's passer rating is under 30 for passes that travel beyond 15 yards rofl.
Member
Posts: 15,839
Joined: Jul 27 2009
Gold: 805.00
#274
Nov 25 2016 11:44pm
Quote (Terps @ Nov 26 2016 01:40am)
Being a fan of team x should never invalidate your ability to be critical of team y (or in this case, team y's fanbase).

Arguments should be judged on content, not the fandom of the person making the argument. Like, Sryan is one of the smartest posters on this forum, but he's a Bucs fan. Under your logic, he would be unable to criticize other franchises because of his fandom. The logic here is fallacious.



That's pretty funny. If this is true, then how come every time I make even the slightest criticism of any team, the immediate and consistent response is always "how many rings do the eagles have?" And this has been standard jsp protocol for years now.

This post was edited by casedizzle45 on Nov 25 2016 11:45pm
Member
Posts: 17,747
Joined: Jul 12 2011
Gold: 69.00
#275
Nov 25 2016 11:44pm
Lot of talk coming from a franchise with no Super Bowls and none in the foreseeable future
Member
Posts: 34,802
Joined: Jul 14 2008
Gold: 8,816.79
#276
Nov 25 2016 11:45pm
Quote (Noun @ Nov 26 2016 01:44am)
In the last 7 games, Wentz's passer rating is under 30 for passes that travel beyond 15 yards rofl.


u cant seriously be trying to insult wentz game?

is that what this thread was consisting of?!
Member
Posts: 35,719
Joined: Jan 19 2004
Gold: 1,720.80
#277
Nov 25 2016 11:46pm
Quote (jackzors @ Nov 26 2016 12:42am)
no its not fallacious its the point

it doesnt matter how smart the poster is, plain and simple fans of terrible franchises keep their ridiculous criticisms within themselves
but as far as that goes, bucs actually have won a super bowl so he wouldnt even fall into the conversation

So only teams that have won a super bowl can be critical of other teams.

Why are you even here then? lol. Come back when your franchise has actually won something rofl

Quote (casedizzle45 @ Nov 26 2016 12:44am)
That's pretty funny. If this is true, then how come every time I make even the slightest criticism of any team, the immediate and consistent response is always "how many rings do the eagles have?" And this has been standard jsp protocol for years now.

Because those people apparently believe in the same fallacy that you are promoting here

This post was edited by Terps on Nov 25 2016 11:46pm
Member
Posts: 62,894
Joined: May 20 2009
Gold: 2,441.00
#278
Nov 25 2016 11:46pm
Quote (jackzors @ Nov 26 2016 01:45am)
u cant seriously be trying to insult wentz game?

is that what this thread was consisting of?!


Wentz is ass.
Member
Posts: 34,802
Joined: Jul 14 2008
Gold: 8,816.79
#279
Nov 25 2016 11:47pm
Quote (Terps @ Nov 26 2016 01:46am)
So only teams that have won a super bowl can be critical of other teams.

Why are you even here then? lol. Come back when your franchise has actually won something rofl


no im saying teams as bad as the lions and browns shouldnt be critical of a god damn thing

1st was the first winless team in history
2nd is the second winless after this year

atleast the eagles won an nfl title in their history and have made serious playoff runs in recent history

This post was edited by jackzors on Nov 25 2016 11:48pm
Member
Posts: 17,747
Joined: Jul 12 2011
Gold: 69.00
#280
Nov 25 2016 11:49pm
Quote (jackzors @ Nov 26 2016 01:47am)
no im saying teams as bad as the lions and browns shouldnt be critical of a god damn thing

1st was the first winless team in history
2nd is the second winless after this year

atleast the eagles won an nfl title in their history and have made serious playoff runs in recent history


Browns are 100x the franchise the Eagles are rofl
Go Back To Football & Rugby Topic List
Prev12627282930103Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll

© 2003-2026 d2jsp  Contact