Which Qb Is Going To Put Up Better Numbers? - Topic

Member

Posts: 14,670

Joined: Feb 23 2007

Gold: 0.00

Aug 18 2013 09:07pm

Quote (xnozx. @ Aug 18 2013 09:51pm)

It's not a fair comparison because of the offensive systems both teams run.

It's apples and oranges.

Eli is a top 5 QB but that has nothing to do with his stats. Our offense isn't designed for QB's to have "sexy" numbers.

so what youre saying is you cant say eli is better then vick because different systems

This post was edited by JVT51091 on Aug 18 2013 09:07pm

jadeoshbogosh

Member

Posts: 66,871

Joined: Feb 24 2009

Gold: 250.00

Warn: 10%

#22

Aug 18 2013 09:08pm

Quote (xnozx. @ Aug 18 2013 07:04pm)

Lol, another example of an asinine statement.

Give Eli Brady's O-line and see how good Eli's numbers would be.

Luck does fine with a complete shit o-line, I'm pretty sure Brees does alright as well. Could you explain to me why Eli can't perform better?

Quote (xnozx. @ Aug 18 2013 06:51pm)

It's not a fair comparison because of the offensive systems both teams run.

It's apples and oranges.

Eli is a top 5 QBbut that has nothing to do with his stats. Our offense isn't designed for QB's to have "sexy" numbers.

I mean come on now noz.... you can't seriously think that. He's not a bad QB but being decent doesn't make you top 5 lol.

This post was edited by jadeoshbogosh on Aug 18 2013 09:10pm

ShowCase

Member

Posts: 15,839

Joined: Jul 27 2009

Gold: 805.00

#23

Aug 18 2013 09:09pm

Quote (xnozx. @ Aug 18 2013 11:04pm)

Lol, another example of an asinine statement.

so you're saying if drew brees was the giants' QB his numbers wouldn't look as impressive?

xnozx.

Member

Posts: 59,137

Joined: Jan 19 2005

Gold: 26.51

Warn: 10%

#24

Aug 18 2013 09:10pm

Quote (JVT51091 @ Aug 18 2013 11:07pm)

so what youre saying is you cant say eli is better then vick because different systems

Vick?

jadeoshbogosh

Member

Posts: 66,871

Joined: Feb 24 2009

Gold: 250.00

Warn: 10%

#25

Aug 18 2013 09:11pm

Quote (JVT51091 @ Aug 18 2013 07:07pm)

so what youre saying is you cant say eli is better then vick because different systems

Well na it doesn't work with Vick. You could say Tebow and Eli are the same skill level, just different systems though.

xnozx.

Member

Posts: 59,137

Joined: Jan 19 2005

Gold: 26.51

Warn: 10%

#26

Aug 18 2013 09:11pm

Quote (jadeoshbogosh @ Aug 18 2013 11:08pm)

Luck does fine with a complete shit o-line, I'm pretty sure Brees does alright as well. Could you explain to me why Eli can't perform better?

Brees has had one of the best O-line's in the league for yearsss.

What?

Markelle

Member

Posts: 31,848

Joined: Jun 6 2010

Gold: 2,227.27

#27

Aug 18 2013 09:12pm

Tony Romo's stats blow Eli's stats out of the water
What makes you think Eli will have a chance with Brady lol?

HugeGirth

Member

Posts: 23,226

Joined: Mar 5 2010

Gold: 0.00

Warn: 10%

#28

Aug 18 2013 09:13pm

Quote (Nerlens @ Aug 18 2013 11:12pm)

Tony Romo's stats blow Eli's stats out of the water
What makes you think Eli will have a chance with Brady lol?

OP is a pats fan, this was probably a feel-good thread.

DyNaMiCz

Member

Posts: 18,058

Joined: Jul 16 2007

Gold: Locked

#29

Aug 18 2013 09:14pm

Quote (Terps @ Aug 18 2013 11:13pm)

OP is a pats fan, this was probably a feel-good thread.

big homer

xnozx.

Member

Posts: 59,137

Joined: Jan 19 2005

Gold: 26.51

Warn: 10%

#30

Aug 18 2013 09:14pm

Quote (casedizzle45 @ Aug 18 2013 11:09pm)

so you're saying if drew brees was the giants' QB his numbers wouldn't look as impressive?

No.

He wouldn't have NEARLY as many attempts as he gets with Sean Payton.

Name me a RB the past few seasons we've had that was a good receiver... I'll wait.

Name me a TE we've had the past few seasons that was heavily involved in the passing game?... once again I'll wait.

Go Back To Football & Rugby Topic List