d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Football & Rugby > Official Insider Request Thread
Prev191011121325Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 55,838
Joined: Aug 7 2007
Gold: 6,313.21
Oct 4 2012 10:24am
Quote (vHero @ Oct 4 2012 06:49am)


Bad link, think this is what you're looking for.

Quote
The discussion: Is Geno Smith capable of being this year's Robert Griffin III?
Todd McShay: Based on his potential to (A) have a Heisman-caliber season and (B) rise to the top of NFL draft boards, Geno Smith does look like he could be this season's Robert Griffin III. In fact, after seeing his performance against Baylor on Saturday, I am moving Smith ahead of Matt Barkley to make him the No. 1 quarterback in my Top 32 draft rankings this week.

When it comes to his draft status, obviously, it's a very fluid situation. It's only the start of October, after all. But I think Smith has the potential to be a top-5 pick and possibly the first quarterback taken in next April's draft.


The biggest issue I had with Smith coming into the season was his tendency to be a fastball thrower at times and not put proper touch on his throws, and he's clearly improved in that area. His accuracy, anticipation and touch have been outstanding in 2012. If his accuracy remains this good, what is missing from his game that Barkley can offer? Both are film junkies with strong work habits and high football IQs, but Smith has a stronger arm and eludes rushers more frequently in the pocket.

This isn't a huge surprise, seeing as how we had Smith rated as the No. 3 quarterback prospect coming into the season (behind Barkley and Virginia Tech's Logan Thomas), good enough to earn a late-first-round grade. But his performance to start the year obviously has played a big role in his rise.

What he did against Baylor was absolutely phenomenal. It was the equivalent of a pitcher throwing a no-hitter. The vast majority of his throws were placed perfectly, and it's not as though he was only throwing bubble screens and quick slants. A lot of those throws were 20 or more yards down the field.

It is important to keep that performance in perspective, becaus***lor's defense is notorious for making QBs look better than they actually are. But make no mistake, Smith is good enough to play at a high level against any defense he faces. If you want proof, just pop in the tape of his performance against LSU last year. Playing against an elite defense, he withstood several hits, made quick decisions and completed a lot of tough throws.

It's going to be really fun to watch how he handles the pressure the rest of the way, against competition that is going to be a lot tougher. He is now officially the "it" player in college football, and the Mountaineers will only go as far as he carries them. Among BCS title contenders, the Mountaineers are the most one-dimensional team. The defense is simply not a good group, and the running game doesn't offer the passing attack any support. WVU is a three-man show -- Smith, Stedman Bailey and Tavon Austin -- and Smith is the star.

Even if his stats come back down to Earth a little bit and WVU loses a couple of games, I expect Smith to continue to play at a very high level.

[+] Enlarge
AP Photo/Christopher Jackson
Tavon Austin has been a tough cover for every defense thus far.
Mel Kiper: It has been something of a perfect storm so far this season for Smith. For one, his numbers are flat-out absurd. I'd say they are video game-worthy, but I don't think video games could be this easy. After Saturday's thrashing of Baylor and its invisible secondary, Smith now has 1,728 passing yards, 20 TD passes against no interceptions, all while completing 83.4 percent of his throws. Smith has done his part. Meanwhile, so has everybody else.

Barkley had one really rough game; Tyler Wilson got hurt and lost the significant presence of Bobby Petrino calling plays; Mike Glennon got off to a bad start; Thomas has really struggled this year and looks like a guy putting too much pressure on himself. EJ Manuel has been pretty good, but the competition among top QB prospects has been limited. A class I saw as really deep has been a disappointment thus far. But it's early, which is why I'd put at least an ounce of caution on Smith.

Over the next eight games he'll see Texas, Texas Tech, Kansas State, TCU, Oklahoma State, Oklahoma, Iowa State and Kansas. Every single defense he'll face over the remaining eight games is better than any defense he has played thus far. I think he'll still put up solid totals, but it's fair to say this is the stretch that will better define him as a prospect. As far as the comparisons to RG3, they could only be made in regard to his chance to rise on the board. Smith is a true pocket passer, who can move well but doesn't rely so much on speed or athleticism. He's highly intelligent, reads the game well and is always prepared. His accuracy is very good, and I'd put particular emphasis on great ball placement. He doesn't just hit the frame -- he gets it to guys in exactly the right spot, allowing them to make plays after the catch.

