d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Football & Rugby > 2013 Nfl Draft Quarterback Rankings
Prev123Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 4,663
Joined: Dec 3 2006
Gold: 16,602.98
Feb 11 2013 05:27pm
Aside from Jones #1 I can't really disagree because 3-8 are more based on offensive system/gameplan than the actual talent level of the QB(Barkley and the WCO being the most obvious fit). Geno Smith and Tyler Wilson are the clear-cut top-2 for me, though Wilson's small hands and concussion history are quite concerning.
Nassib doesn't really lack elite arm strength, his deep ball is just terribly inaccurate. Certainly alot of intrigue around him considering he was a 2 star recruit out of HS.
Manuel's mechanics are terrible as well.
Member
Posts: 51,331
Joined: Feb 18 2007
Gold: 0.27
Feb 11 2013 05:35pm
Quote (sryan66611 @ Feb 11 2013 03:14pm)
Jones looked absolutely fucking turrrible at the senior bowl.  Dunno why you have him first but cool to see your opinion so if AZ had to take a QB you would select Jones over all te others?


If AZ were to take a QB, I'd want Manuel > Jones > Wilson > Glennon > Scott
Member
Posts: 31,164
Joined: Sep 5 2007
Gold: 775.01
Warn: 10%
Feb 11 2013 05:42pm
Did you know Dysert's Receivers dropped 12 passes in just the vs Ohio State game, alone. 12 dropped passes in one game. That was just a lead up to how shitty his Receivers were all season. The guy had absolute shit around him. It's hard to make shit better. I understand the QB is suppose to try and make his teammates better, but there's a fine line there.
Member
Posts: 51,331
Joined: Feb 18 2007
Gold: 0.27
Feb 11 2013 05:49pm
Quote (Hako @ Feb 11 2013 04:42pm)
Did you know Dysert's Receivers dropped 12 passes in just the vs Ohio State game, alone. 12 dropped passes in one game. That was just a lead up to how shitty his Receivers were all season. The guy had absolute shit around him. It's hard to make shit better. I understand the QB is suppose to try and make his teammates better, but there's a fine line there.


Hey, I know you have a boner for him and all like I have a boner for Landry (although I don't like him much for the Cards lol) but hey, I said he didn't have shit around him and he could excel, just needs to be thrown into the right situation lol.

He's not going to go make Braylon Edwards a Pro Bowler again if the Jets take him, but he could do well on any team that already has an established set of receivers with the right coach.
Member
Posts: 23,226
Joined: Mar 5 2010
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 10%
Feb 11 2013 06:07pm
Quote (Randolph @ Feb 11 2013 06:35pm)
If AZ were to take a QB, I'd want Manuel > Jones > Wilson > Glennon > Scott


Why are you so big on Manuel? He has some pretty awesome games, but he also had some pretty shitty games against bad teams. He just seems too sloppy and inconsistent. Plus I think he benefited from a pretty great O-line, which gave him extra time to pull off some of those big running plays he had.
I mean, I'd like to homer my ACC players, but he just seems too inconsistent to me. He's like a sloppy Geno Smith lol...

Speaking of which, whoever drafts Geno should draft Austin at wr
Member
Posts: 31,164
Joined: Sep 5 2007
Gold: 775.01
Warn: 10%
Feb 11 2013 06:11pm
Quote (Randolph @ Feb 11 2013 03:49pm)
Hey, I know you have a boner for him and all like I have a boner for Landry (although I don't like him much for the Cards lol) but hey, I said he didn't have shit around him and he could excel, just needs to be thrown into the right situation lol.

He's not going to go make Braylon Edwards a Pro Bowler again if the Jets take him, but he could do well on any team that already has an established set of receivers with the right coach.


I don't have a boner for him lol. He's just the best QB in a terrible QB class. He's raw and needs some time. If he gets drafted and thrown straight to the wolves, he could have a rough time. But if he goes in the mid-late rounds, is able to sit for a couple years, then his ceiling is right up there towards the top.
Member
Posts: 10,633
Joined: Jun 18 2012
Gold: 1,120.01
Feb 11 2013 06:30pm
Quote (InuDan @ Feb 11 2013 07:11pm)
Way off base on Barkley and Jones, imo.


Don't think he's the best as of right now (Jones) but I believe he will be the best QB out of the class in the NFL.
Member
Posts: 46,807
Joined: Apr 26 2006
Gold: 84.01
Feb 11 2013 06:41pm
Go ACC.
Member
Posts: 37,825
Joined: Jun 22 2008
Gold: 0.00
Feb 11 2013 06:43pm
our QB coach and GM really like matt scott so i wouldnt be surprised if they take him in the late rounds
Member
Posts: 51,331
Joined: Feb 18 2007
Gold: 0.27
Feb 11 2013 07:02pm
Quote (Terps @ Feb 11 2013 05:07pm)
Why are you so big on Manuel? He has some pretty awesome games, but he also had some pretty shitty games against bad teams. He just seems too sloppy and inconsistent. Plus I think he benefited from a pretty great O-line, which gave him extra time to pull off some of those big running plays he had.
I mean, I'd like to homer my ACC players, but he just seems too inconsistent to me. He's like a sloppy Geno Smith lol...

Speaking of which, whoever drafts Geno should draft Austin at wr


He fits Arians' system very well and everything I've heard from/about Araians and pretty much everyone on his staff, I have the most absolute faith that they could mold him into something special.
Go Back To Football & Rugby Topic List
Prev123Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll