Quote (PittaGod @ Sep 2 2015 02:31pm)
I think they do a good job analyzing public perception. However, some of his information about our roster is noticeably off...
I think he is mostly overlooked because he doesn't put up gaudy stats, which then leaves him ignored in the minds of people who only play fantasy to learn about other teams. If he played in an imbalanced pass-heavy offense like the one Matt Ryan, Brees, or Romo (up until last year) played in, he would have better #'s, be fantasy relevant, and receive more acclaim.
He isn't elite though for all of the reasons Eli isn't elite. Joe will win some games and get hot, but he'll also have an occasional game where he can't do shit for some reason. With elite QBs like younger Peyton and Rodgers, you expected even their off-games to be at least average. Elite QBs raise the talent of those around them. If we win games this year despite a mediocre receiving corps, then It'll help Joe's reputation in my eyes.
I will say that Roethlisberger didn't become one of the elites until he entered his 30s. Kind of like pitchers in baseball, QBs don't really hit the peak of their prime until late 20s/early-mid 30s. It's not too late for Joe to enter the elite conversation, although giving him scrubs like Aiken and Marlon as his #2 WR is going to hurt his chances. Wouldn't be surprised if we draft another first round WR next year.