Quote (Secksii @ Mar 2 2023 04:22pm)
Nah, I agree. This trade makes no sense at all. I don't care about the price being paid. Just don't think he's the type of player that the Canucks need or someone that would elevate this team to the next level.
Yzerman sees the east going ham, and there's no chance they'll win anything even if they made playoffs. Seider is his guy and their main guy. Hronek is basically how Hughes is being used in Detroit, plays a lot of minutes but they both play much better when another pair like oel/seider takes on the shit minutes so that Hughes and Hronek can do their thing. So Yzerman sold high on one of his top 4 dman, and now have a chance to become contenders in few years assuming the picks aren't busts.
Meanwhile, the Canucks are worse than Detroit before the trades and chose to retool by getting a solid top 4 rhd. What I don't understand is the timing of this trade.. And the type of player they chose. The Canucks have had a lot of ofd forced to play defensive minutes cuz Hughes eats a huge chunk of pp1. Before Hughes, Myers was sadly the Canucks main "ofd" cuz edler was basically an all around dman. Then oel was also an ofd, now forced to be all around guy like edler. Like I'd be less shocked if the Canucks gave a 2nd and 3rd or something for McCabe retained at 50% to lock him up for only 2m. Who is elite defensively, pk God, basically hits all the boxes the Canucks desperately need. Yet they get another poor man Hughes on the right side... So all I can do is pray oel and Hronek mesh really well together.
This is 100%. Can debate on how good Hronek will be but why pay a trade deadline premium?
I feel Hronek is the kind of d-man the Canucks need but am worried about his contract and how well he will fit in. He is in the right age range, right hand shot and so forth. It is an immediate upgrade for a team with trash tier defense.
Hughes is the only threatening offensive d-man the Canucks have. Giving ourselves another option is going to open things up a bit. Changes the matchup dynamics.
The Major problem is the Canucks need that impact shutdown d-man. They just come at such a high premium so it is probably out of reach. Willie Mitchell would score 1 goal a year and everyone wanted him.
I feel like they overpaid but got a piece they really needed, so right now I am torn but trying to be optimistic. We won't know who won this trade for awhile but it seems like Yzerman does not lose many trades.
Think you are right. He saw the arms race getting out of control and wisely took a step back.
This post was edited by Killingyouall on Mar 3 2023 08:46pm