Quote (nickxcore @ Jan 19 2013 01:41pm)
In the spirit of International Myth-Shattering Week here in sports, let's look at another myth which might have flown just a tad below the intrigue threshold of some other storylines. Since Oprah was double-booked, consider it a public service.
Myth: The 49ers and head coach Jim Harbaugh made the move to start Colin Kaepernick over Alex Smith purely based on the merits of performance. They knew Kaepernick was the future and could do things Smith wasn't capable of, and they made a gutsy move because, as I wrote at the time, Harbaugh had earned the right to go with his gut.
Reality: A lot of it was about money.
The move to start Kaepernick now looks like a typical master-stroke from Harbaugh, but at the time, it was a perfect situation of a personnel move dictated by a trio of factors:
1. Smith was coming off a concussion, so it was easy to justify as a move sensitive to a hot-button medical debate in the NFL.
2. The 49ers at the time were 6-2-1, and had a little first-place cushion to test-drive CK for a week.
3. If the 49ers could learn whether CK was truly the starter-of-the-future, it could save them a bunch of cash. As I also noted at the time, if Smith was on the Niners' roster in 2013, he'd be there at a cap hit of $10 million.
For 2013 and 2014 combined, Kaepernick represents a cap hit of a $2.8 million. The reality is the 49ers didn't just start Kaepernick for what we now know is the potential to be the latest team with a frightening dual-threat QB. It was also because if he was even 80 cents on the dollar of the performance they could have gotten from Smith, they'd still be a really good football team with the knowledge that their young starter would almost surely get better, and also one more flexible to help itself elsewhere. Now, they have a great young starter who represents a two-year cost of what Mark Sanchez will make in about four weeks next season.
It also means Smith could be cut, but more likely, will be pushed in a trade. And it's actually a good time to trade him.
We can call Alex Smith just another Jim Harbaugh creation, but he might be a valuable one, because at the time he was benched he was playing the best football of his life. Smith finished the season with a passer rating of 104.8 which, had it been sustained, would rank behind only Aaron Rodgers and Peyton Manning. Passer rating doesn't paint nearly a complete picture (ask the new breed of read-zone utilized by QBs like Kaepernick, Russell Wilson and Robert Griffin III), but Smith's 2012 QBR ranked seventh and is the best of his career by a mile. He was making better decisions than he ever has, throwing TD passes at a higher rate than he ever has, and driving the ball down the field more often and successfully than he ever has. He helped guide the Niners to the NFC Championship Game last season (exactly where CK has them this season) and was mere bad fumble luck from starting a Super Bowl.
The 49ers didn't just try out CK because of all the things noted above, they also did it because they knew the guy who could step back in was playing well enough to take them far himself.
It should create interest in a number of teams. Here's how I'd rank them in terms of how much they should consider Smith:
[+] EnlargeVick
Howard Smith/USA TODAY SportsEven with Michael Vick at quarterback, the Eagles could pursue Alex Smith for next season.
1. Philadelphia Eagles: Chip Kelly's scheme has had us speculating on a number of possible targets to start for Philly at quarterback. While Mike Vick seems well-suited to be brought back, it could come at a steep cost to Philly if he returns. That's because A) he'll be an unrestricted free agent if the Eagles cut him (which is likely because of his huge cap number);

he has already seen his career rise and fall in Philly, and C) there's need at QB in a number of places.
Smith, meanwhile, would not find a lot of things Kelly has done at the college level difficult to learn and execute. After all, he played college football at Utah under Urban Meyer and was asked to make run reads and take off regularly. As a junior, he ran for 631 yards and 10 TDs for Meyer, and his running ability and overall athleticism were major draws when he was taken No. 1 overall in 2004. He's a throwing upgrade over the still-developing Nick Foles, and probably a durability upgrade over Vick. Kelly and the Eagles brass should kick the tires on what it would take to get him.
2. Cleveland Browns: The Browns have a new owner in Jimmy Haslam and a new VP of player personnel in Mike Lombardi, and Haslam has made it abundantly clear that quarterback is a priority for the organization going forward. And Norv Turner, the new offensive coordinator, has a relationship with Smith. Well, Cleveland already has a "young" QB in Brandon Weeden, you could argue. Except that not only is Weeden actually a half-year older than Smith, his performance in 2012 -- while not bad at all for a rookie, historically -- doesn't make him immune to legitimate competition for the starting job in 2013. For that reason, and because Weeden is locked in at a very reasonable cap rate of $2.2 and $2.5 million for 2013 and 2014, adding another QB without dumping Weeden can be considered a reasonable option on the books.
3. Jacksonville Jaguars: You could argue they already have two quarterbacks to duel it out in Blaine Gabbert and Chad Henne, and both are owed money in 2013. If each remains on the roster, however, the combined cap hit is only $7.4 million. That's not a miniscule total, but if the Jags truly want to upgrade expectations at QB, Smith has shown a higher ceiling than either of them to this point. Were he acquired, either of those two could be offered up in trades that could recoup at least some draft-pick compensation to off-set what they gave to get Smith. Do they really want to head into 2013 with the Gabbert-Henne battle as the camp headline?
4. Kansas City Chiefs: If Andy Reid is known for one thing, it's that he can succeed with his passing attack if he can assure some level of competency. The current quarterback situation in Kansas City is simply bad, and the No. 1 overall pick in 2013 doesn't offer the opportunity to draft a QB the Chiefs can assume will be ready to give them a certain upgrade at the position. In fact, they are probably better off drafting on the offensive or defensive line, spots in which the draft is extremely good at the top, and speculating on a QB in Rounds 2 or 3.
Or they could use a couple of picks to land Smith, and immediately be pegged as one of the turnaround favorites for 2013. The Chiefs simply aren't the disaster in personnel that their record indicated -- consider how well they ran the ball in 2012 even without any expectations at QB -- but they need an upgrade. Smith would be one.
5. Arizona Cardinals: The Cardinals should be ready to accept Kevin Kolb as a sunk cost and mitigate the terrifying cap hits he represents in 2013 and beyond if he remains on the roster. He's far too great a financial bet for them to maintain on the roster. The Arizona offense could also make great strides in 2013 if it can nail down a consistent quarterback. Tackles Nate Potter and Bobby Massie were bad early (particularly Massie, who really needed more time to develop) but showed marked improvement in the final quarter of the 2012 season. Another addition along that line could mean a far higher level of expectations for the offense in 2013. Ryan Lindley and John Skelton have shown flashes, but each lacks a level of consistent accuracy that coaches need. It stands to reason the 49ers might not be thrilled about shipping a QB they developed to a division rival, but all options should be on the table for the Cardinals, who have ranked 31st, 28th and 32nd in the NFL in passing DVOA going back to 2010. Ugly.
Wild-card: Tennessee Titans
Jake Locker is the future, except that he's played for the most part like the quarterback with major accuracy questions the Titans drafted out of Washington in 2011. In a make-or-break year for the coaching staff, all options could be on the table.
Why not the New York Jets?
Sure, the Jets seem like a logical destination for a QB upgrade. That's before you look at the books, however. Unless they can extricate themselves of Mark Sanchez (and the phone isn't ringing), Smith and Sanchez would combine for a cap hit of over $20 million in 2013, more than Peyton Manning.
Alex Smith is no guarantee. He was leading maybe the best-assembled overall roster in the NFL, a team that could defend and run the ball effectively, alleviating the pressure on whoever takes the snaps for Jim Harbaugh. But even if he's considered a Harbaugh creation, he's one the Niners will be looking to move. And the teams above could have interest.