I am in a keeper league with some buddies and I have the first pick.

Only top RBs on the board are CMC, Henry, Dalvin. Then I think Mixon, Kamara, Saquon and so forth.

With the 1st pick who would you or wouldnt you pick. Why or why not. Really torn from this decision.

This post was edited by LongClip on Sep 4 2022 02:56pm

Is it ppr? Cmc has the highest ceiling but injury prone. Henry is the safe choice imo, he did get hurt last year but would be my choice unless it's full ppr and then I may gamble with cmc.

Is it ppr?
If so, CMC and it's not close.

If not, I still go CMC. I know he has an injury history, but he has the highest ceiling and the highest floor/when healthy.

Henry likely going to be carrying the load of the season for the Titans. He could be the the fantasy mvp this season, but high risk moving forward. His usage rate is crazy plus a foot injury to a big body man is scary.

Dalvin would be my 3rd choice. Vikings installing a new offense so not quite sure what we're going to get from him in the passing game. Plus addition of rheagor to JJ and theilen. Hard to tell what's going to happen here. Does have some years left though.

Would not spend #1 on the following:

Mixon 4. Improved Oline. All assumptions will be its a pass first offense, but should see very favorable boxes. He's good out of the backfield too although not always utilized there.

Quon 5. This is only because he COULD STILL be a dynasty assett. He's been labeled an injury concern but really his 2 Major injures were kinda freak-like. He was an absolute star at PSU and shown flashes that he CAN be a star in the NFL. The giants are bad though.

Kamara - avoiding at all costs. We dont know when a suspension will happen. Ideally wouldn't happen during the fantasy playoffs but that would be a massive blow. Under a new offensive scheme, where presumably Jameis will actually be there, Im concerned about his usage rates in the passing game. Mt should be returning, plus the addition of Olave, could leave Kamara in a better situation but it's so unknown whats going to happen. From a dynasty standpoint, kamara is on the wrong side of father time, and although his carries are super low for his age, his targets and touches are high.

Good luck man. I took 2nd to last in 1 league 2nd in my other last year. Who tf knows what's going to happen.

PPR, even half point I got CMC without a doubt.

If no PPR and 4 per TD I consider CMC or Henry

No PPR and 6pt For TD I go Henry. I get the Injury Risk, but I still think hes a beast

half point ppr

Good info guys. CMC or Henry it is. Will be hard to decide. I took CMC last year and regretted it. Hard to move on from that.

This post was edited by LongClip on Sep 4 2022 04:33pm

The answer should be cmc. If you took Henry last year, you also would have regretted it

This post was edited by Randscend on Sep 5 2022 12:34am

cd, still love cmc over henry this year

Went with CMC . Thanks guys!

kick

Watch the cmc injury happen Week 1 haha