Could he be RG3, a potential top-five pick?

Sure, but it wouldn't be a huge surprise. As a prospect, Smith has been ranked among the top QBs in his class for three years. I've had him right on the edge of the Big Board, where he'll debut this week. RG3 did some major work in terms of mechanics to improve his accuracy and draft stock, but Smith is just rounding into great form, executing at the highest level he has yet in his career. I wouldn't be at all surprised if he's at the top of some boards when it's all said and done. He can become a great one, but it won't be because he sneaked up on anybody.

Stock rising
Kiper: Alec Ogletree, ILB, Georgia Bulldogs
I had waited to move him up in my rankings before I got to see his form in 2012, but Ogletree showed he's got significant skills once again on Saturday against Tennessee, his first game coming back from suspension. He had 14 tackles, broke up three passes and showed his versatility. He flies into gaps and can be a good stopper against the run, but shows particularly good skills in coverage, where he can turn his hips and run with pretty much anybody. A hitter, he can be disruptive in multiple areas, and flat-out closes on the ball. Linebackers like Darryl Washington with Arizona show these kinds of skills, and they become really valuable in a passing league.

Ogletree, a basketball player and track star in high school, is just a naturally gifted athlete. Expect to see him ranked on my board as the second-best interior linebacker in the draft, behind only Notre Dame's Manti Te'o.

[+] Enlarge
Joshua S. Kelly/US PRESSWIRE
Don't forget about Dre ... er, Andre Ellington.
McShay: DeAndre Hopkins, WR, and Andre Ellington, RB, Clemson Tigers
Mel must be spying on my house or something, because he keeps picking the players I've selected for this category, but I definitely agree on Ogletree. He showed good instincts and sideline-to-sideline range against Tennessee, and I think he could wind up as a top-15 pick if he continues to improve.

I'll give you two other players who have helped their draft stock: Clemson teammates Hopkins and Ellington. Hopkins has really asserted himself in games when Sammy Watkins has been out, and Ellington has been running with better balance and pad level all season long. The NFL really values speed in its running backs, and Ellington's ability to also provide big plays in the passing game boosts his stock. He's the third-rated back on our board right now, behind only Marcus Lattimore and Le'Veon Bell.

Almost famous
McShay: Ezekiel Ansah, DE, Brigham Young Cougars
A native of Ghana who hadn't even seen a football game on TV prior to coming to the U.S., Ansah has made huge strides in the past six months. He has cracked the starting lineup and is an impact player on a very good Cougars defense, playing nose tackle, 5-technique defensive end and outside linebacker. In BYU's blowout win over Hawaii on Friday night, Ansah had five tackles, one TFL, one QB hit and a pass breakup.

Ansah is still very raw. He plays high and needs a lot of work with his hands. But he's drawing NFL interest because of his rare combination of size, speed and natural athleticism (he's 6-foot-6, 270 pounds, and reportedly ran a sub-22-second 200-meter dash during his BYU track days). He flashes a quick first step, explosive initial pop and very rare closing burst for his size.

Kiper: Tyrone Goard, WR, Eastern Kentucky Colonels
At 6-4, Goard uses his height effectively against smaller corners he sees each week, but he's not just a go-up-and-get-it receiver. He creates big plays with his legs as well, and this week had TD catches of 78, 27, 25 and 14 yards. Goard is slender, at just under 200 pounds, but uses very good body control with the ball in the air, and gets himself in a great position to snatch the ball with his hands, away from his body. You won't get to see him much on TV, if at all, but Goard can play and will crack an NFL roster next season.

A question for next week
[+] Enlarge
Brendan Maloney/US Presswire
Carrington Byndom is one of several NFL prospects in the UT secondary.

Kiper: Can the West Virginia wide receivers break free against Texas?

Not only must Austin, Bailey and J.D. Woods find space in a very good Texas secondary, they'll need to do it early as Smith will face a legitimate pass rush for the first time this season on Saturday in Austin. The Longhorns will bring Jackson Jeffcoat and Alex Okafor off the edges, and with major prospects Kenny Vaccaro, Quandre Diggs and Carrington Byndom roaming the Texas secondary, Smith will have to exercise a little more caution than he's had to thus far.


McShay: Will LSU 'flip the switch' against Florida?

