I mean according to PFR's HoF Monitor he's right smack dab on the borderline



(Bolded names indicate players currently inducted into the Hall)

Don't think he deserves first ballot personally, but to argue he's objectively not HoF quality seems a bit absurd.

I'm sorry, who are you?

Not an exact metric since it has "average HoF QB" at 108 and Mahomes at 100.75, when we all would agree Mahomes is an instant, certified, guaranteed lock at 1st ballot HoF.

The top-heavy nature of the list is naturally going to bring that average up quite a bit, it'll be even worse once Brady gets inducted.

It's not an exact metric though you're right, just something I thought might help visualize his place among the all-time greats at the position.

Mahomes is obviously a first-ballot lock, and I'd wager that by the end of his career he'll be up there somewhere in the 200+ point range along with Brady, Manning (the good one), and Rodgers. Possibly even on the very top of it.

This post was edited by Diablo2Enjoyer on Feb 5 2025 07:04pm

Voted yes, only because him beating Brady twice in the owl

Maybe I'm biased for how bad he was at the end of his career. Can't argue with numbers

he will make it,

won SB twice. and he was a tough player/competitor who had an impressive consecutive starts streak