There are some questions being asked about the Tigers after they barely beat Auburn two weeks ago and had trouble separating from Towson (in a night game in Baton Rouge, no less) on Saturday.

This week, against the Gators, we should get a better idea of just how good this team is. Talent-wise, LSU has Florida beat, but while I think the Tigers' defensive line is the best in the nation, there isn't another aspect of this team that is excellent. The linebackers are average and they're still working out some kinks in the secondary. On offense, the passing game isn't close to where it needs to be, and the loss of tackle Chris Faulk for the season could be really tough to overcome.

Don't get me wrong, this is still a very talented team, but we'll know more after the Florida game about whether the Tigers are a legitimate national title contender, or "just" a really good team that falls short of the elite level of last year's unit.
Member
Posts: 40,861
Joined: Sep 18 2008
Gold: 90.00
Oct 5 2012 10:58am
Member
Posts: 55,838
Joined: Aug 7 2007
Gold: 6,313.21
Oct 5 2012 04:36pm
Quote (draino @ Oct 5 2012 12:58pm)
dissed


Never even saw it.


Todd McShay, Steve Muench and Kevin Weidl of Scouts Inc. provide their scouting report for the matchup between the West Virginia Mountaineers and the Texas Longhorns, looking at how each team's offensive and defensive units will fare and predicting the final score.

West Virginia offense versus Texas defense
• QB Geno Smith is dissecting defenses with a rare blend of timing, accuracy and decision-making. He is taking what the coverage is giving him and spreading the ball around, with WRs Tavon Austin and Stedman Bailey leading the way. While Texas is the toughest defensive challenge the Mountaineers' passing attack has faced this year, both receivers are capable of giving the Longhorns problems. Austin has the awareness to find pockets in the Longhorns' zone looks, and possesses the burst to separate when Texas tries to match up in man.

Meanwhile, Bailey facing off against cornerback Quandre Diggs on the outside is one of many matchups to keep an eye on. Diggs has the natural ability to get the better of Bailey, but double moves have given him problems in the past and the Mountaineers could test him. Plus, Bailey runs well and does a good job of selling the stop-and-go route.

In addition, Texas has played a soft zone, with Diggs giving receivers a healthy cushion. If that happens, Smith can get the ball to one of his receivers underneath, forcing the corner to make a one-on-one play. Regardless of who gets the ball, it's critical that Texas' defense -- which has suffered from sloppy tackling -- cleans up its mistakes and limits production after the catch.

• With Smith playing at a high level and the Mountaineers enjoying some favorable matchups, Texas can't let him get comfortable. Luckily for Texas, they have a decided advantage up front, especially on the edge. OLBs/DEs Jackson Jeffcoat and Alex Okafor are effective pass-rushers, though they do it in different ways; Jeffcoat is a speed-rusher, while Okafor relies on power.

Texas defensive coordinator Manny Diaz also will blitz at times, but it's important that he choose his spots well. Smith is finding his hot read before the pressure has time to get to him, and the Mountaineers' screen package is much more dangerous when the defense gets caught blitzing.

In addition, three- and four-man rushes aren't a lock to give the Mountaineers problems despite Texas' advantages up front. Smith is capable of extending plays with his feet, and West Virginia runs a lot of six-man protections that include a back for support. Shawne Alston, Ryan Clarke and Cody Clay are all big enough to anchor in pass protection. If Alston (thigh) and Clarke (leg) are unable to play because of injuries, Clay can help protect the edge.

• The Mountaineers are at an even greater disadvantage up front when it comes to the ground game. They are allowing too much leakage and there's no reason to believe that will change considering this is the best defensive front they've faced this year. With the Longhorns winning up front, an aggressive Texas linebacker corps is capable of slowing West Virginia RBs Andrew Buie and Alston, if he can return from his thigh injury.

Though the Mountaineers will have a tough time picking up yards on the ground with any kind of consistency, the potential for long runs is there. Misdirection has given Texas some problems and, again, tackling has been an issue. Plus, West Virginia gets its wide receivers involved in the ground game and motions them into the backfield to use them as decoys or hand them the ball.

Texas offense versus West Virginia defense
• West Virginia is holding teams to fewer than three yards per carry and its aggressive 3-4 scheme could give Texas' front some problems. The Mountaineers have good size up front and the three down linemen are tough to move off the ball in one-on-one situations. They will line up over the heads of center Dominic Espinosa and both tackles, making it tough to double-team them.

At the second level, West Virginia's linebackers are aggressive and fly to the ball. Plus, defensive coordinator Joe DeForest will bring pressure from different areas of the field, including the third level. DeForest's aggressive approach, combined with good defensive speed, can lead to breakdowns in blocking assignments.

• That doesn't mean the Longhorns won't have success establishing the run. Offensive coordinator Byran Harsin can use formations, blocking schemes and misdirection to amplify Texas' strengths while exploiting West Virginia's vulnerabilities. He can pack the Mountaineers in with two-TE sets, and then run power to the outside with the frontside tackle and Espinosa leading the way. Pulling the offensive linemen matches them up against the Mountaineers' undersized outside linebackers, and allows the frontside tight end to block down on the defensive end. Plus, Harsin can use spread sets to thin out how many defenders line up in the box when he runs inside.

The Longhorns will be without out their most talented running back Malcolm Brown, who will miss this game with an ankle injury. While he'll be missed, Texas has the depth and talent at the position to overcome his absence. Big running back Joe Bergeron has the power to produce between the tackles and enough lateral bounce to get outside or cut back when the defense gets sucked up inside. Talented true freshman RB Johnathan Gray isn't as big or strong as Brown and Bergeron, but he shows good balance when he runs inside and he's quicker around the corner than Bergeron. The Longhorns have increased his carries in each of the first four games, so look for him to play a bigger role with Brown out.

West Virginia also has to respect the jet sweep when WRs Marquise Goodwin or D.J. Monroe motion into the backfield -- and the threat of QB David Ash keeping the ball off the read option. Both receivers have the speed to go the distance. And though he's not nearly as explosive, Ash has enough burst to make defenses pay when they don't account for him.

• Ash should get some chances to strike deep against a reeling West Virginia secondary that has been hurt by broken coverage. Plus, he has the weapons such as WR Mike Davis to take advantage.

Ash's ability to deliver in these situations is a concern. Smith is the only FBS quarterback that has been more efficient throwing the ball than Ash, who has made considerable strides this year. However, Ash has underthrown his receivers and forced them to make tough adjustments. While they've bailed him out for the most part, he can't continue to throw the ball up for grabs in a game that is shaping up to be a shootout.

Ash should be successful finding WR Jaxon Shipley underneath when the Mountaineers play Cover 3, and should find his backs and tight ends off of play-action based on what West Virginia's defense has shown on film.

Scouts' Edge
The precision and poise Smith displays in operating Dana Holgorson's spread offense makes it tough to defend against West Virginia. However, Smith and his talented receivers should come up short. Texas not only has the athletes along the defensive front to negate the run and harass Smith more than any other defense has this year, but it also has the offense capable of sustaining long drives and limiting Smith's opportunities by keeping him on the sidelines.

Texas' ground game will keep Ash out of obvious passing situations and allow the Longhorns to sustain long scoring drives that give them a substantial edge in time of possession. In addition, Ash is playing with a great deal of confidence -- as he should be after his performance last week. He continues to take care of the football and extend drives with his feet when nothing is available downfield.

Prediction: Longhorns 38, Mountaineers 34
Member
Posts: 40,861
Joined: Sep 18 2008
Gold: 90.00
Oct 5 2012 04:42pm
thx
Member
Posts: 55,838
Joined: Aug 7 2007
Gold: 6,313.21
Oct 9 2012 12:12pm
Up.
Member
Posts: 55,838
Joined: Aug 7 2007
Gold: 6,313.21
Oct 11 2012 05:38am
Up.
Member
Posts: 55,838
Joined: Aug 7 2007
Gold: 6,313.21
Oct 13 2012 08:47am
A girl who looks quiet but plays when she plays
A girl who puts her hair down when the right time comes
A girl who covers herself but is more sexy than a girl who bares it all
A sensable girl like that
Member
Posts: 55,838
Joined: Aug 7 2007
Gold: 6,313.21
Oct 18 2012 06:25am
The bees had declared a war,
The sky wasn't big enough for them all.
The birds, they got help from below,
From dirty paws and the creatures of snow.
Member
Posts: 7,104
Joined: Apr 25 2011
Gold: 20.00
Oct 18 2012 08:40am
What lyrics are those?
Go Back To Football & Rugby Topic List
Prev191011121325Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll